Joey, I can only speak from my experiences so I will tell you that I bought this very brand of magnetic chalk holder a few years ago and quit using it after several attempts at trying to make it work. It didn't matter where I placed the thing, on my belt or in a pocket, I always had trouble with the chalk getting knocked off and falling to the floor. I, being old-school, sit in a chair (preferably the tall spectator-type chairs w/arms) when I'm not at the table shooting. If I had the clip positioned anywhere around the front of my belt (which is where I would have prefered it to be), the chalk would get disturbed/moved by my stomach (which is bigger than it needs to be) and fall to the floor upon standing. If I wore the clip off to the side, whether on the belt or from a pocket, then the chalk part would get dislodged upon standing from the chair arms. I simply got tired of bending over to pick the darn chalk uip off of the floor several times a match or more. Now, if I was the type to stand up between turns at the table, or sat in a chair without arms, or had six-pack abs (I have a KEG :embarrassed2

, I may get away with using the thing. But.....it just didn't work out that way for me.
Maniac