Poolplaya9 said:she seems to be doing what we all did at one time, particularly when we were still learning. Entering events that were way over our head because we enjoyed it, and for the experience, in an attempt to get better.
Poolplaya9 said:would i personally enter an "open" tournament that regardless of the "open" name i knew was really just a pro tournament that was specifically intended for the pro level players, and that would consist almost exclusively of pro level players, and especially if it is being streamed/televised/reported on? Hell no.
As I had already clearly spelled out in the rest of the post you quoted from, just because I wouldn't personally do it doesn't necessarily mean there is anything wrong with it. I would certainly be too embarrassed, but if somebody else isn't, then more power to them. Who am I to tell them they can't play in an OPEN tournament? I bet most of the rest of the players in the tournament were glad to have her, and in fact I bet they wish dozens more just like her would come.Icon of Sin said:??? Lol...
In addition, she has been hired to do it--it is (one of) her job. She wasn't hired because of her skills (and she and the rest of us all know it and nobody including her and CW is trying to make it seem otherwise), she was hired because of her beauty, her poise, her ability to be well spoken, and her demeanor. Those things bring a professional image to a brand, and they get exposure for it. She is doing these things well, and you don't get the most exposure for the brand by playing only the local tournaments.
In that regard it might just be a brilliant move actually. You can sponsor any other "real pro" and get a little exposure all the time, and a little more here and there when and if they manage to win a tournament, or you can sponsor a bombshell who is trying to improve her game and that has great poise and personality and that will attract worldwide attention left and right all the time everywhere she goes.
So is Shanelle meeting the requirements for the tournaments that she is entering, which are open tournaments to anyone that can pay the entry? Check.
Is she having fun by doing something she really enjoys? Check.
Is she trying to gain experience and improve? Check.
Is she delivering on what she was hired to do, which is to represent a brand in a professional manner and get them exposure? In spades.
I just can't find any real fault with what she is doing. What has she does wrong? I understand the position that many people have (and even feel a bit of it myself) that you just don't want to see crappy players in tournaments (but it really isn't a good and rational reason), and because it is a "slap in the face" to the sport (not necessarily real and rational either). But A) this is like Karaoke, who am I to say who can and can't go up on stage to do a song on the OPEN mic. I may not like some of the singers, but tough crap for me. And B) even if you really want to insist on still thinking there is something wrong with it (even when it isn't really rational), it is the promoters fault for having open tournaments to begin with, not the persons fault who did nothing wrong by entering one. Lash out at all the promoters who make their tournaments "open" so you won't have to see those "crappy" players any more.