Worth the read........i hope

Tin Man

AzB Gold Member
Gold Member
Silver Member
When a player is beginning, they are complimented as they begin to improve. People boost their confidence and tell them how much better they are than they were as a rank beginner. Nights that they shoot as bad as a rank beginner they are reassured and encouraged to not give up.

Then, as they develope into run out players, they are compared to league players. They are still complimented when they turn out a good performance. On a bad night they are still encouraged.

Then, as a shortstop, they are compared to other good local players. They are encouraged to go play in some pro events, and are celebrated for turning in a good match or beating a champion or two. On a bad day they are still encouraged.

This continues all of the way until the player's begin to compete professionally on a regular basis and develope a reputation. ALL OF A SUDDEN, everything changes. People begin to compare them to their idea of what the perfect pool player should play like, and our best human players will never come close to perfection. People begin to ridicule them for not being perfect, and post videos of their misses all over this website in disgust.

The attitude is like: Oh, sure, I miss all of the time, but I am just a local player. These guys are professionals, so they are supposed to be perfect. I can't play that good, but they ought to play better, and they shouldn't be proud of what they have achieved because they are a long way from where I think they ought to play.

GUYS! Instead of becoming hung up on how far from perfection human pool players are, lets show some appreciation for what they have accomplished. The women may not be playing as well as consistantly as some of the top men, but they are out competing. If people posted videos of every mistake you made and talked about how bad you played, I doubt you would ever play another tournament. For these players to get out and perform in spite of this is incredible. And, they are getting better. There is no question that the women have come a long ways over the last decade. Maybe not as far or as quickly as you wanted, but as fast and as far as they could.

In the end, the pros have even harder expectations on themselves than you do, that is why they got so good. It tears them up to play badly after sacrificing a lifetime to play. Maybe they, like the beginner that misses five shots in a row, could use some encouragement and some appreciation, and be given a break from the unrealistic expectations that people crucify them with.
 
a very good point. the main problem is the word 'professional' and the connotations of the word.
 
Oh man I love this post. There is so much truth in what you say that I don't know where to begin my reply!

I do indeed believe that people hold pros to too high of a standard sometimes. Granted, people have bad days, but the truly great players shine forever. As much shit as everyone gives Earl Strickland, no one can disbute that he was and IS an amazing player and nothing to turn your nose up at. Perfection is what it is because it doesn't come along that often. To achieve it more than once is more than anyone could ask. Our pros go out and perform tourney after tourney striving for the same thing all of us are. Maybe that's why people are so hard on them?... because we know we are so alike and some of us (myself included) beat our own selves up over little mistakes and hiccups. All I know is that all the pros are at a point where I want to be. Which makes them my heroes and role models even at my age. And I'll look up to them until I'm at their level, end point.

+rep to Tin Man; way to get me all worked up:D
 
Sammy Davis Jr.
A professional is one who does a good job even when he doesn't feel like it
 
It's no different from any other sport, people criticize professional players for their mistakes, or are surprised when they play poorly. Their egos are not that fragile, that's one reason they've gone so far. Just the fact that we're talking about them means they've achieved something that most of us can only dream of.
 
TV has a lot to do with it

TV coverage has a lot to do with this. When we watch the time edited matches on TV they have naturally saved the most exciting parts, not when players were sparring around and neither could get a decent start. Likewise, we don't see old footage of the Hall of Famers on their bad days and stories always grow in the telling.

I listen to tales from years ago and never bat an eye even when I was there and know the story has little resemblance to the truth. However, some believe these myths too and then expect the people they consider pro's should match the myths.

Pro's are just like the rest of us, they have good days and bad. None of them are really gods to begin with, just humans with a lot of heart and desire.

Hu



Tin Man said:
This continues all of the way until the player's begin to compete professionally on a regular basis and develope a reputation. ALL OF A SUDDEN, everything changes. People begin to compare them to their idea of what the perfect pool player should play like, and our best human players will never come close to perfection. People begin to ridicule them for not being perfect, and post videos of their misses all over this website in disgust.

The attitude is like: Oh, sure, I miss all of the time, but I am just a local player. These guys are professionals, so they are supposed to be perfect. I can't play that good, but they ought to play better, and they shouldn't be proud of what they have achieved because they are a long way from where I think they ought to play.
 
