bluepepper said:Jim, I understand the system. I like the system. I learned the system from Hal face to face. Forget about throw and sqwerve for a moment. I know they are relevant to all systems, but please put them aside for this discussion. They don't have to be taken into consideration here.
Shuffet's technique, if for different shot angles and different CB-to-OB distances, changes the distance from center CB to the side that you place the stick before pivoting, or if it changes the orientation of the stick before pivoting may work without other adjustment. Hal's requires adjustment whether it's subconscious or conscious.
With respect, I don't agree. In giving the system the "acid test" I place the CB on the foot spot and began to shoot balls from slightly off the rail at the first diamond beyond the side pockets...moving the OB in 1 ball width increments for each shot.
I approached the shots EXACTLY as taught in every instance...no adjustments. I did use sort of a Allen Hopkins mini stroke...with a slow to medium pace so as to reduce stroking errors as much as possible and found that the only times I missed was when I DID make adjustments because (mostly) certain shots looked too thick...but I would over cut them.
IMHO, those who dismiss the method as voodoo (many of whom do not even understand the system or are blending it with some other system) and who say the system is "inconsistent" are actually committing stroke errors and miss because of that.
I certainly make errors when shooting with a "normal stroke" as has every pool player who has ever lived.
I guess this debate will rage until the end of the world unless someone uses a stroke machine to test it out.
Finally, it is true that Stan Shuffett has made some modifications to the system that he now calls Pro One and all of my comments are related to THAT system and no other system so the fact that you learned what Hal was teaching at the time you trained with him (which may or may not be the same system...exactly...that he teaches now) is beside the point.
Regards,
Jim
Regards,
Jim