Not sure what you mean, but I read this as, you don't want pool to be successful.
Is that right? Are you satisfied with the current state of pool?
I like to play pool. I dig cues.
Success is defined in many ways. Perhaps we just don't see it the same.
Most people people think football is successful. But I would never encourage somebody to do it. I don't think our schools should have it or support it at all. There should be no scholarships for it. It is one of the worst aspects of the educational system in the US. I laugh when people try to point out how it benefits the schools.
But most people feel football is very successful.
Many of the old rooms have closed. I think that is sad. But they were old, often not so pretty places, places not for family recreation. Do I want to see them replaced with another kind of pool room? No, I simply wish they had not gone away.
Saunier Wilhelm closed. I loved that place, and there was a lot of pool history there. Am I satisfied to see it replaced with online retailers? No.
So, am I satisfied with the state of pool? I am not entirely certain but I would say no.
But at the same time I am not so sure I like what some others envision either. I am not sure I define the success of pool the same way.
My daughter went to the pool hall with me last night. She wants to play some. She wants a cue. I find that very satisfying. I gave her future husband a JOSS recently. I am very satisfied to see him play and enjoy it.
Sometimes I think people lose sight of what they perhaps could be enjoying in favor of concentrating on their frustration with other aspects of the game or industry.
If pool gets "bigger" and more "commercialized" than it already is it might lose some of what I already am satisfied with and enjoy.
Personally, I think the best thing that any of us can do for the game is to just go play, and teach somebody to play. Just enjoy it.
I don't work in the industry, so I am not so worried about that aspect of it nor do I seek my satisfaction with matters that concern it.
But, that's just me.
.