Everybody's opinion is welcome. But after reading Genes thread on making a champion I was wanting to know if anyone could be made into a world beater on a bar box or big table? Or do you think you have to have a certain quality about ones self.
i would have to say that no not just anyone could be made into a world beater. even with all the love for the game and training and willingness to practice in the world if a person does not have a certain appitude for playing great pool to begin with they will never be able to rise to that level.
brian
IMO all the elite players I know were great players pretty early on in their career. Then they get seasoning that teaches them how to win.
I don't think anyone could take a B player thats been playing for ten years and make him a world beater. If the guy had the talent, drive and desire required to play at a high level he would already be there.
Most things I have been around it seems that you can reach a certain level just on hard work but to be truly great there has to be some amount of natural aptitude or talent there.
Bob, I agree with you.Especially the part about the early development program. I remember first playing pool as a youngster of 11, then becoming involved in Little League Baseball. Having coaches that understood how to explain the fundamentals, was critical to development. It is why Jr. High Sports Programs are the foundation of scholastic sports. Your observation of the 13-14 year olds displaying the skills to take them to #1 is spot on.I think if you want to be the best the world has ever seen at something, you have to start on it at age 7. If you want to be #1 during your lifetime, you have to start by the time you're 14. If you want to be pretty good, maybe you can start when you're 21. I've heard recent studies that show that you learn best and most deeply about the time your body is growing quickly. I might be off a little on the ages, but you get the idea. Think Lindrum and Mozart.
So, I think part of it is timing. A follow-on idea is that if you want a person or group to be truly competitive, you need to have a related youth program. A serious program. If you wait until high school, it may be too late.
As for the OP, it depends a lot on the player, the goals, and the resources. When did he start playing pool? Is his goal to win a world championship or the local 8 ball league? With reasonable effort he can be better than 99.999% of all people who play pool, but that just gets him to #1000 in the world. That's probably good enough to win the local league championship.
Forget about pool, look at Basketball or Football or Baseball. There is real money there. There are THOUSANDS AND THOUSANDS of 10 year old kids playing their hearts out, with the goal of being a pro when they grow up. For you that say anyone can do it, why is it that only a fraction of a fraction of a percent will make it onto a pro team when they grow up?