Agreed. It amazes me the abundance of predominantly short-rack rotation players who think -- without having ever tried it -- that straight pool "is easy, for you can shoot at any ball, and always adjust your patterns accordingly if you miss shape." They'll give you the impression they can run racks and racks without ever missing.
But once you play this wonderful game, you realize just how tough it is. Position play isn't played in "zones" like it is in short-rack rotation; it's mere inches or fractions of an inch in some cases. Countless examples, but the obvious one -- that even short-rack rotation players understand -- if you miss shape on your break ball, you're going to be playing a safety rather than going into the rack and continuing the run.
One of the funny things that the staff would do at the 14.1 Challenge, is when we get one of these types that pony up the fee to have a crack at it, is friendly-elbow each other and watch what we call "9-ball straight pool" -- where the cue ball runs around the table and the player struggles to play shape using large swaths of the table. Most often, the run unceremoniously ends with either a miss on a "white flag" shot, or getting in trouble with the cue ball being snookered behind a cluster or what-have-you, or a wing-and-a-prayer shot on the last ball on the table, with little hope to hit the rack.
Lesson? Those that think this game "is easy" have a rude awakening coming when they actually play this game.
I agree, a slow pace is actually an albatross around the player's neck. First, it will get you in trouble with your opponent, and the ref that's called over. Second, it prevents you from getting in the natural rhythm of running balls -- the natural rhythm of "solve the problem, execute the solution" with minimal fuss.
There are few things more enjoyable than to watch a clockwork-like player sinking balls on a cadence. Anyone who's ever watched Dave Daya play straight pool (his best game, IMHO) knows what I'm talking about. Blink, and you missed two or three shots. You actually watch the pattern-solving happen in REAL TIME, not an excruciatingly slow pace that puts you to sleep.
-Sean