how do you rank yourself??? A-B-C-D??

Aaron_S said:
Since every league around here seems to have a different handicapping system, we use the ghost to determine how to rank new players who want to play in our weekly handicapped 9-ball tournaments. Our handicapping system goes from -4 (which is like an E) up to 10 (A++), and we make the fine adjustments based on the player's actual tournament performance, but we use this system as a very simple starting point:

A++, Pro - better than even money to beat the 10-ball ghost
A - same odds against 9-ball ghost
B - " 6-ball ghost
C - " 4-ball ghost
D - " 3-ball ghost
E - even money to make a BIH shot

Or, if someone already claims to know what they are, we generally let them start at that.

Aaron
Click to expand...

I always liked this especially when evaluating rotation play. It must be noted that the ghost is a reflection of how you run out. Intangables such as a strong moving game could cause an A to play a touch better if their safety and game management is better.

Everyone is correct though in stating that the pro players and shortstops exceed the A-D scale, the difference between them becomes hard to tell. Man would it be great to just have a scale to rate players that reflected their ability. Golf and bowling are the perfect handicap games because there is a fixed calcuated number that states how good you are, in pool we are all guessing.
 
I can't figure out my rank. I love beer and always will so. If I'm on serious pool I shoot ok . When I'm not shooting OK I drink beer. Then I think I'm playing jam up. Then I go bust on either a bar tab, pool, or both. Gpeezy=sucker (for a good time whew hew!)
 
Trent said:
ok my first question is what do you rank yourself??

How did you come up with that?

do you only compare yourself to league players and local heros or to professionals???

where do you think you will end up on the scale??

i think im a A-,B+ player around league players, but compared to when i play Bartrum, or dee adkins i feel like a C or C- player being that their level is so high.
Click to expand...

Trent:

I believe I'm classified as an "A" player:

Highest 14.1 straight pool run: 133
Largest "package" in 9-ball: 7-pack (an entire tournament set)
Largest "package" in 10-ball: 5-pack
Largest "package" in 8-ball: 6-pack

I had a couple room owners and one or two open players review my game, and they all agreed.

Honestly though, I don't pay attention to "where I'm at." I just play my game, study, try new things, etc.; always seeking improvement from even the most unlikely of sources (e.g. watching beginners play -- I sometimes get ideas from watching mistakes or fluked shots, and I write these down and try them at home).

-Sean
 
According to this scale, I'm between a 4 and 5, but still in the D range. I don't know how to do safes and don't use english. This sounds consistent with 9-ball ghost, BIH and total of 23 over 10 frames. I'm happy that I broke into the D range.

stuckart said:
In Arizona we have number ratings, but the definitions are generally matched up to the ABCD criteria, with maybe a little more split than that.

Here is a list of the definitions: http://www.azpoolscene.com/Ratings.aspx

10 = A
9 = A-/B+
8 = B/B-
7 = C+/C
6 = C-
5 = D+
4 = D

In addition we have a 10(-1) and 10(-2) rating that are higher. The 10(-1) is like the OPEN player or Short Stop that others have mentioned. The 10(-2) is for the PRO's.

We use these numbers to determine races in local tournaments. For example, race to your full handicap. If I'm an 8 and you are a 6, that is the race, 8 for me, 6 for you.

Put yourself up to these guidelines and let me know where you realistically sit.

ps. this is only a guide and many more columns of information go into your full rating.
Click to expand...
 
Rating is always hard to do

Currently a C+ , I don't ge tto play much do to the kids and work, but 4-5 yrs ago, probably a solid B+ here in Ohio. I wished I didn't have to take time away but family always comes first. Gettin back though, until the local hall shut-down as of last saturday. I guess getting the table at home ready to shoot on is the only option. I don't the $$ for traveling 30 mins each way to just shoot for 2-3 hrs. Trent where have you been playing at?
 
Trent said:
id say a 9, what would you list yourself as???
Click to expand...

I'm rated an 8 on the scale by a cast of Rating Committee members.

I feel I can play at the 9 scale once-in-awhile, but seem to burn out or make stupid mistakes here and there.

(If I didn't have 2 jobs, wife and 2 babies, I think a 9 or 10 would be possible......don't we all)
 
Why do players list packages as a sign of level of play? I understand that you have the capability but high runs and packages don't mean a thing when it comes to ratings. Levels are determined by consistency and ability to perform over time. Golfers and Bowlers have averages they don't say I am a scatch golfer because I shot 34 once. Doesn't make sense to me. Players were discussing straight pool and everyone was discussing their high runs to figure out who was best. A great player looked over and said, "I don't care if you ran 200, who misses the least. That is the best player!".
 
I was considered a short stop in Jersey back in the '80s.
I don't play much now and don't see as well but using the scale i would say an 8 with flashs of 9.I don't play in leagues but those that do say i would be an "A" player.
High run 14.1 several just over a 100
high run 9 ball 5 racks
I would like to extend an invitation to anyone that visits Denver to PM me and we can play. I don't gamble anymore but if you just want to knockem around i am still competitive enough.If you want action i can direct you to the place where they will gamble with you.
 
I would have to call myself a strong B player now. Though I can catch a gear now & then. I felt I was an average A when I won the VT state 14.1 championship back in 99. But with a wife, kids, work,,, I don't get to play much anymore. Hopefully our addition will be finished next year so we can get a table as I would like to pick up my play level again.

High runs:
9ball - 7
8ball - 6
14.1 - 84 (just couldn't break that 100 barrier)
 
Fairly solid B player up to 4 Beers
ok C player after 6 beers
After 10 beers I think I am an A player :eek:but truly barely a D
 
9 ball runs - 2 (balls :p )
8 ball runs - 4 (balls; just once)

both on a Valley barbox with 7 inch pockets.
9 foot Gold Crown - might as well be a 3C table for me

so, what's worse than D???
 
well lets see.
last nite i looked like a pretty good banger most of the eve, then maybe a few games i looked like a good d(4).

tonite in the local 10 ball trny i went to the finals on the loser side by sweeping the 3rd place player 4-0. went hill hill and lost . maybe played as an 7/8 or b- .
i am very inconsistant, i think due to bad eye sight ,general health conditions and maybe age (49) .
so, i think i am a 6/7 ..lol sorry for the long answer

carl
 
Haven't played much.. Pool retirement is calling..
Probably around a "B" or so..
Best,
Ken
 
Last edited:
When I am playing and in tune, A+
Lately with no regular play ( 3-5 hours a week) B+

It's kinda hard to rank yourself though. I know players here that if they run 5 balls in a row, they think they are playing pro level. I love to hit them with a 5 pack at that point!!
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top