[...]
We have previously used the red circle - but it s NOT the ball that comes with any set of balls. I have always preferred the red circle but it seems the measle ball is gaining in popularity but it hardly qualifies as original cue ball. [...]
Mark Griffin
Mark:
Glad you mentioned that. A lot of folks seem to think the red circle ball is a "standard" ball and is "automatically bundled" with ball sets. Nothing could be further from the truth. Aramith always sells the red circle ball as a completely separate standalone product, and has NEVER included the red circle with any of their ball sets. That's telling, right there.
Although yes, many folks prefer the red circle, that fact is also telling of the game they like to play -- usually short-rack rotation. The red circle is an especially "zingy" ball (especially with draw), so in games where you have to move the cue ball around, it makes sense lots of players of those games would warm to that product.
However, in order to level the playing field between the various games that a ball set must go through (e.g. short-rack rotation, 8-ball, one pocket, etc.), the cue ball *should* be matched to the object balls. Put it this way, if you used an object ball as a cue ball and shot it into another object ball (using e.g. draw, follow, side spin), a cue ball should respond exactly the same as that object ball that was used as a cue ball.
Lou also makes a good point about the COR of the material used in the construction of the cue ball. Again, that cue ball should respond as close as possible to an object ball if you struck it directly with your cue. Many times, a cue ball product -- even the red circle(!) -- fails this simple test, because the COR is so different. IMHO, the measles ball is as close to an object ball as you can get, and that's why Aramith certifies and bundles it with certain ball sets:
http://saluc.com/html/billiard/index.php?idlien=10
I'm assuming the Cyclop ball is as close to the object balls as possible, so that certain games don't inadvertently "bring out" certain non-standard characteristics of that ball product -- like being zingy on draw, etc.
-Sean