A wrist flick is needed on some (few) shots such as the power draw or when the CB/OB are very close together. But the wrist is near the top of the list for causing stroke flaws.....crooked, off-line, etc. The wrist can flex, extend, deviate laterally/medially (ulnar/radial) and a combination of these movements (twist or curl, think Earl). Some players have fixed (pun intended) this potential problem by pre-cocking the wrist and thereby virtually eliminated movement (CJ (cocked in radial deviation), John Schmidt (cocked in ulnar deviation), Louie Roberts (cocked in extended position), Oliver Ortmann/Jimmy Reid (cocked in flexed position)), see pics. John talked about this in one of his pre-match TAR podcast. Otherwise, for all other players, on most shots the wrist should be preferably neutral (think Mike Sigel) and quiet (loose) and just "follow" where the weight of the cue and momentum (speed) of the stroke wants to take it (think Efren). If you want to use the wrist on many or most shots, good luck with that.
The elbow, on the other hand, can only flex and extend by using the biceps and triceps.......essentially the same every time without any deviation right/left/up/down, etc. If you hold the upper arm and forearm at a 90 degree angle (optimal position for a pool stroke) and then fully flex the elbow (full stroke), the skin of the forearm and bicep will touch each other at the same area every time.......you can't make it different if you tried. The only way to move this fixed alignment of the forearm/upper arm off their intended setup is to have unwanted movements of the joints above and below it........ ones that have a wide range of motion, the wrist and shoulder. For example, if the shoulder is internally or externally rotated prior to tip contact the forearm/upper arm will move automatically with it (together) right or left which will result in the stroke moving off the intended shot line. If the shoulder flexes (moves forward (down)) prior to tip contact the upper arm/forearm will go down automatically with it (together) and you'll miss hit in terms of height on the CB (elbow drop).......elbow drop is OK but only after contact.
DTL
View attachment 377249 cocked, radial deviation
View attachment 377260 cocked, extended
View attachment 377261 cocked, flexed
View attachment 377262 cocked, ulnar deviation
View attachment 377268 Neutral
Hmm......I guess that would be the opposite of a sidearm stroke, lol. That's the thing, the relationship between the forearm and upper arm will always be the same (physically impossible to change it while holding a cue with both hands)........what's moving them (together) is the shoulder, either internal/external rotation (moves tip right/left) or forward flexion/backwards extension (moves tip up/down). And the flexion/extension of the elbow will be the same no matter what position the forearm/upper arm are set at (inward, vertical, or outward like a sidearm position). Now without a cue in the hands one can supinate and pronate the forearm and change it a hair.
Some right handed players that very left eye dominate do what your talking about to a certain degree, but not like your friend.....he's way in there! lol.
Nice pics.
To just comment on some things about your setup as it relates to what we've been talking about since about post #53, you're way above the cue therefore your shoulder is not as "coiled"......upper arm is essentially parallel to the floor. Nice 90 degree angle of the upper arm/forearm. I talked about pre-cocking the wrist a few post ago and yours is slightly cocked in radial deviation and in a slightly flexed position (3rd pic) as well. All good stuff.
Another thing that can cause stroke flaws/miss hits on the CB and not talked about in this thread is the grip (mostly fingers). I noticed that your index finger is slightly off the cue (2nd pic). I do this as well because I think it kinda gets in the way or inhibits a good back swing.
Nice insights in this threat DTL.I don't know jack about 3C, lol. But I respect the game, requires lots of skill and knowledge no doubt.:thumbup:
Nice insights in this threat DTL.
We did hijack the thread a little but don't think anyone minded. LOL
FWIW: I don't think the kind of power shots I've talked about come into the games very much, other than perhaps the 8 ball and 10 ball break, where power may assist, and the rare power draw. A basic technique should suffice, especially on comp tables.
So, back to coiling, it seems it is supposed to mean having the agonist muscles in the forward stroke near full extension... am I right?
One of the points in my breaking video is that more power can be produced when a muscle in nearer full contraction, hence, the shoulder position is MR3C's stance is actually more powerful, at lease in terms of immediate acceleration. Length of stroke comes into the equation too of course.
EDIT: Come to think of it, extending the shoulder agonists, pecs, delts and lats, which attach to the humerus, actually puts the biceps and forearm muscle agonists into a stronger position of contraction. So if one keeps the elbow high, this is a stronger position.
Would be interested in what you notice in the stroke of this guy, Judd Trump, possibly the best power snooker player there has been: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-L7UIWilR8g
I understand the idea of coiling is a collecting or gathering of the muscles in and around the shoulder for a certain movement or even non movement. You're referring to positioning the shoulder, how?
You've mentioned this before , but we've never got any discussion going on about it.
Best,
Mike
As a teenager..........when you were 14, right? Are sure you didn't trip and hit your head on the rail when you were 14. :wink:
It's a Brunswick Anniversary. Yeah, it has big pockets. The one's going through the gait of the pocket are forgiving, like the one shot you're talking about, but balls on or near the rail with anything more than medium speed are super tough as the pocket facings are like a pinball machine. So it evens out. I preface most all my vids saying I'm playing on a table with big pockets. You got 10 tries to run 50......for something cheap, say $500.By the way, the table is for sale.....mint condition and plays great.:thumbup:
Been playing for 48 years. As far CTE goes, almost 2 years. I don't use it on every shot. I've figured out a way to do the pivot or sweep at address by closing either my left or right eye depending on the thickness or thinness of the cut and then getting the visual.........not gonna go into that or how I think CTE works, all I will say is that it's strong!
DTL
The vast majority of BIG runs are/were on tables with big pockets.......> 4.75". JS's 403 was on 5.5" pockets, Mosconi's 526 on 5.25" pockets, etc.
...I personally believe in the continuous straight, horizontal and vertical stroke method, and not pausing. If the player interrupts the rhythm, he may lose the timing and tempo he was trying to achieve. Another very important part of the stroke is crescendo, (increasing speed), never decelerating. Just remember, whatever number of warm-up strokes you choose to take, embed that into your game.