I'm new here - so forgive me for not knowing the whole history. I got the impression he (Justin) dug himself a pretty deep hole by accepting a good cue at a really good price because he was "down on his luck" so to speak. Then a couple months later - SOLD the cue for a big profit. I guess he's had a hard time digging himself out of that hole.
Hopefully things can be worked out in time - people can change as they get older.
But ... back to Schmelke. I got a SP about a month ago - and while I'm very happy with the quality (especially the shaft) ... it does seem very butt heavy. I'm wondering if that's common with Schmelke in general. It's not that I mind it, in fact it reminds me of a few very nice house cues I used years ago. It's just that now-a-days, I tend to lean more towards a center-weighted cue.
(Those are some very sharp looking cues by the way)
I recently purchased a schmelke and mine is not butt heavy at all, actually balanced. I'm not a cue professional by any means however, what I think will give you a better feelng cue is the type of wood you use for the forearm. The forearm on my schmelke is cocobola and I remember Dave telling me because it's a heavier wood it doesn't require any weight added to the butt, therefore giving it better balance. Feel free to correct me if I'm wrong. To the OP, I think your cue is very impressive, enjoy it!