macguy:
Let's not compare someone who, in the sunset years of his life, probably had not picked up a cue, to that same someone in his earlier years that played pool for money (read: everyday), and also worked and ran a pool hall. I would venture to guess that in the time when The Hustler was made, Jackie was a LOT better than in his retirement years. Just because someone has a table in their house, don't think for a minute that table gets used on a regular basis and that the owner is "just a killer on the thing" -- there are, I'm sure, LOTS of AZB'ers reading this that can vouch for this fact. I can't vouch for Jackie, since I wasn't there. But I can say this: when you're trying to do an "exhibition" for guests, and you want to make sure you don't look like an absolute fool, you intentionally set up simple trick shots, and you make sure to hit all shots "confidently." I'm not sure if Jackie knew those in attendance were actual/regular players of the game, so instead of looking like "the guy who can't even make a bridge and hit balls tentatively," he probably made sure to leave those with the impression that he can really hit 'em. Those who play pool regularly will see right through this, as you did. But don't forget the audience, and what Jackie was probably trying to do.
You are correct with those who say they paid their way through college playing pool, yet to even an occasional player's eyes, that same person can't even make a basic bridge or even stand correctly. This goes without saying. But don't compare "lack of experience" with "rust." I'm sure that if anyone asked Jackie on the side (privately and discreetly, so as not to embarrass a very proud man), and ask him in a clever way -- e.g. "Jackie, that's a nice stroke; how often do you play?" -- you'd find out he probably didn't play much at all anymore. The sunset years of such an iconic figure are still demanding, in doing PR and guest appearances.
And, unfortunately, Jackie was a proud man -- confident, boisterous, and overt. The life of the party; when he walked in to the room, it lit up. Many people are adverse to a person like this, and so every little thing that person does wrong, is magnified exponentially in their eyes. Jackie was no exception to this. I met Jackie back in the early 1980's when he was a guest to a private party of a friend of mine. At first, he was kind of aloof; if one wasn't prepared for this kind of reception, and if you're the type of person who is adverse to "any person who gets his @ss kissed by 'the common man'," it *could* put you off. But I knew the man just had his guard up around strangers; after a little while when he felt more comfortable, he opened up, and I mean REALLY opened up. The life of the party, like I said.
Anyway, thanks for your post,
-Sean