WTB: A Cool Cue Case

kvinbrwr said:
OK guys I have my new Gina housed in an old beat up Joe Porper case and the 3rd last time I was in Hollywood Billiards a very well respected AZ member chided me about my lack of a decent case for my new stick.

You could imagine my embarrassment which later turned to humiliation when the same member completely shrugged my attempt to rectify the situation by buying a case from him.

The only way I can now save face is to buy a cool case. I know nothing about cases so I don't know the names or values of makers, but I'll consider both new and vintage (since my cue is a bit of both). I'd like it to be fairly high quality, I need a pocket that will hold my glasses, a 4 by 2 I guess, strap, hand tooled would be nice.

Let me see what you've got.

Thanks

Kevin


Kevin with all the great cues you have, it is hard to fine a case equal. However, the Gentleman from Missouri Rusty Melton is certainly the man who can make you a Case equal to the cues that will be placed in it. I have a feeling in a very short time that Rusty is going to be so Busy that it could tale years to get a case from him. Rusty likes to use Sheridan style patterns for much of his work, and his cases are Hand Stitched, and 100% hand tooled unlike the Machine tool leather with shallow impressions that most of us are use to seeing. Here are some photo's of Rusty's latest work in progress, folks this is the shit!!!!!!! I can't wait till this man starts on mine!!!!!!!!!!!:smile:

Seriously Folks these cases are as close to the work of the famous Chas Clements as it gets, I personally have seen no better hand tooled designs anywhere.

A1.jpg

a2.jpg

a3.jpg

a4.jpg

a5.jpg

Rusty is a Forum Member who's username is capefairpool
 
Last edited:
manwon said:
Kevin with all the great cues you have, it is hard to fine a case equal. However, the Gentleman from Missouri Rusty Melton is certainly the man who can make you a Case equal to the cues that will be placed in it. I have a feeling in a very short time that Rusty is going to be so Busy that it could tale years to get a case from him. Rusty likes to use Sheridan style patterns for much of his work, and his cases are Hand Stitched, and 100% hand tooled unlike the Machine tool leather with shallow impressions that most of us are use to seeing. Here are some photo's of Rusty's latest work in progress, folks this is the shit!!!!!!! I can't wait till this man starts on mine!!!!!!!!!!!:smile:

Seriously Folks these cases are as close to the work of the famous Chas Clements as it gets, I personally have seen no better hand tooled designs anywhere.

View attachment 88747

View attachment 88748

View attachment 88749

View attachment 88750

View attachment 88751

Rusty is a Forum Member who's username is capefairpool


WOW, just so everyone knows, this case is one Rusty just finished for me, and not in Craig's possession.
 
hangemhigh said:
WOW, just so everyone knows, this case is one Rusty just finished for me, and not in Craig's possession.

Here are some photo's of Rusty's latest work in progress, folks this is the shit!!!!!!! I can't wait till this man starts on mine!!!!!!!!!!!

I am sorry if I let the cat out of the bag, my only intention was to promote Rusty's work. In addition it was not my intention to have anyone assume that the case was in my Possession, as I stated above it was a work in progress. I should have been more clear, and again I am sorry.

Still that case is the shit!!!!!!!
 
kvinbrwr said:
John

You got me. I sent you an eMail ordering (I hope that's how it can be done) my first case from you.

Is it done yet?

Thanks

Kevin

:-) It's on the plane as we speak. I knew you were going to order and went ahead and made it and sent it out.

Thank you for the order, confirmation has been sent to your email box.

John
 
manwon said:
Kevin with all the great cues you have, it is hard to fine a case equal. However, the Gentleman from Missouri Rusty Melton is certainly the man who can make you a Case equal to the cues that will be placed in it. I have a feeling in a very short time that Rusty is going to be so Busy that it could tale years to get a case from him. Rusty likes to use Sheridan style patterns for much of his work, and his cases are Hand Stitched, and 100% hand tooled unlike the Machine tool leather with shallow impressions that most of us are use to seeing. Here are some photo's of Rusty's latest work in progress, folks this is the shit!!!!!!! I can't wait till this man starts on mine!!!!!!!!!!!:smile:

Seriously Folks these cases are as close to the work of the famous Chas Clements as it gets, I personally have seen no better hand tooled designs anywhere.

