I have a pair of elk hide moccasins, with customer orthotics that can not be eat for comfort.
You may pay a bit more but I've yet to wear anything as comfortable as Ecco.
Those Clark's look pretty good. They're the early front runners.
I'd still like to see something a smidge more formal, just to see what else is out there.
Shiit just writes itself...literally.I have a pair of elk hide moccasins, with customer orthotics that can not be eat for comfort.
I'd like to add my voice to those who posted in favor of Rockports.
I note you want shoes that are dressy. All brand mentioned are well made and generally comfortable. However Ecco, Clarks, Merrill etc are not dressy, (some Ecco can be but look very Euro) . Cole Haan with the Nike Air technology can be, however, good luck with the fit. BTW, Cole Haan is owned by Nike and they have been trying to sell the company for some time.
Rockports would be the best based on your desire for comfort and suitability for DRESS. They are very good shoes. So is a brand called Munroe, made in America, of H S Trask.
As for made in China, most shoes are today. I say most, as New Balance is still amade in USA. I started making shoes in the USA in 1970 and have made over 11 million pair PER YEAR SINCE 1985, ALL OVER THE WORLD.
Buy the Rockports.
I'd like to add my voice to those who posted in favor of Rockports. They make dress shoes in addition to the out-and-out walking shoes, and you can play pool in them all day and night and still go to business meeting afterwards without feeling the least bit out of place.
FTR, I think footwear is one of the most important sartorial choices one can make, whether on the table or real life.
Phil, may I ask what brand of shoes that you make?