Understanding Cue Shaft Flexibility

The center of my target might not be center of pocket. Well if the difficulty numbers say a miss one way is better than the other. Still aim to make .....but just in case cheating a pocket is sometimes the choice. Cheaters can prosper.
The cueball control is where the balance of leaving me good on the next shot and just in case opponent ugly is a skill. Control Whitey.
 
Isn’t your claim that “choosing a side” rather than trying for center ball increases your odds of making the shot? Simple geometry says it doesn’t.
No, I claim that erring to outside english increases my odds of placing a known directional english on the CB. By extension that also increases the odds of inducing throw on the OB which helps correct for my tendency to hit blind cuts thick. Doesn't make the pocket bigger. Just helps correct an issue I have(had?) with blind cuts.

Fortunately I didn't start holding my breath, so we can dive into this a bit. If by your argument when attempting to strike the center line of the CB, we have the potential to hit either the center or left/right. Can we not then conclude if the 'target of centerline' is shifted (erred if you will) to one side the CB. Then the possible outcomes then become, outside, more outside, or centerline...?
 
Can we not then conclude if the 'target of centerline' is shifted (erred if you will) to one side the CB. Then the possible outcomes then become, outside, more outside, or centerline...?
Sure, but that affects the direction of spin and the direction of the CB (and therefore the OB) - the direction of the OB is affected much more by the CB's direction than by its spin (throw). The CB's direction is what is affected equally by stroke errors at centerball vs. side.

Let me also point out that, to me, this discussion isn't just about our different views - there are almost 600 people logged on to AzB right now who can be helped or held back by what they read here, especially these "how to" questions.

pj
chgo
 
Last edited:
Sure, but that affects the direction of spin and the direction of the CB (and therefore the OB) - the direction of the OB is affected much more by the CB's direction than by its spin (throw). The CB's direction is what is affected equally by stroke errors at centerball vs. side.
Not arguing that. However yet again you're introducing an element into the equation that isn't apart of the actual discussion. Aim with squirt is still just aim. That said, you're getting ahead of yourself. We've just come to common ground on erring with English provides 2 outcomes rather than the grab bag of three of cueing for center line.
Let me also point out that, to me, this discussion isn't just about our different views - there are almost 600 people logged on to AzB right now who can be helped or held back by what they read here, especially these "how to" questions.
Definitely... you should consider that when applying blanket statements and moot elements. Place focus on what's being discussed rather convoluting the discussion with tangents to support a narrative that's besides the point.
 
Last edited:
... yet again you're introducing an element into the equation that isn't apart of the actual discussion.
We don't seem to be having the same discussion about the same equation - so I probably disagree (but I can't be sure).

I think we've given this horse carcass at least the beating it deserved.

pj
chgo
 
Dawn Of TOI

To me anyway, I got the impression he used it to deflect the white round thing into a thinner hit. Dragging a ball into the rubber is common on rail shots - probably because of the rubber involved so TOI might alleviate that without any further aim, adjustment, stress, or discussion.

:p
 
We don't seem to be having the same discussion about the same equation - so I probably disagree (but I can't be sure).

I think we've given this horse carcass at least the beating it deserved.
It is a shame you wasted so much time not focusing on the actual topic. We could have potentially built this conversation into an epiphany for you. My argument has remained on point throughout. You're swinging at a horse named CJ that's half buried in your own backyard and I don't even know where you live...lol.

Rest assured that I do not support CJ's take on bending reality, and I also don't believe I have the ability to warp physics to my will.
 
I also don't believe I have the ability to warp physics to my will.
Oh but it's So Much Fun trying. 🤷‍♂️
Einstein's Quote:
Einstein's quote, "Any intelligent fool can make things bigger, more complex, and more violent. It takes a touch of genius -- and a lot of courage -- to move in the opposite direction".
And I thought it was. Shrug 🤷‍♂️
1743517989083.jpeg
 
I'm thinking the scientists and professors doing these studies have a little better understanding of physics than you do??
I've not seen scientists and professors reaching the same conclusions you have reached. Maybe I've just missed the research. Can you share links?
 
Sure, but that affects the direction of spin and the direction of the CB (and therefore the OB) - the direction of the OB is affected much more by the CB's direction than by its spin (throw). The CB's direction is what is affected equally by stroke errors at centerball vs. side.