View attachment 88747

View attachment 88748

View attachment 88749

View attachment 88750

View attachment 88751

Rusty is a Forum Member who's username is capefairpool


That's pretty high praise from someone as knowledgeable as you Craig. How about Marc Turassco's work? What do you think of that? Or Ron Ross's tooling.

I mean Chas is at a damn high level and it's a pretty high pedestal you put Rusty on there. I think a lot of folks here aren't really that familiar with the work Chas did on cue cases so that they can make the comparisons themselves and I guess unless you visited Chas and understood his background in art and design as well as his vast experience in leather working and his collection of tools that are not even made any more then it would be hard to really know how special a leather worker he is.

Don't get me wrong (although many will I am sure) but Rusty is coming along like a CHAMPION and this case is probably the best tooled one I have seen to date from him - from what I can see of it. But, it's not yet in Chas' league and it's unfair to both of them for you to say so. That would be like me taking a first year cue maker and proclaiming that he is as good as Ernie Gutierrez. I'd get shot down in cold blood in short order.

To me the closest to Chas at the moment is MatCase, Marc Turcasso. His cases are the most evocative of the style that Chas Clements did (and may do again as Chas isn't dead).

But you might be right as well in that Rusty will reach the level of the great toolers of our age which include people like Ron Ross, Chan Geer, Clay Banyan, Peter Main, Chas Clements, and many others. It certainly can't hurt to build him up and get more business going his direction as the more he does then the better he gets.

As long as we are doing show and tell however I'd like your opinion on the following tooling jobs on cue cases and how they compare:

TILLMANv-CARVING2.jpg

Hybrid-Back-Closeup-Top-Open.JPG

gunslinger007.jpg

gunslinger016.jpg

spring-back-closeup.jpg

amazon012.jpg

FOR,UM...INSANITYk-BM.jpg


And this one especially:
InstrokeSign-Chas.jpg


Here is a gallery of Chas Clements' work that I have collected. I hold him in the highest possible regard as a person, an artist and a leather worker. This man's knife sheaths sell for over a thousand dollars and are worth every penny.

Chas Clement's gallery of work.

I am an ass on many levels and one of them is to stand up for what's right when it comes to the work people do. I praise good work, encourage practice and give tips when I see work that isn't quite there yet, and get really hot when I see work put on a level that it's not at yet.

You have stood up plenty of times on this forum when you feel that someone is stepping over the line hyping things so I want you to know that I respectfully disagree with your view this time, at this time.

I understand that this is your opinion. I have been told enough times that opinions can't be right or wrong. So if you feel that Rusty equals Chas then you are neither right nor are you wrong. In any case he is on the right path to get there as long as he keeps putting the knife to the leather.

I know that personally my goal is to someday for my shop to be turning out work that is as good as Chas Clements in all aspects of leather working from the artistic to the fit and finish. Knowing Chas and having been to his shop I know that this will take years and years to get close. If anyone were to compare us to Chas' work then I would respectfully show them Chas' work and point out the differences.

This is Chas' work and at the moment my opinion is that anyone decorating and building cue cases still has a ways to go to be in the same league as this man when it comes to the detail and intricacy of the tooling and the fit and finish of the entire case.

castool1_2.jpg


Respectfully,

John Barton
 
JB Cases said:
That's pretty high praise from someone as knowledgeable as you Craig. How about Marc Turassco's work? What do you think of that? Or Ron Ross's tooling.

I mean Chas is at a damn high level and it's a pretty high pedestal you put Rusty on there. I think a lot of folks here aren't really that familiar with the work Chas did on cue cases so that they can make the comparisons themselves and I guess unless you visited Chas and understood his background in art and design as well as his vast experience in leather working and his collection of tools that are not even made any more then it would be hard to really know how special a leather worker he is.

