Matchroom could have easily sanctioned their events while following the exact same path they are on now. Then they could have achieved the commercial success they’re striving for alongside the WPA. And once they achieved that and made millionaires of their players, they could have dropped the sanctioning and told the WPA their international subsidization was no longer needed and cut ties then. Same outcome but more assistance and opportunities along the way. Instead the players will have to struggle a little more during the journey than they would have otherwise.
I would be shocked if this dispute ends soon or easily, absent a near full surrender by the WPA. Wishful thinking imo.
The WPA has said the dispute is not about sanctioning anymore, if I recall correctly, and whatever the case, the standoff really revolves around control/calendar.
By sanctioning tournaments, the WPA has some control over the dates that promoters can use. That's a powerful tool.
Matchroom doesn't want to cede that control. It's tour is big and growing, and is complicated to set up: The venues, the broadcast partners, the marketing. Especially while it is young and growing, MR needs flexibility to stage its events, and naturally it wants the best dates possible.
Just look at how difficult it was for MR to set up the Reyes Cup. Ideally it would not have started two days after the Hanoi Open, but that's how it ended up. I would guess MR got penned in by the complexity of the matter.
Giving the WPA a big say in the calendar limits MR's flexibility, all to appease other promotors who are effectively competitors who invest far less in the game.
Most of the other promoters aren't really doing anything to try to grow the game and bring in a new audience. Pro pool needs broader media reach to achieve more success and can't be stuck on just Youtube and obscure pay-for websites. MR gets it.
EDIT: I forgot to add, WPA wants calendar control to get sanctioning money from OTHER promoters.
What good is its sanctioning authority, however, if MR ignores the WPA and schedules events when it wants. Other promoters could lose out and then question why they are paying the WPA sanctioning fees themselves.