Doesn't matter. (Long)
Being a new poster on these forums, I doubt my opinion will matter much but I'm going to weigh in anyway.
In advance, please forgive me now as this will be a somewhat lengthy post/reply.
Personally, I do not mind paying for bottled water or tap water on ice. The local venue I play at is also a dealership and thus his hours are fixed where he closes the doors at 6 pm unless one of the APA leagues is playing.The owner charges 50 cents for bottled water. 55 cents for canned sodas and offers a few snacks. No alcohol is served.
Being diabetic, I can not indulge in the sodas or the snacks so I'm limited to to just the water. Granted, this appears to be a small support for the room and the particulars involved are for another thread so I'll get back on track here.
The way I see it, is that if the owner is charging for tap water on ice, every time he turns that tap on and that ice machine is making ice, his water meter is spinning. This equates to the fact that he is spending money to not only supply the toilets but also to supply the consumer with tap water on ice. This is not free for him/her. Is it really fair for that owner to just give that glass or cup of water on ice away? If they serve it in a glass, there's the associated costs involved in cleaning that glass when you're done which means that this also requires running water and thus that meter is spinning again. Granted it may only be pocket change or chum change but in the long haul, it will add up over time
If the owner chooses to make it gratis, then that is his/her choice but there is nothing wrong with charging for it.
As for bottled water, a dollar is not an exorbitant amount and I wouldn't fuss about it. It's cheaper than going to the ballpark and paying $4-$6 dollars for the same bottle of water. In any case, that room owner must go to his wholesale club to pick up the case(s) of water which also incur costs unless it is being delivered and then there will be a delivery charge. Time, fuel at $3 +/gallon, the electricity (another meter that is spinning incurring costs) to chill it, etc are all associated with this. The list can go on and on. So why shouldn't a room owner charge for water either way?
In supporting the room, I am there on my days off (Friday-Monday) when he is open (closed on Sundays) all day plus I operate a league there on Saturdays that bring him in a little extra table time on a day when there wouldn't be anyone there other than customers kicking tires and thinking about purchasing a pool table.
He does give me perks but I don't ask for them or demand them and sometimes I debate with him a little that I am no different than anyone else when it comes to table time. but he's never given me free water. I gladly pay that 50 cents for his bottled water and pay whatever he charges me for table time.
Again, please forgive for the lengthy reply.