Don't get me wrong (although many will I am sure) but Rusty is coming along like a CHAMPION and this case is probably the best tooled one I have seen to date from him - from what I can see of it. But, it's not yet in Chas' league and it's unfair to both of them for you to say so. That would be like me taking a first year cue maker and proclaiming that he is as good as Ernie Gutierrez. I'd get shot down in cold blood in short order.

To me the closest to Chas at the moment is MatCase, Marc Turcasso. His cases are the most evocative of the style that Chas Clements did (and may do again as Chas isn't dead).

But you might be right as well in that Rusty will reach the level of the great toolers of our age which include people like Ron Ross, Chan Geer, Clay Banyan, Peter Main, Chas Clements, and many others. It certainly can't hurt to build him up and get more business going his direction as the more he does then the better he gets.

As long as we are doing show and tell however I'd like your opinion on the following tooling jobs on cue cases and how they compare:

And this one especially:
[
Here is a gallery of Chas Clements' work that I have collected. I hold him in the highest possible regard as a person, an artist and a leather worker. This man's knife sheaths sell for over a thousand dollars and are worth every penny.

Chas Clement's gallery of work.

I am an ass on many levels and one of them is to stand up for what's right when it comes to the work people do. I praise good work, encourage practice and give tips when I see work that isn't quite there yet, and get really hot when I see work put on a level that it's not at yet.

You have stood up plenty of times on this forum when you feel that someone is stepping over the line hyping things so I want you to know that I respectfully disagree with your view this time, at this time.

I understand that this is your opinion. I have been told enough times that opinions can't be right or wrong. So if you feel that Rusty equals Chas then you are neither right nor are you wrong. In any case he is on the right path to get there as long as he keeps putting the knife to the leather.

I know that personally my goal is to someday for my shop to be turning out work that is as good as Chas Clements in all aspects of leather working from the artistic to the fit and finish. Knowing Chas and having been to his shop I know that this will take years and years to get close. If anyone were to compare us to Chas' work then I would respectfully show them Chas' work and point out the differences.

This is Chas' work and at the moment my opinion is that anyone decorating and building cue cases still has a ways to go to be in the same league as this man when it comes to the detail and intricacy of the tooling and the fit and finish of the entire case.

Respectfully,

John Barton




John, I did not intend to get you so excited here, nothing I said was directed at you or your work in any way. This thread was started by a gentleman who stated he wanted to by a cool case, and in my opinion I have the right to offer him some ones work which I feel is fitting to hold the quality of cues he possesses. I have followed leather work where it applies to cue cases for many years out of a love for fine art, beauty and Craftsmanship, just like I have followed the custom cue field which is also my passion. I personally love traditional styles of Craftsmanship in both cues and cue cases, most people who know me understand that my taste is centered around traditional styles and designs.

I have always wanted to own some of Chas Clements work, as far as, I am concerned he is head and shoulders above any other Craftsman in this country and equal to anyone in the world that I have seen Leather work by. My opinion is based upon research I have done and what I like in designs. When I compare Rusty's to the work of Chas Clements it is based upon, the beauty, designs, and craftsmanship that are obviously apparent to anyone who takes the time to look at what this gentleman is building. I never said he was better than Chas, or even equal to Chas, this is for others to decide, but again in my opinion he is building cases in the style of Chas Clements that are a compliment to that style.

In addition, the prices charged for the work that Rusty is doing at this point in time is very reasonable, in comparison to other products being sold by others on the market today. I am betting John that Rusty's work will be sought after far into the future, I have no professional backing for this statement other than my eye for art and beauty, so again this is my opinion only time will tell.

John, I mean no disrespect to you in any way, however, if I were you I would not allow my pride to become blinding. You are a good guy who means well with you post to me, you are stating your opinion which is fine, however, you also appear to have been hurt by my comparison and that was not my intention.

Here some other photo's of Rusty's latest case:

r1.jpg

r3.jpg

r5.jpg

i6.jpg

r7.jpg

Thanks for your opinion John, but time and the public will decide if I am right or wrong.

