Hence the difference between you and I.
One of our stances takes into consideration the future of American pool, one does not.
I would rather lose with dignity, than win like a whore with my skirt over my head.
In other words, there is honor at stake.
There is the image and integrity of American pool (and players) at stake.
You complain that American pool is going nowhere in one breath, and in the next you want to score a " fix " at any cost.
Hopefully you can see how one interest does not serve the other.
Your idealism is admirable, and I myself try to subscribe to it to the greatest extent possible.
Still, suggesting that the recapture of our honor should be the main priority here is, to me, a bit short-sighted. I agree that it's part of what we're shooting for, but the international image of American pool has been tainted by unusually poor results in the most visible overseas competitions.
More than anything, that means the World 9ball Championship, the China Open, the World Cup of Pool, the Japan Open, and the Mosconi Cup, which are the only events having a huge international audience. I might be wrong, but I don't believe America has a win in any of these events in this decade.
Competitively, America has fallen way behind Asia and Europe and to quickly dismiss the opinion of those most concerned with the quality of the team as far as competitive performance is concerned is really inappropriate.
Your assumption that a recapture of honor is the key to the future of American pool is your opinion, and perhaps you are right. For me, the key to the future of American pool is a return to international competitiveness and, of course, maybe I'm wrong ... but for me and those who see it the way I do, we aren't thrilled that three of America's best five players (Dechaine, Archer, Morris) won't been on this team.
That said, though, I fully support Mark Wilson. His approach to trying to recapture the Mosconi Cup is the one he believes in and perhaps he has hit on a winning formula --- we'll find out in December. In this very thread, Mike Dechaine has endorsed Mark's choices as being solid. I have done the same and wish them all luck. Mark Wilson, one of the greatest American instructors ever, is the perfect guy to get our guys back to being competitive.
Playing good pool will be the path to re-establishing the credibility of American pool and, in my opinion, nothing short of that will get the job done.
I really like the way you think, Mr. Bond, and you and I have the same high hopes for the future of American pool, but I have high hopes for Mark's team and I'll measure their performance by the final score of the Mosconi.