Bad Rep thread??

mycustomcues

know the game!!!
Silver Member
besides the buyer and seller thread that is always on top, dont you guys think that we need a BAD rep thread???


You know, just to give warnings to our fellow azer if they would like to do any transaction to any member?? Just to keep it safe??


Its kinda tough to dig on all that pages of buyer/seller report you know!


In this case we are going to be able to keep on track with members with bad reps.



M
 
We need a bad rep baseball bat IMO. I'm still trying to collect over $1,100 from one of our own . . .

BTW, you can use the "search this thread" option for a person's name in the buyer/seller transaction report that you mentioned.
Mr H
 
Wow

That's funny! I would not expect it from you!


I still could not believe that this jack a$$ members have gotten away with their crap with all the nice members all this time. Weird part is they are still doing some transactions with other members.

Why cant everybody be like Vinniebabrooch or Mr. Bama or some other guys that are top notch and class act.


Seriously though, We need to do something about this guys who does bad transactions here on aZ!


I just read two bad transaction just this week.


:mad: :mad: :mad: :mad:
 
Last edited:
the real problem isn't the lack of tools, it is more to do with being reluctant to post negative remarks about people. Most people will say nothing at all, instead of saying something negative. The only exception to that imho is when you are blatantly ripped off.

not to mention when you say something negative you often get turned into the bad guy in this forum.
 
Last edited:
mycustomcues said:
besides the buyer and seller thread that is always on top, dont you guys think that we need a BAD rep thread???


You know, just to give warnings to our fellow azer if they would like to do any transaction to any member?? Just to keep it safe??


Its kinda tough to dig on all that pages of buyer/seller report you know!


In this case we are going to be able to keep on track with members with bad reps.



M
Just click on the iTrader,thats what its for,its like Ebay in a way with feedback for you to read. ;)
 
Good Idea

It seems that when there is a bad transaction between members, it does get posted quickly.

Usually in the, " For Sale Section ".

Many members chime in and sometime the deals work out for everybody involved.

I do think that pressure from our, " AZ Family Members ", does have a positive effect in helping to resolve some of these situations, so that's a good thing.

I think a separate section addressing this problem (Deals gone Bad :mad: ), would be an asset to this site.

Something more for Mr. Wilson to monitor nightly, some of our guy's can get pretty heavy :rolleyes: , but still it would be useful.
 
Fast Lenny said:
Just click on the iTrader,thats what its for,its like Ebay in a way with feedback for you to read. ;)

The I-trader is meaningless, and so are the Green Squares!!!!;) There have been threads on this subject also, and it is well known that people buy Rep, and I-trader ratings. While many feel this is harmless, it certainly ruins the systems put in place to identify bad transactions by sellers and buyers. Along with this is the needless hype that and unrealistic cue reviews people do as part of this hype, and as part as helping a buddy out!!;)

So maybe all the rating currently given should be wiped clean, and just maybe things should be started from scratch and policed this time. Maybe all transactions can be passed through one individual who will post them for everyone. Because the current system is broken, falsified, and it clearly is not a true reflection of anyones creditability as it is~;)

Just my opinion!!!!!!:)
 
manwon said:
The I-trader is meaningless, and so are the Green Squares!!!!;) There have been threads on this subject also, and it is well known that people buy Rep, and I-trader ratings. While many feel this is harmless, it certainly ruins the systems put in place to identify bad transactions by sellers and buyers. Along with this is the needless hype that and unrealistic cue reviews people do as part of this hype, and as part as helping a buddy out!!;)

So maybe all the rating currently given should be wiped clean, and just maybe things should be started from scratch and policed this time. Maybe all transactions can be passed through one individual who will post them for everyone. Because the current system is broken, falsified, and it clearly is not a true reflection of anyones creditability as it is~;)

Just my opinion!!!!!!:)
Well anyone I do business with I go through there past post,and do some detective work to see what they have sold in the classifieds and look through the iTrader.If they have bought and sold with some respected members I feel ok,I have dodged a bullet or two on here luckily.I agree the rep is meaningless as for using it as determining whether someone is good business wise or not but the iTrader,feedback sticky,and searching the persons post to see what they have bought and sold has worked well with me and I have over 30 transactions easily on here with no problems thankfully. :)
 
manwon said:
The I-trader is meaningless, and so are the Green Squares!!!!;) There have been threads on this subject also, and it is well known that people buy Rep, and I-trader ratings. While many feel this is harmless, it certainly ruins the systems put in place to identify bad transactions by sellers and buyers. Along with this is the needless hype that and unrealistic cue reviews people do as part of this hype, and as part as helping a buddy out!!;)

So maybe all the rating currently given should be wiped clean, and just maybe things should be started from scratch and policed this time. Maybe all transactions can be passed through one individual who will post them for everyone. Because the current system is broken, falsified, and it clearly is not a true reflection of anyones creditability as it is~;)

Just my opinion!!!!!!:)


I disagree.. I don't think the itrader is worthless once you get above 10 or 20.. You can insert the link along with the negative or positive to show proof of a deal. It shows how you have done business up to that point. and who pays for itrader? How stupid that would be..

I don't think we need to change our system.. I think we need to change how the people who rip people off are handled.. Screw someone once, Depending on the situation, and it's a warning.. Do it twice and it's a month vacation.. Do it three times and your banned..