Take care John
 
Last edited:
rusty was my vote too.

funds are tight but i will not buy another pool related item (not for my shop) until i get a case from rusty. mark my words

azb user name capefairpool

there are alot of great makers but with exception to the justis/ross cases EVERYONE else is playing second fiddle to rusty JMO
 
Last edited:
Kevin,
I'm raffling a nice Jack Justis 2x4 for just $20. Check the link in my signature if interested. Additional pics are available.
Mr H
 
manwon said:
John, I did not intend to get you so excited here, nothing I said was directed at you or your work in any way. This thread was started by a gentleman who stated he wanted to by a cool case, and in my opinion I have the right to offer him some ones work which I feel is fitting to hold the quality of cues he possesses. I have followed leather work where it applies to cue cases for many years out of a love for fine art, beauty and Craftsmanship, just like I have followed the custom cue field which is also my passion. I personally love traditional styles of Craftsmanship in both cues and cue cases, most people who know me understand that my taste is centered around traditional styles and designs.

I know your comments were not directed at me personally. Of course you have the right to recommend any one you want to and Rusty's work is worthy to hold any cue made by anyone. I have told Rusty how I feel about what he is doing and I hold his work in high regard. I do not, at this time, feel that his work is as you say, "as close to Chas Clements as it gets". That is just not true when Rusty's work and Chas' are compared side by side, when there are other case makers like Marc and Justis/Ross, and Murnak who are doing fantastic work as well. I like your enthusiasm but I think your comparison, as the famous SJM likes to say, is premature.

I have always wanted to own some of Chas Clements work, as far as, I am concerned he is head and shoulders above any other Craftsman in this country and equal to anyone in the world that I have seen Leather work by. My opinion is based upon research I have done and what I like in designs. When I compare Rusty's to the work of Chas Clements it is based upon, the beauty, designs, and craftsmanship that are obviously apparent to anyone who takes the time to look at what this gentleman is building. I never said he was better than Chas, or even equal to Chas, this is for others to decide, but again in my opinion he is building cases in the style of Chas Clements that are a compliment to that style.

But you said his work was as close to Chas' as it gets and that's not true right now. Maybe in a few years it will be closer, or as good or even better. Right now though, without question, the closest to Chas Clements in build quality and artistic design and execution is Marc Turcasso, who goes by MatCase on AZ. He has faithfully duplicated Chas' signature style and added his own flavor.

Now, I could be wrong and invite Rusty to speak up here but I don't think that Rusty is even trying to be the next Chas Clements. I see Rusty's own style emerging and it definitely ROCKS on it's own.

In addition, the prices charged for the work that Rusty is doing at this point in time is very reasonable, in comparison to other products being sold by others on the market today. I am betting John that Rusty's work will be sought after far into the future, I have no professional backing for this statement other than my eye for art and beauty, so again this is my opinion only time will tell.

Fair enough but this is not a discussion on price. If you compare apples to apples then perhaps in reality someone else's case is the better "value" on paper. Of course we all know that with things like this value is a slippery thing because a man suspends all reason when he is in love with something and sees nothing but the positive aspects of it. I am not going to bet against you regarding Rusty's work, I am SURE that if he continues then he will become a truly great case maker and leather carver. I hope he goes beyond what Chas has ever done.

John, I mean no disrespect to you in any way, however, if I were you I would not allow my pride to become blinding. You are a good guy who means well with you post to me, you are stating your opinion which is fine, however, you also appear to have been hurt by my comparison and that was not my intention.

I know that you are just enthusiastic about the guy building your next case. And well you should be because Rusty is doing great work. The person you disrespect however is Chas Clements.

Chas spent 40 years learning his craft. He has forgotten more about working leather than most leather crafters will ever learn. He owns tools that are over 100 years old and knows how to use every one of them in just the right way. When you truly take the time to compare his work with others you will surely see all the detail that makes all the difference.

This is not about me. It's about preserving a man's legacy. Imagine that a person reads this thread without my comments then they will come away with the impression that Chas' work is like Rusty's and that is not true at this time on any other level than they both work with leather. They would get that impression by the fact that you make the comparison.

envcolordesk_2.jpg


Thanks for your opinion John, but time and the public will decide if I am right or wrong.

