Opinions Needed

Danktrees said:
signature confirmation doesnt mean it has to be that person to sign for it. it just has to be someone who is present at the address.

Yeah... In my case, I was standing on the sidewalk in front of the house digging through my car. So it just has to be someone in the vicinity of the address. :D
 
While it is true that signatures can be spoofed, the approach is still a wiser choice because it forces both the delivery person and package recipient to exchange in a handshake of sorts. In this case, it is reasonable to believe that the recipient would have spoken up and prevented the error after noticing 1 or more of the following truths:

1. This package is not addressed to my name
2. This package was not sent to my address
3. I was not expecting a package from this sender

From here, the error could have been detected and the package rerouted to its intended destination.
 
When shipping anything insurance is always the best thing to purchase,delivery conformation is a waste of money because the item is scanned either way. Items under 200.00 do not require a signiture and can be left in a secure location but the post office will still pay a claim if the item is reported missing or damaged. Just because it is left at a address doesnt mean thats the end of it. Trust me ...I know:D
 
thedude said:
Even signature confirmation can be flawed. I often go to visit a friend of mine inbetween jobs(I am a field archaeologist, and there can be lots of downtime depending on weather, the season, etc.), and she and her roommates work during the day. One of her roommates is about 5"4" white as can be, I'm 6'2" about 220lbs, and have waist length dreadlocks. So needless to say, we don't look a like.

I went out to get something from my car one day, and the mailman pulled up asked "Timothy?"(this being her short clean cut roommate) and I said "Thats me," and he handed me the package had me sign for it. I just signed his name. He had mentioned in the past about receiving packages and the mailman just leaving them on his porch without him signing for it. Ths particular package happened to be equipment that he had ordered for a computer he was building.

I took the inititive to sign for it because I needed a new computer... :) In reality, just didn't want his stuff sitting out on the porch or taken to the pile undelivered mail that sits at the post office.

I also once ordered a cue from Maryland, that was to be overnighted to Kentucky... The postal service sort of lost it, and it turned up in California. I ended up getting the cue(which was insured,) but I often wonder whats wrong with the USPS! In the 90's you always heard about stressed out postal workers going ballistic... I think they must of all been prescribed valium/xanax and and just don't give a shit anymore.

If you want to ship your item to a person and no one else then you have the option of RESTRICTED DELIVERY...its right there when u fill out the form. Signiture conformation means anyone at the residence is able to sign for it. So basically the mailman asked you if your were 'Timothy" and you being a fine young man lied and said yes. Years ago,a normal person would respond by saying "No I'm not Timothy but if you want I know him and can sign for him" But today everyones a clown and arent taught being honest is something you should be all the time. When your dealing with moorons you tend to not give a shit:D
 
Last edited:
It depends what im shipping whether im going to pay extra for signature,insurance and all of that,if its a $50 item or less i usually dont do too much,if it gets lost i will eat it.I think joint protectors cost about $5 to ship but if you add insurance and signature it almost doubles the cost of shipping,not being a cheap skate but somethings arent worth spending the extra money on.If its an item over a $100 i do insurance and confirmation,signature usually only if i have doubts on the buyer. :cool:
 
if i were jim i would make new proterctors. much cheaper than a refund . just upgrade shipping to the max. tell usps about the problem and note the package accordingly.

ive talked to jim hours on the phone. great guy. i dont know the seller but i dont think hes lying either.

shipping peroid is flawed

jim- learn a lesson here. be thankful its only 50$ joint protectors and not a 2k$ cue. (which isnt even your cost.) it takes alot of saved dollars to make up for that one lost item. ship fully insured with sig confirmation. i even scan and email a copy of the reciept to the buyers. extra mile for peace of mind :D
 