Make new members submit some information that would prove what name they sign up under.. Would help stop the ones coming back under a new name. You know the ones who rip someone off, Get banned, Then sign up again.. eBay makes you sign up using a credit card as proof of who you are if you want to sell items..

I know it will never happen but a decent idea I thought..
 
Nine Ball said:
I disagree.. I don't think the itrader is worthless once you get above 10 or 20.. You can insert the link along with the negative or positive to show proof of a deal. It shows how you have done business up to that point. and who pays for itrader? How stupid that would be..

I don't think we need to change our system.. I think we need to change how the people who rip people off are handled.. Screw someone once, Depending on the situation, and it's a warning.. Do it twice and it's a month vacation.. Do it three times and your banned..

Make new members submit some information that would prove what name they sign up under.. Would help stop the ones coming back under a new name. You know the ones who rip someone off, Get banned, Then sign up again.. eBay makes you sign up using a credit card as proof of who you are if you want to sell items..

I know it will never happen but a decent idea I thought..
Well perhaps there would be a way that the person can be verified and therefore have an asterick or something that lets people know they are a verified buyer and seller with information given to AZ. :cool:
 
manwon said:
The I-trader is meaningless, and so are the Green Squares!!!!;)

I agree! I think there should also be a bad rep thread or a blacklist thread. Real names and all in case they come back under a different username. Have them for anything from bets to cue sales or trades.
 
powerlineman80 said:
I agree! I think there should also be a bad rep thread or a blacklist thread. Real names and all in case they come back under a different username. Have them for anything from bets to cue sales or trades.
I agree,Im all for verifying members who are upstanding and crooks,it would be a good idea.
 
Nine Ball said:
I disagree.. I don't think the itrader is worthless once you get above 10 or 20.. You can insert the link along with the negative or positive to show proof of a deal. It shows how you have done business up to that point. and who pays for itrader? How stupid that would be..

I don't think we need to change our system.. I think we need to change how the people who rip people off are handled.. Screw someone once, Depending on the situation, and it's a warning.. Do it twice and it's a month vacation.. Do it three times and your banned..

Make new members submit some information that would prove what name they sign up under.. Would help stop the ones coming back under a new name. You know the ones who rip someone off, Get banned, Then sign up again.. eBay makes you sign up using a credit card as proof of who you are if you want to sell items..

I know it will never happen but a decent idea I thought..


I disagree.. I don't think the itrader is worthless once you get above 10 or 20.. You can insert the link along with the negative or positive to show proof of a deal. It shows how you have done business up to that point. and who pays for itrader? How stupid that would be..


People still cheat, and give rating that are not honest, in fact there are people who give people ratings with no sale at all, just because they are a Buddy.

I don't think we need to change our system.. I think we need to change how the people who rip people off are handled.. Screw someone once, Depending on the situation, and it's a warning.. Do it twice and it's a month vacation.. Do it three times and your banned..

I also do not agree with 3 strikes your out, I think it should be a single strike and your out. In addition, anyone giving false ratings or those who except them and do not have them corrected should also be out!!

Make new members submit some information that would prove what name they sign up under.. Would help stop the ones coming back under a new name. You know the ones who rip someone off, Get banned, Then sign up again.. eBay makes you sign up using a credit card as proof of who you are if you want to sell items

I think that all members should have to prove their information is correct when they sign up, so to do right all members would have to be checked out. But this is not going to happen, so being careful is the only answer. For me I trust everyone until they show they can't be trusted, and once is all it takes.

We will have to agree to disagree on this subject.

Have a good night!!
 
manwon said:
I disagree.. I don't think the itrader is worthless once you get above 10 or 20.. You can insert the link along with the negative or positive to show proof of a deal. It shows how you have done business up to that point. and who pays for itrader? How stupid that would be..


People still cheat, and give rating that are not honest, in fact there are people who give people ratings with no sale at all, just because they are a Buddy.

I don't think we need to change our system.. I think we need to change how the people who rip people off are handled.. Screw someone once, Depending on the situation, and it's a warning.. Do it twice and it's a month vacation.. Do it three times and your banned..

I also do not agree with 3 strikes your out, I think it should be a single strike and your out. In addition, anyone giving false ratings or those who except them and do not have them corrected should also be out!!

Make new members submit some information that would prove what name they sign up under.. Would help stop the ones coming back under a new name. You know the ones who rip someone off, Get banned, Then sign up again.. eBay makes you sign up using a credit card as proof of who you are if you want to sell items

I think that all members should have to prove their information is correct when they sign up, so to do right all members would have to be checked out. But this is not going to happen, so being careful is the only answer. For me I trust everyone until they show they can't be trusted, and once is all it takes.

We will have to agree to disagree on this subject.

Have a good night!!



I am on your side on this one 100%
 
Last edited:
I would agree with the concept

I am a relatively new member here at AZ, and I have seen a few threads discussing gentlemen who have had significant issues with transactions, yet the seller still has good rep and positive Itrader feedback!
This is a little disturbing to consider that I completely trusted the itrader feedback for Tulipwood Lover when I purchased my Mike Stacey cue from him. Thankfully he was a class-act like Bamacues, etc and I had a great transaction. You definitely need a system that gives the historical information, bad or good, on sellers for potential buyers to review.

Btw, the board is awesome I think you guys do a great job with it!
 
Back
Top