Jealousy?
It has come to my attention that what I posted comes across as jealousy and that I may have "alienated" some members here.
I will address the second part first, I have been alienating people here and on other pool related forums for a decade. Sorry but I am not the type who holds his tongue to pander to everyone in order to get more business. Obviously I don't rub everyone the wrong way because I still have more orders than I can handle. So much so that I get daily reminders from customers that I shouldn't post on AZ and get to working on their orders. Much truth in that certainly.
So to those of you who have PM'ed about JB's latest inferiority complex filled jealous rant all I have to say on that is yeah, I am jealous but not for the reason you think. I am jealous that you can choose to remain ignorant of really great, really superior, there I said it SUPERIOR, work when you see it.
Now when I say that, do I REALLY mean that our work is superior to Rusty's? Am I just using Craig's comparison to really say that we are closer to Chas' work than he is? Maybe that's what I really mean, probably. But the fact remains that Chas Clements' work stands WELL above anything I have done and well above what Rusty has done, well above what Justis has done, still above what Marc has done although he is closer than all of us.
No matter how you slice it, no matter how you "feel" about it it's true. Put all our cases up at an International Federation of Leather Guilds show and let them all be judged on fit, finish, and decoration and Chas' work will be the clear winner in every category by a LARGE margin.
Where would JB Cases end up? Who knows? I would hope near the top but if not then I would take it as something to work on and resolve to get better the coming year.
I find it to be really disheartening that so many of you will nitpick a cue to the last detail and when it comes to high-end (meaning those that cost more than a couple hundred dollars) cases you will accept anything and proclaim that it's the greatest work since the Sistine Chapel. I find it more than disheartening, I find it disgusting that some of you show so much appreciation for the art that cue makers produce and have them classified by their relative abilities and the work they produce and yet you refuse to apply that same level of sophistication to the vessel entrusted to protect your cue.
Read what Chas is about. My views on case making echo his wholeheartedly. The only difference is that I am able to make more cases.
When we make cases we do things that other people do not in ways that are not seen. These things are done based on direct advice from Chas while I was visiting him IN HIS STUDIO.
So, do I take offense and get jealous when people think that just carving on leather and "hand sewing" make a case the equivalent of Chas' work? You bet I do. Because I know how much work really goes into what he does, I know how much work goes into what we do to satisfy his standards and it hurts me to see his name casually tossed around in a comparative way that is ignorant of all that really goes into the case.
"Passion is a hard thing to conceal", said Thomas Wayne. Is there a fine line between Jealousy and Passion? I am sure there is and I am sure I am guilty of crossing it. But for those of you who think that this is all about jealousy and not about preserving a great artist's legacy all I have to say is that I am glad I have alienated you.
If you choose to be the kind of person who doesn't care to cultivate a greater understanding of the art you wish to buy then I don't care to sell to you. My customers understand what goes into making what they order from the construction to the decoration just as Chas' did.
Now, for the last time, I consider everyone's work to have merit. I think Rusty's work is great, I think Marc's work is fantastic, I think Chaz Dillon is going to be a great case maker, I think Jack Justis and Ron Ross make a great team, I think the Whittens do some unbelievable work, I think that Garth Bair at On Q Case is the best inlay man in the cue case business, Jim Murnak is continuing to put out jam up cases, I think that Steve Price can take a simply built case and make it super elegant by just the right placement of lines, I think that Ron Thomas builds very clean cases and carries on a difficult style of case, Brian Bonner is doing some really nice work, I think Erofey Evladin's stuff is fresh and funky, have I missed anyone? All of these folks are pushing the art form and I think it's great.
Do I have issues with each of their cases? I certainly do. I can look at ANY cue case including my own and find fault with it. Things I would do better than them, should have done better on mine, and things I will do better in the future. Chas Clements taught me to really look a lot deeper than I had been. He ripped the Instroke case apart at my request and taught me a lot of things I didn't know and taught me how to make them better.
In John Barton's world I am making cases on a daily basis from $5 soft cases to $2000 carved leather cases and applying Chas' lessons to all of them. So I'd say I study case making and especially cue case making a bit more than the average case maker.
Because of that I have a higher sensitivity to what is "good" and what is not. Maybe too high but it's not going to change anytime soon and I am not about to start compromising my values and beliefs when it comes to case making so that I don't alienate a few people. If you don't like what I have to say or refuse to face the truth I present to you then you don't have to deal with me personally. That's the beauty of a free market. However, you won't get me to shut up about it just because you think I am jealous. I am exactly where I want to be in life and have no one to be jealous of.
So thank you to all those that place orders with me, I promise to get my ass off AZ and in gear on your designs.
To those on the fence about whether to order a case from me - I am who I am and what you see is what you get, if I rub you the wrong way then there are a lot of other good choices.
To those of you who have developed a hatred for me, life is too short to spend hating a cue case maker for his opinions and his passion but feel free to tell everyone how much you hate me and direct them towards the object of your hatred - I need more people looking at my website
Sincerely,
John Barton, green with envy. (well actually I am just green cuz I am wearing my favorite green RunOut shirt today)