The problem with kicking the top 5 guys out of the event is that now the 6th best guy looks like he is stealing.
Where does it end?
The BCAPL has been bumping some people back into the open every year of late and at times it is deserved, other times those getting bumped back go to Vegas and rob the place. About 2 years ago two of the best bar box players from Calgary got dropped back into the open division, well sure enough they went down and entered it and they both ended up playing each other deep on the final board on the A-Side and then deeper yet on the B-Side. I think they chopped close to 5 digits up between them.
As good as some of the guys from the states are there are a few guys I see in this years open event from Canada they are going to be in tough against.
Plus, I am not sure how good Chris Gentile is at 8-ball but that guy got second place in the US Open 1-pocket against an absolutely stacked field.
http://www.azbilliards.com/tours_an...us-open-one-pocket-championship-2011/results/
I for one would not really be looking forward to playing him were I anyone on that list. He actually BEAT Alex into 3rd place, and Alex is a monster at 1-pocket.
At the end of the day I would just let them play, but the BCAPL set a pretty strong precedent when they took the winnings away from the two Taiwanese players AFTER they won the money. I think they need a pretty strong hand when it comes to keeping pro level players out if they don't want to look biased at this point.