Celtic said:
Totally wrong. With zero deflection it lends itself to more true cueball paths. No aiming system I can think of, ghost ball, tangent lines, ect. take into account deflection when using siding. The minute you start having a cueball deflect when putting siding on the ball there is a factor where you cannot use a system to determine the aiming of the shot. No 2 cues deflect exactly the same, no two shots will deflect the exact same based on speed, the amount of siding you are putting on the ball, the distance of the shot, the felt you are playing on, the factors are extreme and NO aiming system takes them into account. They simply cannot, the minute your cue deflects the shot you are forced to use a "feel" or a natural instict on how much the cueball will deflect on the shot you are playing. Using a non-predator cue people take huge amounts of time getting accustomed to the amount of deflection they are getting out of the cue, they have to create the feel for the particular cue.
I totally disagree with you on this, the Predator is in no way the cue for the "feel" players over the non-Predator cues. The non-predator cues force a player to have a engrained feel for the amount of defelection their cue produces on every fathomable shot and that information cannot be put into any sort of system, it has to be learned through countless hours of shooting with that cue and slowly your brain will work out for you subconsiously where you need to aim when using siding.
You say Predator does not work due to reduced deflection, well what aiming system do you know of that actually incorperates deflection into it to begin with? The aiming systems I have seen, wether it be a ghost ball, some kind of rali system, ect... never take into account defelction and always work under the assumption that the shot is center ball, or as the ghost-ball system and most others work the cueball must be at X at contact when the contact is made. Having a straight line to the target "ala Predator" is going to work better then a curved line to the target "ala normal shafts" for almost every system.
Having beat on each others head like battering rams on the now defunct aiming thread, I have to pretty much agree with everything you said on this post and especially your first one in this thread. There are a couple of areas that I want to address as I see it. You said, "No aiming system I can think of, ghost ball, tangent lines, etc. take into account deflection when using siding".
There may in fact be a system that you just don't know about, and it's Hal Houle's system which in essence NEGATES deflection by the use of backhand english that is incorporated into just about every shot with a cut. So it's a twofold method: one of aligninging the shot, and tip offset with backhand to negate deflection that makes it totally unique. However, NO...NO OTHER SYSTEM DOES.
You also said, "The minute you start having a cueball deflect when putting siding on the ball there is a factor where you cannot use a system to determine the aiming of the shot".
My feelings are you can ALWAYS use a system to determine the aiming of the shot. IT JUST GIVES THE PLAYER AN INITIAL REFERENCE POINT TO START FROM. But based on the other areas that you suggested such as speed, amount of siding, distance, felt, you then HAVE to make an adjustment through feel OR make a conscious effort to aim further outside or inside your determined spot that you would have for a normally straight forward shot with centerball. Either way it comes down to an educated guess through experience, or feel through experience.
Whether you use a Predator or a non-Predator shaft, you'll still develop "feel" over a certain period of time with either shaft. They're just at opposite ends of the spectrum and you couldn't really be talking the same language between both users. Eventually you could even develop some sort of feel if you used a metal rod for a shaft and have NO FEEL for anything else.
At least the Predator users on here are honestly stating certain things that non users or previous Predator users have said about the shaft:
(KYLE) "Have patience with it. I've had mine for about 2 years now, it probably took half of that time to get completely comfortable with it. I have a couple of friends who bought one and didn't like it a couple of days later.
My response is, who in the hell wants to give up one whole year of playing to get used to a shaft? Who wants to miss shots and shoot like crap over a year just to get back to where you were initially"? In my case, I DID! And I could kick my own stupid ass for doing it, and it never did boost me beyond where I'd ever been.
(TATE) "Predator shafts are definitely different. They are extremely accurate but have a funny feel to them. They are 1/2 ounce lighter than most standard shafts of the same dimensions and all of this weight is removed from the tip area. On soft english shots it felt like the tip was bouncing off the cueball".
YES, they are definitely different. They have a funny feel and the lighter weight from the front end sure doesn't help if you like the feeling of a forward weighted cue and have been used to playing with one your whole life. EVERYTHING gets thrown off, tempo...timing...distance control...spin...throw, that's a lot of getting used to.
(Iusedtoberich) "I also hear many people here say that you can't use backhand english with a Predator. The aiming point is different".
Yep...the Predator actually overcorrects if you're used to using it and you'll miss EVERYTHING. Efren said about a Predator, "The CB just never goes where I aim it". I know the feeling well, and don't want to put 2-3 years into figuring it out.
(CheffJeff) "After using nothing but my Predator for seven months now, I am still struggling on these shots". Meaning curve and jump.
Well, how much longer do you want to struggle? When do you think "the magic" is just going to kick in?
And then in Celtic's first post he basically said that the Predator just feels like shit and plays like shit and you have to change your whole game around to get used to it. Why have we wasted all of these words when that pretty much sums it up? (no offense to the Predator users who I like and respect otherwise...I love you guys)