This thread really went sideways. Like someone else said on here, who really was the BEST! It changed from day to day and week to week, just like it does today. What I will say unequivocally is that David Matlock was a BAR TABLE LEGEND! And he could play pretty sporty on big tables too!
Someone asked me about Bakersfield Bobby. He and Weldon Rogers were two more great "big ball" bar table players. I would rate these two just under Keith, Buddy and Matlock. IMO those last three were the best I ever saw, at different times and places. I don't think Bobby or Weldon would have gone out of their way to play these three guys. In fact, probably the opposite is true.
Once again, Keith was the most exciting and entertaining. Buddy was the most methodical and consistent, and David was the most overpowering and dominant on a small box. Three different styles for three GREAT players. They were all champions because they could come with the big shots under pressure, they had a burning desire to win and they had no quit in them. All three could play for days if need be.
There was another guy who came up here a few times from Mexico in the early 80's named Canella. He was a good looking Mexican guy who was like the Mike Sigel of the bar tables. He just played perfect pool for days on end. I don't know if anyone ever beat him back then. He made some money and returned to Mexico where he succumbed to drugs and alcohol. When he returned to the states a few years later, he wasn't the same guy. Who else remembers him? He played mostly around Texas. Ironman?