Very interesting, I guess I just haven't spent enough time learning the rack!
Now, what about my other two questions?
- do you think earl was doing this?
- is it legal/ethical?
IMO its legal, but unethical.
Its a part of the problem with rack your own. Tournament directors went with rack your own to shut people up. Players were whining so much about the rack, stuff like getting slugged or pattern racking to make tougher runouts etc. instead of addressing and enforcing what is basically good sportsmanship in making sure racks are honestly as random and racked as good as can be, they gave into the whiners. Grady Mathews was a huge proponent of rack your own, and in one pocket it works out better because you really are just avoiding getting screwed as opposed to setting up dead balls, you can tilt the rack to help avoid the accidental scratch, but thats not as huge of an issue IMO as it doesnt happen as much.
So now, in turn rack your own set up a situation where guys can pattern rack for themselves, and gap the rack for the wing balls (easier to set up than the nine ball).
As a purist, I consider it a bastardization of the game, and contributes to dishonesty and unethical behavior in pool. There was always a good amount of both so why add to it IMHO.
Chuck
Last edited: