Wow; what a turnaround in this thread.
for the offender, Abernathy (or Smabernakie if you prefer) to have gone to the length of actually getting dowels that could have the appearance and weight of a cue in their shipping boxes, makes him an even bigger POS, imo, than the guys who simply don't stick to their end of a deal. But, yes, they are bad guys, too.
He knew what he was doing was wrong and the level of deception, again imo, makes him eligible for *no leniency*.
there's plenty of "desperate" people out there who find a way to get by without doing mail fraud, deception, and harm to others.
if both bill's and joe's trades involved no cash, maybe these deals were a little lopsided, that being part of the bad guy's allure.
Glad you guys are getting made whole - def an impressive community effort. And *The Only Reason* Abernathy is sending cues back is in an effort to save his skin; not because he sees the error of his ways.
hope he gets some legal problems over this.
best,
brian kc