jay helfert said:I don't want to throw rain on anyone's parade, but Newman was brilliant in the role of Fast Eddie in The Hustler and should have won the Oscar that year. TCOM was an ego piece for Newman and his opportunity to reprise the Myron McCorminck role of the stake horse (in The Hustler). It should have just been named The Hustler II. After reading the book TCOM, I was disappointed that he and Richard Price, the screenwriter, weren't more faithful to Walter Tevis' story, which had many brilliant lines in it.
By the way, Newman did not do as good a job as McCormick did in the original. I thought McCormick played the part to a 'T'! Watch both movies and compare the parts of the two stake horses and tell me which one is more believable. Newman was a great Fast Eddie but only a fair "Charlie".
I agree the stake horse in "The Hustler" was played perfectly as was Fast Eddie. The role can't be compared with Newman in TCOM because Charlie was never a big time player, his perspective was entirely different than that of one time great "Fast Eddie" trying to come back via somebody else. His role was more like that of somebody who almost made it to the bigs in baseball driving his kid to fulfill his dreams.
I thought he did a good job as did Cruise, but TCOM was not near the quality movie that "The Hustler" was.
Favorite line has to be McCreedy line though I can remember it well enough to quote it. The nightmare one and it getting worse and worse.