Owners of a Murnak, Justis, or Whitten Cue Case

You folks with the megabuck cases might want to consider this little proximity alarm.

"Simply put the transmitter on the person or item to be protected and if it goes out of a 5 to 30 ft range of the receiver an alert sounds and vibrate.... There is also a serach (sic) function on the receiver. If you can not find your object or persn. (sic) Dial it to sarach (sic) function. The receiver will beep and vibrate when you walk close to your object or person."

Pretty sic, huh? :D
 
Cocobolo Nut said:
I am looking to get a 3 x 6 configuration, and color, trim, name on case is somewhat unimportant to me.

What I want is protection for Cues, storage room for accessories, towel holder, ease of getting into the cases pockets, and last a place/compartment/pocket for a Jump Butt/Handle.
Click to expand...

Based on your requirements, you will be very happy with a Murnak. Individual tube protection, lots of storage room and easy accessibility, towel ring option and jump butt compartment.

Also the following: a second removable strap for carrying it backpack style if you wish, spacers for the tubes to raise the butts and shafts for optimal "grabability", foam filled cap to hold the butts and shafts securely and prevent them from rattling around, and real comfortable shoulder pads.

And a very affordable price considering the quality of what you're getting.
 
JimBo said:
Why haven't you touched a Justis yet??

Jim
Click to expand...

Who, or why would you question whether I have?

Maybe you know better than I all the cases I am familliar with.:rolleyes:
 
Since all the cases except Murnak have had criticism, I'll list why I don't use mine. Not that it's a bad case, just not perfect like everybody who has one implies.
First and foremost the latch on it has to go. The only possible positive of it is that it "locks", unfortunately anybody could pop it with a pen knife and maybe with their fingernails. In all other respects it is a negative, difficult to latch.
He tried to do too much with the long pocket, making it do each of the things it tries to do not quite well enough. The front part is too shallow because of the back part for papers, and personally I never have enough papers that I need a separate compartment for them. The jump handle pocket was to small for my jump cue handle.
The straps are a little difficult to adjust, but you only do that once.
It bulkier than any of the others, including an Instroke which you didn't mention.
It is a good case, but not my preferred and definitely not the best I've ever touched. However, that said I don't think you can go wrong with any of them. All three offer good protection, but I honestly think Instroke (which isn't on your list) offers the best protection of all.
The first thing I decided is what kind of style you want. If you want the sleek, finished leather look and you won't be banging it around, eliminate the other 2 and go with Whitten. If you like the rugged western saddle look with tooling eliminate the Whitten and choose between the other 2 based upon price and what you've heard here.
Lastly I'd suggest you call all three and talk to them.
Good luck sorting threw the prejudices of the various case owners you've heard from.
 
Sweet Marissa said:
Ribdoner, you can't be evasive! Let us know which case you are going to go with!
Click to expand...

GLAD YOUR BACK!!

I'm 99% certain of what I want. Got to sleep on it for a night or three. Not sure if I'm capable of posting but if I can I will upon receipt. take care
 
catscradle said:
Good luck sorting threw the prejudices of the various case owners you've heard from.
Click to expand...

This is the best line in this whole thread.
Well said Steve.

Jim <------(your name is Steve isn't it???)
 
JimBo said:
This is the best line in this whole thread.
Well said Steve.

Jim <------(your name is Steve isn't it???)
Click to expand...

Yeah, I think... Yep, I'm sure I just looked at my license.
 
catscradle said:
Since all the cases except Murnak have had criticism, I'll list why I don't use mine. Not that it's a bad case, just not perfect like everybody who has one implies.


Good luck sorting threw the prejudices of the various case owners you've heard from.
Click to expand...

That's cuz the moment someone says anything that it isn't high praise, it's looked upon as bashing. Thanks for the honest review and hopefully helpful constructive (construction?) criticism.

Personally, I wish Whitten's zippers were stronger,the cases lighter, and not allow the cues to ratte so much. I wish Jack would turn his zippers around, and do something about letting us get our hands into the pockets. I'd say something more about the Murnak, but I don't own one. The few I picked up were too heavy, given the direction I'd like cases to go.

