Ideas to Improve IPT Broadcast Production

Colin Colenso

AzB Silver Member
Silver Member
Tons of geniuses here who have watched boat loads of pool video, so let's have some of your ideas on aspects of the TV production that make watching the game a better experience.

Here's a couple of things that came to my mind:

1. Use of telestrator (lines on table) to show shot choices.

2. Balls that zoom (appear larger and show number) when being discussed regarding strategy or choice of shot.

3. CB strike graphic - shows where the CB was hit by the tip and the speed of the CB. Maybe even the spin / speed ratio on the shot.

4. Detailed stats visuals with Break percentages, B&R percentages, Visits per game averages etc.

5. Collect video of player quirks such as chalking techniques, spinning - handling cues, wrist flicks etc. Many players have some quirky smooth moves developed from thousands of hours spent with the equipment. (A bit like how the poker players play with their chips).

6. Something like the spotted CB, so we can see the spin more clearly.

7. Some high speed close up video of collisions in slo-mo.

8. 3D graphics of some physics concepts such as the parallel arc created with follow and draw.

I think viewers enjoy it when they begin to understand the deeper aspects of the game. To see and understand the game more from a professional's perspective.

Regarding the "reality tv" aspects of the production:

1. Family members / player supporters interviews.

2. Player focus segments, showing them in training, talking about their past experiences, ambitions.

Anyone else want to add suggestions?
 
The players are usually miked, but almost no one says anything while they are shooting. Vivian whistles, or says "I'm gonna bank it." Jeanette shouts "Come on, baby!"

I want to hear them think out loud, as they are down on the shot. Like, "A little inside spin here, to get around the five ball. Gotta watch the deflection, though."
 
Last edited:
JohnnyP said:
The players are usually miked, but almost no one says anything while they are shooting. Vivian whistles, or says "I'm gonna bank it." Jeanette shouts "Come on, baby!"

I want to hear them think out loud, as they are down on the shot. Like, "A little inside spin here, to get around the five ball. Gotta watch the deflection, though."

I agree wholeheartedly. That is something I always would like to know - what the pro is thinking as he is getting ready to shoot. If he could think out loud that would be great.

Jake
 
This is cool, but...

Remember, some of these cats are straight hustlers and are funny about folks knowing what they know. Hell, some pool players don't even want you to know what stick they are playing with!:confused: I'm not knocking the idea, as I would love to see what they do on the field of green. But guys like Efren, do so much crazy stuff to the QB, that he may not want you to know he's strategies because he still plays for money. Just my $.02.:D
 
Have some good commentators in the booth. Someone who can lucidly explain possible patterns/shot selections.

Have good opening/ending music..I'm sick of ESPN's.
 
Last edited:
short CB control animation

I think the key is to help the general public understand the game of pool better. I think the average schmoe knows the general methodology (although maybe not exact) of pocketing a ball. What the average schmoe has absolutely no clue about are the basics of cueball control.

I think before they show the first match of each episode, they should create a short 3D animation that shows the basic fundamentals of cueball control. This should include descriptions and effects of the follow, draw, and stun shots. This should also describe the 90 degree rule on stun shots, and how a little follow and draw can make the CB deviate from the tangent line. Lastly, the animation should desribe side english, and how this can help the CB rebound off a rail.

These fundamentals can all be adequately described in a short, minute-long animation at the beginning of each episode (just like how some of the poker shows on TV allocate a small amount of time at the beginning of each episode to explain the rules of hold'em). That way, the audience can understand what it means when the commentator says, "Manalo will probably use low-left english to come off one-rail for position on the 8."

That "CB strike graphic" that Colin talks about sounds like a great idea as well, which would really help the audience understand the finer intracacies of controlling the CB.
 
Last edited:
Gee ....

You guys sound like it is going to be an illustrated MATH CLASS .... lol

That may be good for you, but not the general public. The general public
can not program their VCR! And they still watch cartoons on Saturday
morning even though they are adults.

In depth details should be kept for private instruction, and you can pretty much tell what a player is thinking by the way they shoot the shot. The only time I describe what I am doing is when I am instructing.

Tips during the matches are okay, short and sweet. Lets not rape the
TV coverage, or we will end up with something like WWE, or whatever
they call it now.
 
Split screen video of Charlie Williams chalking his cue and another match completing to games.

Split screen video of Johnny Archer and Kid Delicous with a timer measuring who shoots first and how long it took. (insert CW as a sub for either player)

Seriously,

More Post match interviews.

The Vegas odds maker's favorites. Euro sports has this all the time.

More stats (accustats is ok) but match results from previous encounters and the scores.

Interviews with the fans.

On screen match updates for all the matches. Like the 'bottom line' on ESPN.

Quick Bios of the players during the introductions, focus on past championships and maybe home town pool room.
 
Snapshot9 said:
The general public
can not program their VCR! And they still watch cartoons on Saturday
morning even though they are adults.

Right on both counts. And in between the cartoons they tell KT how he should run the IPT.

As far as VCR's go, that is what grandkids are for.

My wife, the "Doctor", still refuses to learn how to program the VCR/DVD. LOL.

Jake
 
A few suggestions,


Get commentators that don't make the match feel like your watching paint dry, another words don't hire Jim Wych or Billy Incardona, get some commentators that are actually exciting to listen to. And for **** sakes don't let KT within fifty feet of that damn commentating booth!