You're welcome. I think that by showing people what Chas did then they can decide now and will know what to expect from anyone who is said to be as close as it gets to Chas' work. I personally am glad that you provided the platform to show off Chas' work as I think looking at work at this level raises everyone's understanding of what truly great work is. AND it serves as a reminder to me as to what I need to be working towards.

Here is some more eye candy, courtesy of Chas,

claytor4_2.jpg

adams5%20_2.jpg

ChasClements5LZ.jpg

ChasClements3LZ.jpg

ChasClements.2LZ.jpg

sunfacebullT_2.jpg

handstit1.jpg
 
Wow

Wow that's some gorgeous work. Proves that cue makers aren't the only remaining craftsman artists left.

Thanks for the show

Kevin
 
Well.....Thanks everyone for the kind words. For the record, I have never made a comparision between Chas Clements and myself, nor will I EVER. Chas is in a class of his own and a comparision is wrong. I'm just a plain and simple country boy makin' some cases in his spare time, not trying to top anyone, belittle anyone, or ruffle any feathers. My goal is to make a heavy duty case that looks good and protects the cues, that's it. Thanks again for the comments. Rusty
 
capefairpool said:
Well.....Thanks everyone for the kind words. For the record, I have never made a comparision between Chas Clements and myself, nor will I EVER. Chas is in a class of his own and a comparision is wrong. I'm just a plain and simple country boy makin' some cases in his spare time, not trying to top anyone, belittle anyone, or ruffle any feathers. My goal is to make a heavy duty case that looks good and protects the cues, that's it. Thanks again for the comments. Rusty

And I want to add, as I said to you on the leatherworker board, that you are doing GREAT work and really doing the teardrop style of case in a great way.

This last case that Craig showed is really nice. I'd love to see better pictures of it.

See you on LW!
 
JB Cases said:
manwon said:
I know your comments were not directed at me personally. Of course you have the right to recommend any one you want to and Rusty's work is worthy to hold any cue made by anyone. I have told Rusty how I feel about what he is doing and I hold his work in high regard. I do not, at this time, feel that his work is as you say, "as close to Chas Clements as it gets". That is just not true when Rusty's work and Chas' are compared side by side, when there are other case makers like Marc and Justis/Ross, and Murnak who are doing fantastic work as well. I like your enthusiasm but I think your comparison, as the famous SJM likes to say, is premature.


I know that you are just enthusiastic about the guy building your next case. And well you should be because Rusty is doing great work. The person you disrespect however is Chas Clements.
JB Cases said:
manwon said:
That is your opinion and nothing more, to me simply put ever thing you have said is nothing but your opinion. In my mind when you compare anything to something it is never Disrespectful, in fact it just the opposite, it is a compliment but that is just another opinion.

To all forum members who wish to learn more about MR Clements here some links.

Bio - http://www.jacksandsaps.com/aboutme.htm

Photo's Gallery - http://www.jacksandsaps.com/photo.htm

Home Page - http://www.jacksandsaps.com/

Thanks again John for your opinion, but sometimes ignorance truly is bliss!!!!!!!!:smile:
 
Last edited:
manwon said:
JB Cases said:
I know that you are just enthusiastic about the guy building your next case. And well you should be because Rusty is doing great work. The person you disrespect however is Chas Clements.
[/B]

That is your opinion and nothing more, to me simply put ever thing you have said is nothing but your opinion. In my mind when you compare anything to something it is never Disrespectful, in fact it just the opposite, it is a compliment but that is just another opinion.

To all forum members who wish to learn more about MR Clements here some links.

Thanks again John for your opinion, but sometimes ignorance truly is bliss!!!!!!!!:smile:

First thank you for listing Chas' website, it's listed on my front page and when I went to check it earlier it wouldn't come up for me and I thought it might be gone. You never know with Chas.

Now, I am not sure about your idea that any comparison is a compliment but this isn't a discussion about that so um, ok.

