I think we're in agreement here. If you can hit the middle of the 10 without catching the corner of the pocket yes. If you'll catch a hair of that rail then maybe not so much.
Had this layout last week in league. I was stripes. What is your first instinct to run out from here?
I will post what I did later (This happened hill-hill and I lost my match), but wanted to get other opinions. I've set up this layout a few times on the practice table since then and I still don't see a great easy way out....
The problem is the 10 ball - it's in the jaws pretty much as displayed in the diagram. I had one shot at it before this turn and already missed it once coming off the rail, and fouled.
I haven't seen enough respect in this thread for the fact that the ten-ball is hanging and
froze to the lower left jaw....it's a problem position shot for the 13 or the 8.
...there's no rail-first when a ball is hangin.
...set it up a few times and you'll see what I mean.
...on a deep shelf table, it's even more difficult.
Bank the 13 across the corner making sure you hit it so the cue rolls up against the long rail so if you miss your opponent does not have a straight in 8 ball on the 8/10. When you bank the 13 hit it soft enough so if you miss it sticks in front of the pocket, better to miss long than short. If you do make it you will have a good angle to cut the 10 and get on the 8.
I haven't seen enough respect in this thread for the fact that the ten-ball is hanging and
froze to the lower left jaw....it's a problem position shot for the 13 or the 8.
...there's no rail-first when a ball is hangin.
...set it up a few times and you'll see what I mean.
...on a deep shelf table, it's even more difficult.
Bank the 13 across the corner making sure you hit it so the cue rolls up against the long rail so if you miss your opponent does not have a straight in 8 ball on the 8/10. When you bank the 13 hit it soft enough so if you miss it sticks in front of the pocket, better to miss long than short. If you do make it you will have a good angle to cut the 10 and get on the 8.
Thanks everyone for all the responses. Very insightful. Here is what I did, which I mentioned lost me the match - of course this situation came up hill-hill and decided everything.
-Shot the 10 first, in between the 10 and the left tit - with right english. Thinking was that would shoot the cue ball down the long rail (above the 8 ball), and I'd have the 13 in either the opposite side or corner. What happened here is the cue ball came back left, hit the left tit slightly and bounced out a bit. I still could then see the 13, but it was a very difficult cut into the corner. I missed the shot by about 3 inchs but left almost perfect shape on the 8 to go in back where the 10 was - for my opponent.
After reviewing all the responses, I think the best option is the person who said to bank/position the 13 for the bottom right corner, and leave the cue ball very near the top rail in the diagram. Pretty sure my opponent (a very mid-low level player) would have called the 8 where the 10 lies, sink the 10 and leave the 8 there.
The other option I thought of (which I know some won't like but didn't see anyone else post... ) is to play safe on the 10, slow roll the cue ball and attempt to leave it as close to where the 10 is (in the jaws would be the goal). If you can get it in the jaws, opponent cannot even hit the 8 ball without doing something crazy and potentially scratching in the process. Obviously this is very risky but with a good touch on the cueball, very doable IMO.
Even with this option, I think the bank-13-first is the best answer here.
Thanks everyone for all the responses. Very insightful. Here is what I did, which I mentioned lost me the match - of course this situation came up hill-hill and decided everything.
-Shot the 10 first, in between the 10 and the left tit - with right english. Thinking was that would shoot the cue ball down the long rail (above the 8 ball), and I'd have the 13 in either the opposite side or corner. What happened here is the cue ball came back left, hit the left tit slightly and bounced out a bit. I still could then see the 13, but it was a very difficult cut into the corner. I missed the shot by about 3 inchs but left almost perfect shape on the 8 to go in back where the 10 was - for my opponent.
After reviewing all the responses, I think the best option is the person who said to bank/position the 13 for the bottom right corner, and leave the cue ball very near the top rail in the diagram. Pretty sure my opponent (a very mid-low level player) would have called the 8 where the 10 lies, sink the 10 and leave the 8 there.
The other option I thought of (which I know some won't like but didn't see anyone else post... ) is to play safe on the 10, slow roll the cue ball and attempt to leave it as close to where the 10 is (in the jaws would be the goal). If you can get it in the jaws, opponent cannot even hit the 8 ball without doing something crazy and potentially scratching in the process. Obviously this is very risky but with a good touch on the cueball, very doable IMO.
Even with this option, I think the bank-13-first is the best answer here.
That is exactly why I would pick the 13 first, you have to get good shape off the 10 where you can't go rail first or even hit the rail after to the 13 and then get good again on the 8. 13 is not that hard to make, and you can go anywhere on the table to make the 10. The key is to hit the 10 exactly where you aim at the right speed, but even then you have a lot of options to shoot the 8 ball no matter where you end up. You'd have to be unlucky to end up having to bank it or have no reasonable shot at it. Even then you can play a rail to rail safe on it.
You should have probably shot the 13 first as shape was natural to the 10, and the shape from the 10 to the 8 is then much easier than it would have been from the 10 to the 13, especially if you aren't a pretty decent player.-Shot the 10 first, in between the 10 and the left tit - with right english. Thinking was that would shoot the cue ball down the long rail (above the 8 ball), and I'd have the 13 in either the opposite side or corner. What happened here is the cue ball came back left, hit the left tit slightly and bounced out a bit. I still could then see the 13, but it was a very difficult cut into the corner. I missed the shot by about 3 inchs but left almost perfect shape on the 8 to go in back where the 10 was - for my opponent.
I think this is a horrible choice if your opponent is good enough to be likely to be able to shoot the 8 into the pocket/10 ball like you say. Unless you are a great player (and maybe still then) this is a low percentage bank so you probably aren't going to make it and your opponent will get a shot. The guy is probably just going to make the 8 right behind your 10 and win the game as the 10 is going to have fairly minimal effect on his chances for making the 8. It's just way too easy to make the 8 right where the 10 is the way you have it diagrammed with the 10 deep in the jaws.After reviewing all the responses, I think the best option is the person who said to bank/position the 13 for the bottom right corner, and leave the cue ball very near the top rail in the diagram. Pretty sure my opponent (a very mid-low level player) would have called the 8 where the 10 lies, sink the 10 and leave the 8 there.
This is pure craziness. The chances for corner hooking him are low and take a great touch (and maybe some luck), and the chances for leaving him a decent free shot at the 8 or even scratching and giving him ball in hand are high. This option shouldn't even be in consideration IMO.The other option I thought of (which I know some won't like but didn't see anyone else post... ) is to play safe on the 10, slow roll the cue ball and attempt to leave it as close to where the 10 is (in the jaws would be the goal). If you can get it in the jaws, opponent cannot even hit the 8 ball without doing something crazy and potentially scratching in the process. Obviously this is very risky but with a good touch on the cueball, very doable IMO.