Well I said I would listen to what the Forum said. I have learned a lesson . I don't know if its what Dave thinks I should learn, but I have learned a lot. I realize it only a set of Joint protectors , and Yes I could just make him another set, no problem, but I have no confidence they would ever arrive. The buyer said "someone in my building has my joint protectores, and send me another set." He did not even offer to look for them . He was issued a tracking number when they were shipped. Five days after they were delivered by the P.O. he is asking for a tracking number. The P.O. says they were delivered, he says he never got them. I have over 2000 positive feedbacks on E-Bay and several in the short time here on AZ, I ship over a hundred items a month to England Poland, Greece, Turkey, Australia, and over 40 other countrys around the world, including NY , and he says you should never ship to NY without a signature , I have never had this problem before. Maybe we should just cross NY off our list, but that would not be fare. It's only a set of Joint Protectors, but it is the idea that someone is ,Maybe trying to get something for notheing, Dave says he has talked the buyer for hours, That makes him a good guy. I will issue a refund Tommarro, for the full amount, I had already decided that after talking to KBSAILING earlier tonight. I did want to hear what everyone had to say. The buyer says he would rather I made him another set, but thats not going to happen. As I said before there is no way to beleive it will get there when any one of his neibors could sighn for them. Thanks for your replys. Jim
 
Jim Baxter said:
Well I said I would listen to what the Forum said. I have learned a lesson . I don't know if its what Dave thinks I should learn, but I have learned a lot. I realize it only a set of Joint protectors , and Yes I could just make him another set, no problem, but I have no confidence they would ever arrive. The buyer said "someone in my building has my joint protectores, and send me another set." He did not even offer to look for them . He was issued a tracking number when they were shipped. Five days after they were delivered by the P.O. he is asking for a tracking number. The P.O. says they were delivered, he says he never got them. I have over 2000 positive feedbacks on E-Bay and several in the short time here on AZ, I ship over a hundred items a month to England Poland, Greece, Turkey, Australia, and over 40 other countrys around the world, including NY , and he says you should never ship to NY without a signature , I have never had this problem before. Maybe we should just cross NY off our list, but that would not be fare. It's only a set of Joint Protectors, but it is the idea that someone is ,Maybe trying to get something for notheing, Dave says he has talked the buyer for hours, That makes him a good guy. I will issue a refund Tommarro, for the full amount, I had already decided that after talking to KBSAILING earlier tonight. I did want to hear what everyone had to say. The buyer says he would rather I made him another set, but thats not going to happen. As I said before there is no way to beleive it will get there when any one of his neibors could sighn for them. Thanks for your replys. Jim
For absolute signature confirmation= Hold @ Fedex

You have show I.D. before you sign and receive package.
 
hangemhigh said:
For absolute signature confirmation= Hold @ Fedex

You have show I.D. before you sign and receive package.

Its the same with the restricted delivery from usps, you must show ID.
 
Refund or Reship

While you do not know if he would receive a set if resent, you do not also know if he gets a refund unless wire transferred or Perhaps sent via paypal.

Since a refund will still be a bad experience for the buyer, I would make another set and figure out a way to resend. Can you send to a work addresses - which might be more secure?

Upside is where you send hundreds a month, this does not appear to come up a large percentage of the time.

Caveat the resending of protectors with the expectation that a review (good or bad) will be posted on this forum. This can be better advertising than renting a billboard.
 
Agree with Robert above.

Also, both seller and buyer sound like very stand-up people, and problem is with postal service. Make another set, confirm it with us, have him review them, and you will get so much positive rep you will sell more joint protectors and more than make up for whatever you have in them.

And restricted delivery or the FedEx option with ID sound like the way to avoid this. However, given your track record, you have done very well so far with shipments not geting lost, much better than most I think. You can see from the threads that delivery services do mess up sometimes, and it is a cost of doing business.

Good responses from both buyer and seller.
 
hoosier_cues said:
When I have something shipped I like signature required. I live in a low traffic area so theft is not really a issue. I had UPS leave a Bluegrass out in the rain one time. Lucky for me I got home a few minutes after he dropped it.

I have noticed our FEDEX guy will leave it on the porch even if a signature is required. I can't stand FEDEX where I live now. Before we moved they were the best. Now it seems USPS is my best bet. Our normal USPS guy is pretty good.


