I ws at the poolroom last night watching the league players warm up. A 6 was showing a 4 how to play 8 ball. The 4 was a good shot maker, but knew nothing about english or position. It was the 4's turn, he has solids. The 6 level player told him what to shoot and why. Needless to say, my eyebrows raised a bit when the 4 pulled it off, what do you think he did?? And, what would you do?? Playing on a diamond barbox.
When you said outside the box thinking.. i didn't think you meant absurdity..
What would you have done in this situation neil?
that isnt an absurd shot at all. actually pretty smart shot. if he has decent speed control he has a shot at either stealing the pocket like he did, or the six may come back out and get between the cue and the 12. not like he had much else of a chance.
at the angle he has to work with, you want him go almost 6ish diamonds and come off the 7 like he did?
i'd let him go at that shot all day long because most of the time he'll either miss the 7 completely, or hit it and do something completely opposite of what he wanted.. either way, my 12 is still a sitting duck in the pocket.
yes. think about it, the guy is a 4. pocketing the 6 is probably just as low percentage as pushing the six down towards the 7 and hoping to get lucky and tie the 12 up. i wouldnt have played it this way, but if you really think about who is at the table, it really wasnt a bad or crazy play at all. he gave him a chance to knock the 12 out of the pocket, leave the 8 between the cue and the 12 or leave the 6 or 7 (depending on where the 6 hits the 7) blocking the 12.
The fact that he is a 4 is the exact number one reason I wouldn't want him even trying this shot..
I've posted what I would do.. what i'd have the 4 do is come off the 6 at an angle so it goes to the opposite rail and ends up hopefully behind the 8 for a decent safety... much higher percentage of working then anything else that sl 4 can pull off.
The whole thing about this situation is the sl6 is TEACHING the sl4. So to not have him even try to attempt it doesnt make sense. The whole point of the game is to learn as much as you can. Not have someone hold you back because you are a skill level 4.