Thanks for stating the truth. It's a shame when folks criticize the livestreamers, not realizing that sometimes things are beyond their control. It happens all the time in Vegas and Reno. If the hotel bandwidth sucks, so, too, will the livestream. :embarrassed2:
I have no idea how fast your connection speed needs to be in order to get a stream to the host, but almost all broadband connections these days have plenty of bandwidth to handle an HD stream.
Bandwidth
consumption, OTOH, is a whole other ball o' wax, but that should have nothing to do with the quality of the stream going out, only how much you get charged. This, I believe, is based on bitrate, length of broadcast, and number of viewers. I know it's a mathematical formula similar to power usage, and not a connection speed issue per se. This is why TAR had to bump up their price a few bucks for the full HD stream, because the bitrate is higher. Justin C. explained this clearly a few weeks ago.
Anyway, that was not my gripe. What
was tedious for me was... the entire production.
- Cameras constantly shifting poorly thought out viewpoints at the oddest times, each camera with it's own color profile. Calibrate you equipment ahead of time, and stick to one camera angle for at least five seconds.
- Terrible sound balance, with half the match spent talking with the chat about the volume rather than actually commentating on the play. Sometimes the background was so loud we could hear the TV in the background, or Alvin telling Alison not to show the players asses. Then they make it too loud, then too soft. It's called a "sound check", and it's done hours ahead of time. There are about 100,000 aspiring musicians in the NY metropolitan area that know more about this than IP does. Surely, one of them plays pool and would do it for beer. They're used to that.
- Very unprofessional commentating, with established pros sitting in and mocking Earl. In what other sport do you hear the commentators doing this? In the meantime, Earl was acting fine (for Earl, anyway). Cue sports are the classiest sports of all, and the pros behind the scenes ought to show a little class themselves.
- Bickering with each other about how they think a shot should be played, rather than explaining it as it was actually shot. I know Hunter is a very knowledgeable guy who demands the respect of a lot of pros for his knowledge, but he seemed to be in a battle of one-upmanship with Mika that really took away from the enjoyment of the game.
- Then there is Alvin. I don't know him at all, only saw him on occasion at SBE (always with a sour puss on BTW), but he seems to be every pro's friend. Good. Have a beer with him after and thank him for his hard work, but PLEASE keep him away from the microphones. I cannot believe some of the nonsense that comes out of his mouth. I mean,
really, talking about Santa Claus beating some kid up with a baseball bat???? Get a grip, Alvin.
- The chat. Drop it in the dumper, or let Alvin answer questions via keyboard. It is a huge distraction, even for the best commentators. Even Mary K. fell prey to it during the 10-Ball finals at SBE. If the players are at the table, talk should revolve around the
play, not how the commentator got into pool in the first place.
I could go on, there is really no end to the flaws I am seeing in the IP streams. Almost all of them could be resolved with out spending a penny, just some self-control, diligence and planning ahead of time. Accu-Stats has this thing DOWN, so if IP really thinks they are an up-and-comer in the field, they better pull themselves up by the bootstraps. Free is fun, but pro pool is a BIDNESS! Act accordingly.
Of course, then there is Alison Fisher from NYC Grind. What a class act she is! If it weren't for her we would have simply turned the sound off. I met her briefly at SBE and was so impressed with her I volunteered my services for the next Turning Stone event. Her commentary is already first rate, just think what a few years in the booth with somebody like Billy I. would do for her skills.
Oh... and I am officially in love with her, so she better get herself hitched real quick or some fat old guy is gonna make a fool of himself.
JK Alison, I'm already in love, but I do wish you well in all that you do.
