Matt;
You are a good man and so is Geno and Johnnyt, I believe.
I also think both Geno and Johnny possess a lot of personal experience and knowledge of our game.
It's apparent that they don't agree in their methodology for aiming and this topic had become so contentious on here that the mods had to make a subforum for it, as I know you are aware.
It doesn't surprise me that there can be such back and forth; though, admittedly, Johnny's input in the example you posted above could have been less harsh.
With that said, we're all here to share our thoughts and opinions and so I'm not sure I saw a foul.
best,
brian kc