I had the same experience, I have been using the Recoil Green since April on my new Becue Prime II shaft, couple of things I tried that really worked for me is when chalking just swipe the chalk in one direction on the tip, I found I need less chalk and don't need to chalk on every shot, and the best scuffer I have used is believe it or not is the Sandman shaper, I just drag it across the tip like I would drag it across the head of my rooster if you know what I mean, it doesn't remove any measurable tip material, move the tool slow and apply no pressure, the weight of the tool is enough, hope this helps, I have these tips on 3 different shafts, I love the consistency of them, best tip I have ever owned, I don't work for Bulletproof, I have tried at least 20 different tips in my lifetime and played all of them for awhile before moving on to another, I have no plan for moving on from the Bulletproof Recoil.