And you're right about the whole thing being just opinions. You give yours and I give mine, you post pictures to show off why you feel the way you do and I do the same. Hey if everyone agreed all the time we wouldn't be typing at each other because the head of the patent office 1885ish said everything that can be invented has been invented. Lucky for us he was wrong.

As you can see from the bio provided Chas has been according to himself a professional leather worker since 1964, that's 45 years as a pro and he says he started around 1952 which means he's been doing for 57 years so I was off on my statement that he's been learning (and honing) his craft for more than 40years by about 20 years.

" I was trained as a saddler and fine maker in both the European and Southwest American traditions over fifty years ago. I continue the art and craft of leatherwork in the legacy of the custom studio for Best Quality 'bespoke' work to Safari/Expeditionary standards of construction and engineering.

As fancy as it ever gets, my first commitment is to the construction. I work to 'railroad stout'. I want it to be 'horse high, bull strong, and pig-tight' before I'll let it out the door.

In making primarily 'southwestern' art, I have also learned silversmithing, lapidary work, some woodwork, something about working horn, ivory, bone, and antler. I've done some museum work out of my familiarity with older techniques and having the tools to effect the job.
" - Chas Clements

This is a man with few peers owing to the diversity of his work. He stands well above most people who decorate leather. You are right in that being compared favorably to Chas' work is a high compliment indeed and I am sure that Rusty feels very good about it.

However it's like when someone comes on the main board and says that Jasmin Ouschan is as good as Allison Fisher. That's a great compliment to Jasmin but a rather stark slap to Allison and others who have accomplished far more than Jasmin has, at the same point in their respective careers. SJM is fond of letting the records speak for themselves as the results cannot be disputed. Here the only record we have is a man's own biography and some snapshots of the type of work he produced in his 60 year career.

Anyway, you have provided us all with a greater acquaintance with not only a rising star but also a chance for some of us to revisit and others to see for the first time the artistry of Chas Clements.

Edit: came across this page while browsing Chas' pages and thought that I could never say it better, pay special attention to Chas' definition of custom and think about it when someone attaches the word to their cases. Chas' view on cue case making.

And this view on why the right sheath for a knife is important is the best description of case making that I have ever read. In deference to Adam, all the circumlocution I have ever done doesn't describe why I build cases better than this. Chas' on knife sheaths.

And although the original poster, Kevin, won't be getting a case directly from Chas, I think we can all agree that his work, and Rusty's both qualify easily as "cool cases".
 
Last edited:
kvinbrwr said:
I saw and considered that case, thanks. It does look like a deal but I think the white stitching (if that's what it is) would end up making me crazy.

Thanks

Kevin


if it is tooled in white then i can paint it for ya if anyone is interested
 

Attachments

  • roy letters.JPG
    roy letters.JPG
    48.9 KB · Views: 763
i have a case i am making for someone, ill post pics and see if your interested in having me make one for you
 
Jealousy?

It has come to my attention that what I posted comes across as jealousy and that I may have "alienated" some members here.

I will address the second part first, I have been alienating people here and on other pool related forums for a decade. Sorry but I am not the type who holds his tongue to pander to everyone in order to get more business. Obviously I don't rub everyone the wrong way because I still have more orders than I can handle. So much so that I get daily reminders from customers that I shouldn't post on AZ and get to working on their orders. Much truth in that certainly.

So to those of you who have PM'ed about JB's latest inferiority complex filled jealous rant all I have to say on that is yeah, I am jealous but not for the reason you think. I am jealous that you can choose to remain ignorant of really great, really superior, there I said it SUPERIOR, work when you see it.

Now when I say that, do I REALLY mean that our work is superior to Rusty's? Am I just using Craig's comparison to really say that we are closer to Chas' work than he is? Maybe that's what I really mean, probably. But the fact remains that Chas Clements' work stands WELL above anything I have done and well above what Rusty has done, well above what Justis has done, still above what Marc has done although he is closer than all of us.

