I'd like to wish everyone good luck that is working on new pool tours or events. But call shot rotation games are a very bad idea.
The PCA used call shot. The rules became very convoluted as they attempted to preserve natural aspects of 9-ball at the same time. Playing two balls at once, or playing a difficult shot that might leave tough position if you miss, or in some situations waylaying a kick hoping to luck in a ball are natural and vital parts of rotation games as we know them and should not change, imo.
You cannot remove luck from rotation games by using call shot. All you can do is complicate the game unnecessarilly and remove exitement from the game.
Long races using tight pockets (near 4" for sides and corners) and worn cloth would increase the skill factor. Call shot, imo, will not.
If anybody has the old PCA rules could you please post them?
It is my opinion that maximizing the popularity of pool in general requires emphasis on the uniqueness of pool compared to other sports. That is why I believe certain aspects of pool games should not be changed. Winner breaks, win by one game (hill-hill) matches, and not calling shots are three of these aspects for rotation games that, imo, shouldn't be touched. Personally I'd add the double elimination format to that also for all pool tournaments.
The PCA used call shot. The rules became very convoluted as they attempted to preserve natural aspects of 9-ball at the same time. Playing two balls at once, or playing a difficult shot that might leave tough position if you miss, or in some situations waylaying a kick hoping to luck in a ball are natural and vital parts of rotation games as we know them and should not change, imo.
You cannot remove luck from rotation games by using call shot. All you can do is complicate the game unnecessarilly and remove exitement from the game.
Long races using tight pockets (near 4" for sides and corners) and worn cloth would increase the skill factor. Call shot, imo, will not.
If anybody has the old PCA rules could you please post them?
It is my opinion that maximizing the popularity of pool in general requires emphasis on the uniqueness of pool compared to other sports. That is why I believe certain aspects of pool games should not be changed. Winner breaks, win by one game (hill-hill) matches, and not calling shots are three of these aspects for rotation games that, imo, shouldn't be touched. Personally I'd add the double elimination format to that also for all pool tournaments.