The feel and playability of a tip is very subjective.  Ask 100 people and you'll probably get 100 different answers.  With that said, after trying a slew of tips, I've settled on a Moori soft.  My cue has a 11.75 tip diameter and this may affect tip performance.  Surprisingly, I've had no mushrooming issues or glazing in almost a year of use.  I almost never miscue since it holds chalk so well.  My style of play is usually hitting the cue ball softly with pocket speed.  Rarely do I hit the cue ball very hard.  This may account for the lack of mushrooming.  On the opposite end of the pole, I played with a Super Pro for a while and enjoyed playing with it.  It feels a lot harder than the durometer hardness reported for this tip.  I did have a problem once in a while with the cue ball directly on the cushion.  Had to be very careful with the hit when the cue ball was in that position.  In summary, all I can say is keep searching Pilgrim.  Good luck in your quest for the perfect tip.