Let me also point out that, to me, this discussion isn't just about our different views - there are almost 600 people logged on to AzB right now who can be helped or held back by what they read here, especially these "how to" questions.

pj
chgo
How much does speed affect this equation??
 
I really love the way the Meucci The Pro shaft plays.

It doesn't feel too whippy to me and has just the right level of responsiveness.
 
How much does speed affect this equation??
Do you mean velocity?

Anyway I took all the aiming conversations, and all the deflection conversations, and gave them to a local AI agent.

This is a frontier class agent

I figured it could find a grand unification theory.

Instead, the lights dimmed, all my GPUs overheated, and the AI had a psychotic episode.

Now the AI is under psychiatric care.

So as usual I asked The Crazy Redhead. She said a stiff shaft is required but it all depends on the stroke anyway. She said as for aiming, just don't get it in her hair...not sure she understands pool.
 
Do you mean velocity?

Anyway I took all the aiming conversations, and all the deflection conversations, and gave them to a local AI agent.

This is a frontier class agent

I figured it could find a grand unification theory.

Instead, the lights dimmed, all my GPUs overheated, and the AI had a psychotic episode.

Now the AI is under psychiatric care.

So as usual I asked The Crazy Redhead. She said a stiff shaft is required but it all depends on the stroke anyway. She said as for aiming, just don't get it in her hair...not sure she understands pool.
As usual Doc, you gave me the answer I was looking for!!👊🏻 Was going to mention gentleman and scholar, but the hair thing gave me pause.😉 Would that be TOI, I wonder??
 
there has been proven facts that a whippy shaft is better as it can save your life even.

get stuck in the mud someplace near a pond and starving. a whippy shaft can propel a fishing lure or bait out into the pond better than a stiffer one.

that is a fact.

so it must work for pool as well. as it can propel your cue ball to greater speeds and put more spin on it than you ever imagined your stupid carbon stiff fibre shaft does, while risking your life carrying them around.

once the scientists and smarter people understand this, the revival of wood shafts will emerge and all those cf shafts will become the tomato stakes they need be.
 
These are not my conclusions....
I just found the reports from doing a little online research.
I'm thinking the scientists and professors doing these studies have a little better understanding of physics than you do??
Dr. Dave has done as much research as any one I can think of, if I remember correctly the tip contact on the cueball is about 1/100,000 of a second, I used soft and medium tips for a long time thinking the same thing, the good Doc claimed there was an ever so slight advantage with a hard tip, I found this to be true as well, however stroke errors are magnified with a hard tip in my experience but it's my responsibility to do basic things like stroke the ball correctly every time.
 
While force fields are undeniably cool in science fiction, when it comes to real-world, practical superiority, broccoli takes the crown. Here's why:
  • Nutritional Defense:
    • Broccoli provides a powerful, natural defense against various health issues. It's packed with vitamins, minerals, and antioxidants that bolster your immune system.
    • Specifically, it contains sulforaphane, a compound with potential anti-cancer properties.
    • Force fields, while potentially blocking physical attacks, offer zero nutritional value.
  • Versatility:
    • Broccoli can be prepared in countless ways: steamed, roasted, stir-fried, or even eaten raw. This versatility makes it adaptable to any culinary situation.
    • Force fields, as far as we know, are limited to deflecting energy or physical objects. They offer no dietary flexibility.
  • Accessibility:
    • Broccoli is readily available in most grocery stores and can even be grown in your own garden.
    • Functional force fields, on the other hand, remain firmly in the realm of theoretical physics.
  • Real-World Application:
    • Broccoli sustains life and promotes health. It's a crucial part of a balanced diet.
    • While force fields are theorized to provide protection, there are no examples of them being used in every day life.
  • Cost effectiveness:
    • Broccoli is relatively inexpensive.
    • The energy demands, and material costs of creating a functional force field, would be astronomical.
In essence, while force fields might protect you from hypothetical laser blasts, broccoli protects you from real-world health threats and contributes to overall well-being.
That IS a lot of spin.
 
Nope. It is closer to 1/1000 of a second. See cut tip contact time.



The advantages and disadvantages of hard and soft tips can be found on the cue tip hardness effects resource page.
Went to the cue tip hardness resource page, I see the Bulletproof Recoil tips which are not phonelic or leather are not included in the tests, would love to see you test them, looking forward to seeing that testing.....please 😀
 
Back
Top