Fred
 
Cocobolo Nut said:
The time is approaching to get a new Cue Case, (Christmas Present) and I am considering ordering a Murnak Vintage, Justis, or Whitten Cue Case.

But quite frankly can not decide upon what case to get. I do not have the funds available for all three VBG.

So I am hoping some owners of Murnak Vintage, Justis, or Whitten Cue Case would share with me their like and dislike about what they own. also what they might change if ordering a new Murnak Vintage, Justis, or Whitten Cue Case again.

I am looking to get a 3 x 6 configuration, and color, trim, name on case is somewhat unimportant to me.

What I want is protection for Cues, storage room for accessories, towel holder, ease of getting into the cases pockets, and last a place/compartment/pocket for a Jump Butt/Handle.
Click to expand...

I've never had a Murnak case or have even seen one, but I am sure they are good cases.

I've had Instroke and Whittens. I didn't care for the Instroke's design or quality of leather. The Whitten is like fine luggage, well made and competent, but not exciting. I admired the quality workmanship. One of the cases seemed to hold a dent in the shell.

I just use a plain natural leather Jack Justis case. It's the second one from the left in the photo below. I also have a couple of other Justis cases, but the plain one is the one I use.

I'm 100% satisfied with my case and I plan to use it for the rest of my life. It's 11 years old already and just look at it.

Chris


Justis_op_800X674.jpg
 
Last edited:
Mho

Cornerman said:
That's cuz the moment someone says anything that it isn't high praise, it's looked upon as bashing. Thanks for the honest review and hopefully helpful constructive (construction?) criticism.

Personally, I wish Whitten's zippers were stronger,the cases lighter, and not allow the cues to ratte so much. I wish Jack would turn his zippers around, and do something about letting us get our hands into the pockets. I'd say something more about the Murnak, but I don't own one. The few I picked up were too heavy, given the direction I'd like cases to go.

Fred
Click to expand...

I agree- I wish the Justis pockets were a little roomier. I like the lid and the general appearance. They age well. Personally, I liked the tube design a bit better. The prolites are nice because you can get in a lot of cues but I have to be pretty mindful when putting them in and out- as they can click together coming in and out.

Whitten cases are great- but really heavy- plus I tend to worry about scarring/scuffing. With the Justis I really don't mind it because I think they look good even if they get roughed up a bit. I agree that the Whitten have a slight tendency to rattle.

I wish I had bought the introductory Murnak. I PMed him on the last day and his box was full. I did not follow up on it and I think he tried to get me. I was super busy at that time. If that offer were good today I would place an order immediately. I like the design- I would probably opt for a single strap though.
 
gforces1911 said:
I wish I had bought the introductory Murnak. I PMed him on the last day and his box was full. I did not follow up on it and I think he tried to get me. I was super busy at that time. If that offer were good today I would place an order immediately. I like the design- I would probably opt for a single strap though.
Click to expand...
PM me if you need his email or phone number :)
 
Mr. Wilson said:
Who, or why would you question whether I have?

Maybe you know better than I all the cases I am familliar with.:rolleyes:
Click to expand...


You make no sense and yet somehow it's your job around here to decide what's right and wrong?? I sometimes wonder if your comprehension skills are as good as your writing skills.

BTW it was a joke, of course you missed that as well :rolleyes:
It was just a counter to your add for Murnak cases, if you really need me to I'll explain it in a PM.

Jim <---If you have 2 splain them...
 
Cornerman said:
That's cuz the moment someone says anything that it isn't high praise, it's looked upon as bashing. Thanks for the honest review and hopefully helpful constructive (construction?) criticism.

Personally, I wish Whitten's zippers were stronger,the cases lighter, and not allow the cues to ratte so much. I wish Jack would turn his zippers around, and do something about letting us get our hands into the pockets. I'd say something more about the Murnak, but I don't own one. The few I picked up were too heavy, given the direction I'd like cases to go.

Fred
Click to expand...


Good post Fred, give me 10 minutes with anything and I'll find things wrong with it.
I'll go about the case thread a different way, I'll list what I like and it differs greatly by size.

for a 1x2 I don't think you can beat the Whitten, size and weight as well as the way it fits in your hand, very sleek and streamlined.

