dquarasr
Registered
Huh? I thought 5 represents the miscue limit. It’s equivalent to the stripe of a striped ball, which I understood to be the limit. See this image of the Rempe ball.
Help with cue tip contact point.
- Thread starter dquarasr
- Start date
dquarasr
Registered
Please ignore this reply. I stand corrected. Patrick is right. 3 is the limit per Dr Dave.
Attachments
Sounds like that misunderstanding might have something to do with your miscue problem...?
P.S. Looks like the red lines on the Rempe ball might accurately show the miscue limits from the “side” of the ball (the left and right in your pic), but not from the “front”.
pj
chgo
dquarasr
Registered
Yes I believe it has major influence on my miscues.
That said, I’m still working on applying the other suggestions received in this thread on hitting the CB at my intended point rather than where it typically hits, a bit above where I’m aiming, reducing the intended back spin.
There's probably a whole dedicated sub-forum for this topic, but something to give a go if you don't mind experimenting is a pick.For a hard tip I find that more aggressive tools do a better job, something like the "Brad Scuffer" does a good job, but it's very coarse, so use it sparingly and don't try to start any fires
I have been using hard tips for nearly 20yrs, and opt for this tool. It roughs the surface by creating pockets and allows chalk to embed. Really no different than anything else in that regard. The bonus is that it does not remove any material like an abrasive and subsequently does not alter the shape.
dquarasr
Registered
I have one of these. Now, if I can just remember where it is . . . . .
I've used one every day before I play for the past couple of decades - no problems as long as you "poke" it straight in and pull it straight out. I hit my tip 20 or so times with it.
pj
chgo
You're aware that the tip hits the ball on its edge when using max english, right? For example, with max draw the tip's top edge hits the ball.
pj
chgo
Yep same... When playing seriously, I'll condition the tip before every set. Just for sake of the routine so I wouldn't forget.
dquarasr
Registered
Yuppers.
boogieman
It don't mean a thing if it ain't got that ping.
I forgot to mention this, I also use it when less aggressive treatment is required. Very good tool.
It also raises the edges of the pockets a little when pulled out, "roughing" the surface without any loss of material. Perfect tool for the job, IMO.
pj <- and it recycles old phonograph needles
chgo
Shaping a 13mm tip to the roundness of a U.S. nickel coin gets the tip very close to the shape of the cue ball equator itself, maximizing control and feel for most. Some shape to a dime to get more zip (with their particular stroke and cue) on the ball.
A nickel shape is the same curvature no matter what size tip you put it on - and it's nowhere near the curvature of a ball.
pj
chgo
dquarasr
Registered
If a nickel roundness is very close to the shape of a cue ball, a nickel would be 2.25 inches in diameter.......
Here's a comparison of nickel and ball curvatures on a 13 MM tip (enlarged for clarity).
A tip with a curvature anywhere near that of a ball would be far too flat. In order to reach the miscue limit without playing on (or past) the edge of your tip you need at least 60 degrees of arc in the tip's curvature - you get that with a nickel or dime shape, but with a ball shape you can barely reach half that far before hitting on the tip's edge and risking miscues.
pj
chgo
Last edited:
Why? Just chalk between each shot and you should be fine. I stopped fidgeting with my tip 20 years ago and can probably count the miscues on two hands. I don't play with real hard tips so maybe that makes a difference.
Because I can - there’s no downside to ensuring that my hard tips don’t glaze over.
I do, and I am.
It’s like chalking every shot - you might not need it that often, it’s just how you remember to do it.
pj
chgo
1) "Very near" and "nowhere near" are subjective terms. Stop being a pedant, anyone who knows the game well uses rounded tips, not flat tips.
2) Speaking of subjective, place the edge of the nickel in your diagram at "A" touching "B" so that it's top sits atop the ball's equator . . .
. . . and we'll see you are stretching the truth, and . . .
3) We all avoid using the edges of the tip anyway, near the miscue limit.
4) I wonder how many books Bob owns that advocate shaping to a nickel coin? But what do pros know? And countless strong amateurs shape to a nickel. You consistently tell everyone you know more than the pros.
5) If I looked at your cue tip now, it will almost surely sit somewhere between a nickel and a dime shape, depending on preference. So give us a "break" (pun intended).
--Thanks for the correction on the curvature at any size tip. You are certainly correct. Now play nice with the other children today.
I apologize. "Very" is a subjective word.
What do you shape your cue tip to? A nickel or a dime?