I don't necessarily agree. It depends on the type of "coaching" that Hopkins, or Sigel or Frost could bring to the table. It is more about "leadership" and having a unified approach to winning, and the right mind set to coach the men to victory. And that starts with their mental game and having a plan of attack. Not saying the others don't, but we don't really know for sure how they would respond.
Many other coaches of many other sports (ones far more difficult than pool) have succeeded all over the place without having first to play against their team they are coaching, in fact, I'd say that 99% or more have not played against the players they are coaching, and have won World Series, Super Bowls, Stanley Cups, NBA Championships, College championships in every sport imaginable.
I think it's time to quite putting pool on this pedestal that nobody else can coach except a HOF type player. Pool is the bottom feeders in the sports world, and every other league is stepping right over us with coaches that lead their teams to victory, but would never have been given a chance if they were coaching a billiard team that mainstream America has NEVER even heard of.....
This has been debated before many people saying you have to have a teacher at least on par of top pros , I am 100% of the mind set you are
I would take a team of Vets and young players and mold them together
If they let Canada in my team would look something like this
Shane, Alex , Brandon Shuff , Billy Thorp , and Skylar Woodward
A good mixture of vets and some young talent with some learning curve left
1