Try this one..

I had a cue coming priority mail and was waiting by the door looking out the window as the mailman is supposed to bring the packages to the door. So I wait and if I see them get out of the truck I come out and get the package from them.

Well, He puts a few things in the mail and drives off.. I was disappointed because I expected the cue that day. I walk out and get the mail to find a slip for my package that says "sorry we missed you" and will try again..

I was heated over that... He didn't try to deliver the package.. He just didn't want to get out and come to the door..

At times mailing and receiving cues can be a real pain in the donkey..
 
Jim Baxter said:
I don't know if its what Dave thinks I should learn, but I have learned a lot.

Really? It seems like you haven't learned the most important thing which is that YOU made a mistake when YOU decided to send the package with no signature required. For maybe $0.25 you could have forced the exact level of awareness needed at delivery that would have resulted in me having the merchandise I ordered.

Yet, despite having an opportunity to learn from *your* mistake, you continue to desperately try and find something shady or off from my end. I don't appreciate it one bit. You're shocked to hear me make the claim that a neighbor has my merchandise? Guess what buddy... that's based on common sense. If you had any, you'd realize New York City isn't Little House on The Prairie. There are millions and millions of people here. The chances of a package accidentally falling into the wrong hands is great enough that any amount of common sense could easily justified paying the extra quarter for signature delivery.

And another thing, I don't appreciate being bashed and made out to seem like I'm just looking for free merchandise. When I stated that I'd *prefer* to have the caps made again and sent back out, it was because I believe you do great work. I was obviously interested enough to begin with and I'd still like to own a pair of your caps. But wait... stop everything.... you're going to grant me a refund? Guess what? I don't need you to do me any favors. I'm more than comfortable *taking* my money back via paypal's dispute department. After all, I'm the one who never received the goods. I'm the one who's out the price of the merchandise. I'm the one who needs to be made whole.

At the end of the day, you should have handled this much better. When you take the liberty of sending a package using a sub-optimal approach, you have no ground to stand on when the very situation things like "signature required" are designed to protect against, occur.

Hey Alton, feel like making some caps to turn this into a happy ending?
 
Last edited:
Just my opinion...replace them...the good will that you instill by a simple act like that will come back to you 100 fold. Especially if people know you did it. NYC is certainly not the best place for deliveries and we all know the postal systems are flawed. I'm already thinking about ordering JPs from you specifically for the way you handled this issue.
 
Well according to popular opinion , I should make him another set. I'm not sure he wants another set now. Today is a new day, and my Birthday . Attitude is a lot of my problem . In less than 2 hours , He went from , I did not receive to I want another set ,a refund , or I'll let everyone on AZ know just what happened. Never ofering to check with neihbors or anything, Just I want another set. If he still wants a set , I'll build them , but as always I will be out of town till next Monday, but If he does want them I'll have pictures of them posted on AZ before I send them . I will have them ready to ship by Weds. of next week , but he has to let me know if he wants them, as I am deep into other orders . I will also be sending Everything , signature required in the future. To bad our world has to be this way, or maybe just part of it. Thanks to everyone for their opinions. Jim
 
Jim,

Let's go ahead with the new set. That's exactly what I asked for (despite providing you with the option to issue a refund) originally.

Thanks,
Adam
 
They will be started today, but will not be able to finish till 1st of week. Should be able to ship by weds. , with luck tuesday. Thanks Jim
 
From another perspective:

I live in a nice area with an enclosed porch and I HATE signature required. I have never had a problem with a package being lost or stolen, but it is a big hassle to try and be at home when something is supposed to be delivered while I am at work.

It makes me mad when someone ships a low cost item (Under $200) signature confirmation. I recently ordered a hard drive and it came signature confirmation and was a big pain to be at home to recieve the item.

Just another opinion, but not everyone needs or wants signature confirmation.
 
I agree with you 1000% , but you can see what happens when it's not done. Thanks for your comment. Jim
 
Back
Top