I think being a pool player is to be in a constant state of dissatisfaction and frustration. There is always the missed shot, the misplayed position, the ill-chosen shot. Always something to improve on. And because being in dead stroke means different things to us at different points in our "careers" we are never truly happy as pool players.
Lou Figueroa
Hi Lou,
IMHO:
I don't know about being 'happy' as a player as that can be a relative term as it relates to 'pure' happiness.
But I do know that when I have been in that 'dead stroke zone' playing with no discernable system or method & my feel & connection to the table & the situation on it were uninhibited by any conscious thought other than to run the table there were no ill chosen shots, no missed shots, & no misplayed positions.
I've been there rather often back in the day when I was playing a lot. Sometimes multiple nights a week for multiple weeks at a time. Not so much anymore but it still comes in spurts.
'Pure Feel' is an elusive entity. It comes to visit us on the outside from time to time for a continued period, though too short of a time for most of us. Then we have a conscious thought that chases Pure Feel back into the deep dark recesses of our subconscious mind were it only peaks out here & there in between being shoved back down by our conscious mind.
Then we are like you say, frustrated & dissatisfied, because we have reverted back to that hybrid of conscious beings with a subconscious in the shadows of our minds.
It's almost like there is a war for supremacy of our minds. I think the subconscious is far more superior but it is also far less aggressive & in fact submissive in it's nature as it relates to being in control of us. So...our aggressive for control conscious mind dominates the more submissive subconscious mind even though it, the subconscious, is the superior 'entity'.
Very many amateur golfers will hit a couple or maybe even only one shot purely & a feeling & realisation comes over them that that is what it is supposed to feel like. That feeling is what will make them go back to a course again & torture themselves with their normal game in search of that feeling again.
The odd thing is that those 1 or 2 shots usually happen near the end of a round of golf on either the 17th or 18th hole, but more so on the 18th hole, when the player was thinking about giving up the game or actually decided to do so & was just sort of finishing out the round with no real care as to the outcome. They then simply went through the motions of making a swing to hit the ball & KAPOW a perfectly struck golf shot.
Some seem to think that there can be a conscious method of 'aiming' a shot that encourages one's feel to come into play.
Others seem to think that clearing one's conscious mind clears a path for 'feel' to surface from the depths of our minds.
I lean toward the 2nd.
But who knows, as I've said, there may be several parameters or levels of what we call 'Feel'.
There are things that CJ Wiley says that rather many see as crap & he knows that. He keeps saying those types of things because he also knows that there are some that get what he's saying & what he means. He continues to throw them out for consideration for those that can get it to get it. Like most good coaches he knows that it sometimes takes saying the same thing many many different ways before it finally clicks for some.
Just some thoughts for consideration.
Best 2 All,
Rick
PS I guess this was not to you, Lou. I guess your post just spurred some thoughts.