Can A- players and above do the following test?

If you deliberately can add side spin and return the cueball to the tip then you are at the point where you don't need any drills. Accidentally it will be quite a rare feat.

The thing is that if you are trying to go in a straight line then you can observe the motion of the ball relative to where you are standing and see if it's going in a straight line or not.

Possibly but thats irrelevant to the drill in question. The question is one of unintentional side spin, thats the purpose of the line.

Not that I'd ever assume you would simply 'stand corrected'.

:)
 
10X harder that CB to rail back to tip.

No, that is probably more like 1000x harder, you are talking about two contacts that have to be dead perfect, no spin whatsoever imparting to the objectball on the first contact or it will spin off the footrail and offline. That second contact still being perfectly straight and making that cueball come back to hit the tip? That is not even on the same planet of difficulty. On a 9-foot table that would be bloody hard. I would bet against Ronnie O'Sullivan coming in cold on that shot and trying it on a snooker table in fact, I would bet $100 a shot on that for quite afew shots before I believed it was not a fluke if he actually made it.
 
Place a striped ball one diamond off a short rail and stroke it straight to the other short rail and back with the stripe hardly wobbling? Or not? Consistently..shot after shot? I can do it accidentally. But I'd like to know if you can be A- or above with a minor (?) hitch in your stroke.

You might want to try videoing yourself. I've been doing this drill recently to try and straighten out my stroke, and thought I was doing alright until I saw video of it.

Here's a link: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sCbgMWWbUhk

You can see that I was using the measles cue ball, with Joe Tucker's third eye attached. The CB came back pretty much to the tip (I moved the cue ever so slightly). But the video clearly shows I wasn't lined up correctly. I never would've figured it out without the video (or Joe Tucker's 3rd eye dvd).
 
I practice a considerably harder version:
A) take CB and place it on head-spot.
B) take OB and place it on center-spot
C) stroke CB to hit OB to hit rail to hit CB that finally comes back and hits the tip of your cue.

10X harder that CB to rail back to tip.


Wow, that is tough. Max Eberle shoots this on one of his instructional dvds.

Other versions for when you get bored, and want to get frustrated instead-

1) Shoot A) above through two balls stradling the center spot about 2 3/4 inches apart, and have cb return straight, passing through those two balls again on the way back to your cue tip.

And/or add two balls on the rail separated by 2 3/4 inches at the target end rail(with or without th 'center table gate').

2) Shoot A) above at a ball frozen to the rail at the center diamond of the end rail, so the double kiss comes back to the cue tip. Add center table 'gate' variation once it is too easy.

I can't do any of these-but I try them every once in a while. I seem to add a quarter? tip of right to everything that I think I am hitting center ball. Just enough to miss close at best.
 
Possibly but thats irrelevant to the drill in question. The question is one of unintentional side spin, thats the purpose of the line.

Not that I'd ever assume you would simply 'stand corrected'.

:)

I will stand corrected when I have been corrected. I designed the CueSight training ball so I think I am familiar enough with all variations of this drill. I am of the opinion that it is more beneficial to understand where you actually hit the ball in this drill based on where it goes after hitting the rail.
 
You guys are able to place a stripe so perfectly (vertical) that it can travel to one end of the table & back without wobble? I can't see myself doing THAT let alone stroking it perfectly too.

Exactly right. Placing the ball so the the line is perfectly perpendicular to the table is the difficult part and has nothing to do with your stroke.

Keeping it that way isn't really that hard but will show flaws in your stroke.
 
It is harder to set the striped object ball up, perfect, than it is to shoot that shot...
 
Back
Top