I think we need a cue maker to give us his opinion. I would guess that if you are ordering a cue and ask if you can break with it about 99% are going to tell you to have at it.
Don't laugh, I know a guy that pretty much used to do that. A break cue, an english cue, a masse cue, and so one... he couldn't do any of that stuff anyway and he loved to talk about why he needed all of them. It drove us all nucking futs!
There is another issue that I have wondered about. Baseball bats, particularly ash bats, go "dead" in a couple of seasons. The cell walls of the wood are damaged over time. I understand that this is due to the flexing of the wood.
I suspect that cues also suffer this damage in wood over time. Is it a good thing for a pool cue or a bad thing? I don't know but I suspect breaking with a shaft speeds up this process quite a bit. If I find the perfect shaft that suits me to a "T" I'm not going to break with it. I'm not going to let another human being touch it either, a lesson learned the hard way!
Hu
I have a few cues I like. On is an elite that I am going to get a low deflection shaft for soon the other is an old dufferin sneaky Pete. I was wondering if I don't have a monster break but a pretty powerful one is it ok to break with these cues and can I do so without damaging them or do I need a breaking cue?
Thanks
AF
Funny you should mention the "dead" word, Hu. :smile:
For the last fifteen years every time I go into a tennis pro shop where they don't know me well, the use that line trying to get me to replace my 20 year old racquets with their new, improved, world-beater, model. Meanwhile I continue to search the tennis forums looking to buy another 1990ish Yamaha Secret 4. Can't find one, maybe they are all dead buried.:grin:
My racquets and cues ain't dead yet.
J
I was breaking with my player which had a predator 314/2 shaft just for a short time. I noticed a hairline crack in the ferrule then I stopped breaking with it. Eventually the crack extended an inch into the wood. I could hear a weird sound.
I kept playing with it til it completely collapsed like an accordion so I'm never breaking with a player again.
Is it harmful? Sometimes yes, sometimes no. I broke with my old JOSS a lot, but I won't anymore.
Everything can go along fine with no problems, until there is a problem.
It can cause premature wear or compression of the tip. Parts can break (tip, ferrule, shaft, joint, forearm).
We have seen failures posted in the forum, so it can and does happen. If you can afford a break cue then I say why not? Even a relatively inexpensive cue with a good ferrule and tip can serve nicely as a break cue.
Do you need one? Well...need is a strong word...no.....
.