Pre and post match interviews, and I mean right after the match just like you see in baseball, football, and other sports. Maybe even entertain the idea of press conferences for the bigger matches seeing how the tournaments are going to be broadcast live in Asia and Europe, you might need a translator for our friends overseas but this shouldn't be a problem seeing how the players in the IPT field speak a variety of languages.

Have those entertaining introductions for the players, like Mosconi Cup style where the players come right down through the crowd giving the fans high fives, makes the event more interactive for the fans and makes for excellent TV, which is what this thread is about LOL!

Just a few ideas to entertain.
 
I think it's important to have a full table view of shots. I hate it when TV production ends up ruining the experiance. I for one could care less about seeing the ball go in the pocket from a pocket cam. I'd prefer to see the big picture. ie. CB and OB paths.

JMHO
 
Snapshot9 said:
You guys sound like it is going to be an illustrated MATH CLASS .... lol

That may be good for you, but not the general public. The general public
can not program their VCR! And they still watch cartoons on Saturday
morning even though they are adults.

In depth details should be kept for private instruction, and you can pretty much tell what a player is thinking by the way they shoot the shot. The only time I describe what I am doing is when I am instructing.

Tips during the matches are okay, short and sweet. Lets not rape the
TV coverage, or we will end up with something like WWE, or whatever
they call it now.

I'm with you Scott. The ideas for improvement are things geared towards us hard-core enthusiasts, which is not the market the IPT needs.

However I am a bit worried that the current plan is to make the broadcasts into less of a pool show and more of a reality show, the antithesis of what Colin is suggesting.

Dave
 
Tom In Cincy said:
Split screen video of Charlie Williams chalking his cue and another match completing to games.

Split screen video of Johnny Archer and Kid Delicous with a timer measuring who shoots first and how long it took. (insert CW as a sub for either player)
This is hysterical and had me laughing out loud... too funny Tom! :D

Colin Colenso said:
Regarding the "reality tv" aspects of the production:

1. Family members / player supporters interviews.

2. Player focus segments, showing them in training, talking about their past experiences, ambitions.

Anyone else want to add suggestions?
They couldn't show #1... too many cheaters in the pool world. ;)
 
DaveK said:
I'm with you Scott. The ideas for improvement are things geared towards us hard-core enthusiasts, which is not the market the IPT needs.

However I am a bit worried that the current plan is to make the broadcasts into less of a pool show and more of a reality show, the antithesis of what Colin is suggesting.

Dave
I actually think the reality tv aspect is a great idea. But they are also planning for some live broadcasts and I assume that with production of 10+ international events yearly in the future, a lot of the coverage will be actual tournament coverage.

It may be that myself and a few others are particularly fond of stats, informative graphics. I know I would have been bored senseless trying to follow World Poker coverage without graphics that explained the game, odds advantages etc.

I remember reading an article that stated that a lot of the success of Poker on TV came from the audience being able to follow the game via the graphics (player's cards, win percentage odds etc).

There has been a lot of advancements in other sports using graphics, such as ball tracking software for tennis and cricket.

Anyway, it never hurts to have more options to consider.
 
Colin Colenso said:
Tons of geniuses here who have watched boat loads of pool video, so let's have some of your ideas on aspects of the TV production that make watching the game a better experience.

Here's a couple of things that came to my mind:

1. Use of telestrator (lines on table) to show shot choices.

2. Balls that zoom (appear larger and show number) when being discussed regarding strategy or choice of shot.

3. CB strike graphic - shows where the CB was hit by the tip and the speed of the CB. Maybe even the spin / speed ratio on the shot.

4. Detailed stats visuals with Break percentages, B&R percentages, Visits per game averages etc.

5. Collect video of player quirks such as chalking techniques, spinning - handling cues, wrist flicks etc. Many players have some quirky smooth moves developed from thousands of hours spent with the equipment. (A bit like how the poker players play with their chips).

6. Something like the spotted CB, so we can see the spin more clearly.

7. Some high speed close up video of collisions in slo-mo.

8. 3D graphics of some physics concepts such as the parallel arc created with follow and draw.

I think viewers enjoy it when they begin to understand the deeper aspects of the game. To see and understand the game more from a professional's perspective.

Regarding the "reality tv" aspects of the production:

1. Family members / player supporters interviews.

2. Player focus segments, showing them in training, talking about their past experiences, ambitions.

Anyone else want to add suggestions?

The IPT should take notes from the Golf channel. Just about everything they do is very good.

I especially like the way they break down a players swing
 
Cameron Smith said:
The IPT should take notes from the Golf channel. Just about everything they do is very good.

I especially like the way they break down a players swing
Doesn't KT own the golf channel?
 
If you want to improve the IPT broadcasts, first of all, you have to get to the basics.

1. Get them on TV timely. How long are we going to have to wait for the King of the Hill broadcast? It has been months.

2. Get these broadcasts on major networks, not networks that you can only receive if you have a certain cable provider or a certain dish network. They should be on networks that everyone has access to.

3. Get some good announcers, who can create the interest and excitement that the anouncers do during the World Series of Poker. Those guys are very good at what they do.

Cover the basics and then you will have time to fine tune the other points.
 
STOP explaining the rules! Really, we are all not fourth graders. Just play the game and comment on it without explaining the rules every ten seconds.

The public will get it. If they want to know the rules in detail they will go to the website to get them.

I have watched tennis, racing, boxing, spelling bees, cheerleading, curling, diving, and who knows how many other sports throughout the years and none of them have the degree of hand-holding that pool has - not even close. Poker - not a sport - has a fair amount of explaining of technical terms but they do it in a non-intrusive, non-patronizing way.

John
 
Back
Top