2x4 I just love the Justis, you can't beat the look of class and the unique style, you get something that stands out and heads turn when you walk in the room.

Big case 3x7 I love the Instroke, the protection it offers is great the features are great (pockets, jump handle pouch) But the construction is a bit off (latches, lower grade of leather)

As far as cases I don't care for, Giuseppe (?) they are made of cardboard, very crappy, Porper are a step up but still import quality. Any no-name import I wouldn't use the tubes suck and they fall apart.

Other cases like Murnak, Swift, NYC all have some nice features and workmanship, but IMO are a bit heavier and for lack of a better word Clunky, But sometimes the trade off may be worth the lower prices

Other cases like It's George, Flowers and Felini are nice, but try to find them in good shape for a good price.

Jim
 
Oy-Vey !!!

Originally Posted by JimBo
This is the best line in this whole thread.
Well said Steve.

Jim <------(your name is Steve isn't it???)



catscradle said:
Yeah, I think... Yep, I'm sure I just looked at my license.
Click to expand...


My mother used to print my name in the collars of all my shirts when I went to camp. She's passed away now, but I looked in the collar of my t-shirt anyway. Come to find out, my name is 'Fruit Of The Loom'.....
Doug
(it's going to cost a fortune to change all the paperwork)
 
Btw, I'm following this thread closely also. With this potential poker ban, I will have to head back to the poolroom and I'm thinking of buying a new case too....

Doug
( I appreciate the pictures of your cases )
 
Last edited:
I have had a Whitten 3x6 for about 2 years now. I absolutely love it. It is a light brown almost orange leather, with a nice grain pattern that almost looks like lizard (it isn't). The case has held up fine, and looks great. I like how the pockets have zippers instead of flaps. This makes the chances of things falling out pretty close to zero. I don't think there is a special pocket for a jump cue handle. However, the large pocket could probably fit one easily. The small pocket is enough for a couple of boxes of chalk. The weight is reasonable for what it is. Not super light or super heavy. If you change cues a lot, it might be annoying, because you can adjust the height that the cues sit by inserting little rubber spacers. this system works great, and gives a satisfying spring to the bottom of the case. Once I set mine up for all my cues, they all sit perfect for easy removal. Also for what it is worth, the case stands up pretty well on a flat surface. I keep a bungee cord wrapped around mine so that I can attach it to a chair or something and then use it as a cue holder.

No experience with the others.

hope this helps,

KMRUNOUT
 
JimBo said:
Good post Fred, give me 10 minutes with anything and I'll find things wrong with it.
I'll go about the case thread a different way, I'll list what I like and it differs greatly by size.

for a 1x2 I don't think you can beat the Whitten, size and weight as well as the way it fits in your hand, very sleek and streamlined.

2x4 I just love the Justis, you can't beat the look of class and the unique style, you get something that stands out and heads turn when you walk in the room.

Big case 3x7 I love the Instroke, the protection it offers is great the features are great (pockets, jump handle pouch) But the construction is a bit off (latches, lower grade of leather)

As far as cases I don't care for, Giuseppe (?) they are made of cardboard, very crappy, Porper are a step up but still import quality. Any no-name import I wouldn't use the tubes suck and they fall apart.

Other cases like Murnak, Swift, NYC all have some nice features and workmanship, but IMO are a bit heavier and for lack of a better word Clunky, But sometimes the trade off may be worth the lower prices

Other cases like It's George, Flowers and Felini are nice, but try to find them in good shape for a good price.

Jim
Click to expand...

Good post and observations.

My cases jump from 2X4 to 12X24 with only 1 in-between, a George 3 X 6 case. I only need to ever carry two cues (one player with two shafts, one break cue with one shaft) and a jump cue, so a 2X4 with a long pocket suits me fine.

I never understood exactly the need for a 3 X 6 case. Stuffed, they're big and heavy to drag around for playing and they're too small for storage. I know a guy with a 3 X 6 and his leather strap actually broke because he used it like a shoulder sling.

Chris
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top