A little cranky........? I think you're a lot cranky. You made a statement that wasn't true and now you get all pissed about it because someone has contested it?. I'm not disputing you then ducking back in some hole, I'm here to tell you that your statement was flat ass wrong. If you can't take the heat for being wrong then maybe you should just be out of here and leave the answers to people that know facts. Just like you, I too, get sick of the bullshit that people spew out on the forum and expect the world to believe it like the gospel.
I never said that a wood lathe was the best way. All I'm saying was it has been done and is being done today. End of story.
The problem with cranky, closed minded, people is a lot of them think their way is the only way just because they've done it that way for X number of years.
Get over yourself......
I got to say, you are def coming off as just trying to start crap for no good reason.
The OP was asking for advice on starting out making cues. Blackheart gave some very sound advice that was very appropriate to the conversation at hand. You had to go in and basically take one statement out of context and try and make something out of it. Yes I know that in a quote he says " you cannot build cues on a wood lathe", but if you read the post as a whole it is VERY clear what is meant. The real statement that is so plain to see, it is absurd is : "Even though a wood lathe is a lathe and does turn wood down, it is far from the best option, and anyone with any sense who is starting out to buld cues today would never even consider this option."
I would love to hear from anyone who missed this message that was loud and clear and expounded upon in the context of that post.
The major difference between his post and yours is that it was addressed to the original poster and directly addressed the questions asked with actual constructive information. It was intended to be on point and helpful. Yours are being petty and argumentitive.
When advice on a topic is asked for, do you think that the person asking is looking for LEAST efficient way of doing things? OR do you think possibly the intent is to save themselves some headaches and trouble? If I told you I know a guy who whittles cues out of tree trunks with a swiss army knife, would you suggest this as a proper method of building cues? Would you change your methods to be more like his? Would you recommend this to a brand new cuemaker? If a customer came to you and requested you to make them a cue on a standard wood lathe, would you? Also, Abe rich is not building cues today, so who is still currently building cues on a wood lathe? I would honestly like to know the answer. Are they making more than 5 cues a year? More importantly, are they making a living doing it this way? Does chris hightower"s book or videos discuss building cues on a wood lathe? Why not?

I think we all know the answer.
The OP was looking for usable information, not trivia. One of you was giving useful info, the other wasn't. Wonder which is which? Yet YOU want to get on a soapbox and criticize and point fingers.:thumbup: Good luck with that!
Give me a break.
Jw