No matter how you slice it, no matter how you "feel" about it it's true. Put all our cases up at an International Federation of Leather Guilds show and let them all be judged on fit, finish, and decoration and Chas' work will be the clear winner in every category by a LARGE margin.

Where would JB Cases end up? Who knows? I would hope near the top but if not then I would take it as something to work on and resolve to get better the coming year.

I find it to be really disheartening that so many of you will nitpick a cue to the last detail and when it comes to high-end (meaning those that cost more than a couple hundred dollars) cases you will accept anything and proclaim that it's the greatest work since the Sistine Chapel. I find it more than disheartening, I find it disgusting that some of you show so much appreciation for the art that cue makers produce and have them classified by their relative abilities and the work they produce and yet you refuse to apply that same level of sophistication to the vessel entrusted to protect your cue.

Read what Chas is about. My views on case making echo his wholeheartedly. The only difference is that I am able to make more cases.

When we make cases we do things that other people do not in ways that are not seen. These things are done based on direct advice from Chas while I was visiting him IN HIS STUDIO.

So, do I take offense and get jealous when people think that just carving on leather and "hand sewing" make a case the equivalent of Chas' work? You bet I do. Because I know how much work really goes into what he does, I know how much work goes into what we do to satisfy his standards and it hurts me to see his name casually tossed around in a comparative way that is ignorant of all that really goes into the case.

"Passion is a hard thing to conceal", said Thomas Wayne. Is there a fine line between Jealousy and Passion? I am sure there is and I am sure I am guilty of crossing it. But for those of you who think that this is all about jealousy and not about preserving a great artist's legacy all I have to say is that I am glad I have alienated you.

If you choose to be the kind of person who doesn't care to cultivate a greater understanding of the art you wish to buy then I don't care to sell to you. My customers understand what goes into making what they order from the construction to the decoration just as Chas' did.

Now, for the last time, I consider everyone's work to have merit. I think Rusty's work is great, I think Marc's work is fantastic, I think Chaz Dillon is going to be a great case maker, I think Jack Justis and Ron Ross make a great team, I think the Whittens do some unbelievable work, I think that Garth Bair at On Q Case is the best inlay man in the cue case business, Jim Murnak is continuing to put out jam up cases, I think that Steve Price can take a simply built case and make it super elegant by just the right placement of lines, I think that Ron Thomas builds very clean cases and carries on a difficult style of case, Brian Bonner is doing some really nice work, I think Erofey Evladin's stuff is fresh and funky, have I missed anyone? All of these folks are pushing the art form and I think it's great.

Do I have issues with each of their cases? I certainly do. I can look at ANY cue case including my own and find fault with it. Things I would do better than them, should have done better on mine, and things I will do better in the future. Chas Clements taught me to really look a lot deeper than I had been. He ripped the Instroke case apart at my request and taught me a lot of things I didn't know and taught me how to make them better.

In John Barton's world I am making cases on a daily basis from $5 soft cases to $2000 carved leather cases and applying Chas' lessons to all of them. So I'd say I study case making and especially cue case making a bit more than the average case maker.

Because of that I have a higher sensitivity to what is "good" and what is not. Maybe too high but it's not going to change anytime soon and I am not about to start compromising my values and beliefs when it comes to case making so that I don't alienate a few people. If you don't like what I have to say or refuse to face the truth I present to you then you don't have to deal with me personally. That's the beauty of a free market. However, you won't get me to shut up about it just because you think I am jealous. I am exactly where I want to be in life and have no one to be jealous of.

So thank you to all those that place orders with me, I promise to get my ass off AZ and in gear on your designs.

To those on the fence about whether to order a case from me - I am who I am and what you see is what you get, if I rub you the wrong way then there are a lot of other good choices.

To those of you who have developed a hatred for me, life is too short to spend hating a cue case maker for his opinions and his passion but feel free to tell everyone how much you hate me and direct them towards the object of your hatred - I need more people looking at my website :-)

Sincerely,

John Barton, green with envy. (well actually I am just green cuz I am wearing my favorite green RunOut shirt today)
 
Back
Top