For most people and most circumstances that is fair, although in my opinion that solution doesn't take into account the loss of time for sending the cue off to be refinished, and if he had sent it back to the seller does he get his refund instantaneous once he drops it in the mail?
i went through a dispute which paypal ruled on last week
bought a cue which featured a "pin straight 29", 13mm shaft
i received a 11.25 mm shaft which was 30" long
the seller offered a refund which didn't include paypal vig
paypal ruled that i get a full refund but i had to pick up the tab on return shipping
funds should be in my paypal acct late this week
so far apprx 19 days and counting since i filed the dispute
Lets say you spent 3grand on gift for the wife's birthday, your last 3 grand till the next payday, seller screws up on listing, and you end up empty handed on her birthday because you have to wait for a refund to hit your account, or wait for a replacement.
Does a full refund + shipping really due the buyer justice, I personally think it is a case by case basis.
Anyways the seller screwed up up the listing, don't list a cue as great condition if you don't take the time to actually look over it to make sure it is in great condition.
TRUE, the seller accepted responsibility
Seller make a reasonable offer, but I would have gone the extra mile personally if I was the seller and offered a discount on a future order to keep him happy.