What a wonderful post and it goes for all sports. If you are just under pro you are praised for being so good but if you ARE pro but at the low end people compare you to the TOP pros and talk about how bad you suck.
 
Wow! good post. It realy hit the nail on the head. which is a reminder that....."Its the tall nail that gets pounded down"

-jay-
 
I would also like to thank you for the insightful post...as well as for the sentiment behind it.

As a pro, I've received my fair share of praise and criticism. It does seem that on the way up, the praise flowed like beer on St. Patty's Day. But when I first turned pro, it would've been easier getting action from monk than it was to get real compliments from people. Of course I received congratulations from just about everyone...but more often than not, it was followed by some sort of question as to why I wasn't doing better on tour or winning pro events yet.

After I had some successes on tour, the praise started flowing again...but it has never reached the level that it did when I was an up-and-comer. Not that I am complaining. No one is ever harder on me than I was on myself. Through all of it, I learned to play for me...not anyone else.

We can never reach others' expectations of us....we can only try to reach our personal goals and take comfort when we know that we are doing our best. I could win a tournament tomorrow...and there are people out there who will say I got lucky...or I will never win again...or that I still play bad compared to the men. To them I say...at least I'm out there. I'm doing what I love. I put myself in the public for all to ridicule...and I'm OK with that. I know that there are others who appreciate that...and I appreciate them for the support and love they give me.

So again, thanks to all my supporters AND detractors. Each of has made me stronger and more complete in your own way. And I am sure that other pro players would echo my sentiments.

All the best -

Melissa Herndon
 
Nice Melissa!

You have a great attitude! Your post sounded very sincere and honest - much more so than many others are willing to be. Good for you! I do believe that good karma comes from the spirit within (it just takes a lot longer for the results sometimes)
 
Kewl

well.............i read the above.......i got my pee pee wacked in 9 ball tourn at the carom room in beloit, wi tonight. so............

just some food for thought.

*differene between a pro, and an amature..........a pro knows how to fix his mistakes.

* if ya never make a mistake, yer a lazy sob.

*if ya don't learn somthing new every day yer a stupid sob.

*and.........if i was any GOOD at this game...i sure as hell woulnd't be playin YOU in here tonight !!! fer a BEER !!!!


i shot so bad tonight........i should go kill the guy that make my cues...............ME.............LOL
 
yeah u hit em with "6" but....

tin man,
Great post!
P.S. You're still probably at least 2 balls under SJM's posts.
P.S.S.You should of never lost to that guy from Iowa. How could you "hit" S. T. with 6 then loose to that "super nobody"...f-n rediculous!!!
I would of told you "you'll get em' next time but...your past that point in your development.
muck
 
for fun.........

jrmuckadoo said:
tin man,
Great post!
P.S. You're still probably at least 2 balls under SJM's posts.

Yeah, everyone posts like a world champion for fun. Let's put up $500,000 a thread and see how good he posts.

(ALTERNATE RESPONSE) Well, if I posted as much as him, I'd be just as good...........

Later muck...........
 
  • Like
Reactions: sjm
Great post tin man, very well covered.

I was watching shane struggle a little at viking natl. and i was hearing people saying that " Oh he missed an easy shot, i coulda made that." so i turned to them and asked if they ever played for that much in one game? have they ever given such big weight? have they ever played on triple shimmed pockets?.. And got some people to encourge him on, even tho suddle but respectable to the oppenet as well, for they put on a good show
 
Tin Man said:
Yeah, everyone posts like a world champion for fun. Let's put up $500,000 a thread and see how good he posts.

(ALTERNATE RESPONSE) Well, if I posted as much as him, I'd be just as good...........

Later muck...........

Not sure I have got the juice. I suspect at those stakes, misspellings and poor grammar and generally inferior sentence structure would be great concerns.

Thanks for a good laugh, Tin Man. Reptuation coming your way.
 
Last edited:
Sjm

sjm said:
Not sure I have got the juice. I suspect at those stakes, misspellings and poor grammar and generally inferior sentence sturcture would be great concerns.

Thanks for a good laugh, Tin Man. Reptuation coming your way.

SJM,
Tin Man's standard response to anything is to pick a number add four to six zeros and claim "let's see if they can do the same thing for..." (pick your own exagerated number)
It's a classic bit and shows his comeic genius.
P.s. I'm stuck in a hotel room with him for four days this weekend-pack a freak'n lunch!
MUCK
 
Back
Top