The knowledeable collectors won't be influenced by anyone's list of "elite" cuemakers. They know who they like and why.
However it will probably influence the thinking of many who are looking at high end cues for the first time. Seeing cues categorized by an "authority" will probably lead them to repeat that list to other less knowledgable people.
It's Cornerstone's opinon and right to classify cues in any way they see fit to do so. I guess that there might be some cuemakers who don't make "the list" who might not feel so good about it.
If another website makes a list of who they feel are the best cuemakers then it will be the same thing. All it will do is reinforce that this is all subjective and based on ever fluctuating criteria.
Marcus said that real cuemakers only do everything by "hand". There are some Chinese cuemakers who qualify as masters if one uses just that description.
Throughout history craftsmen have used jigs and templates to make their products. A computer is no different.
Recently I completed two cases where almost every part on it was designed using the computer. Still I spent more than forty hours in total on this project just designing the parts. Along the way I used the laser to cut the parts from pattern cardboard to test them. I also made models using printed paper that I cut out with scissors and taped up with scotch tape. Now, I could never have completed these cases without a tool that allowed me to tweak the design along the way. If I had to redraw the initial design by hand with each change then I wouldn't have done these cases.
Using a computer to aid in design allows a degree of artistic freedom in design that was next to impossible in the time without it. But the fact is that this is just one step in the process. Using a computer to control a router bit is no different than using a jig or a template. When someone uses a pantograpgh then the template was cut by CNC. The advantage however to using a computer to control the output is that the operator has the advantage of flexibility. Longer, wider, shorter is all a matter of adjustment.
But, as anyone who uses CNC can attest to it is NOT as simple as making a shape and throwing wood in the machine and out comes a cue on the other end.
So a master cuemaker is not defined solely by the tools he uses. He is defined by the product that he produces and the demand that such product elicits. And in my opinion there are many more than 15 cuemakers who are rightly in the master class. Of those which are the "elite" is certainly not a debate that will be settled by one dealer's list. However one way to get attention is to make such a list and for that it is a smart move on Cornerstone's part to do so.
However it will probably influence the thinking of many who are looking at high end cues for the first time. Seeing cues categorized by an "authority" will probably lead them to repeat that list to other less knowledgable people.
It's Cornerstone's opinon and right to classify cues in any way they see fit to do so. I guess that there might be some cuemakers who don't make "the list" who might not feel so good about it.
If another website makes a list of who they feel are the best cuemakers then it will be the same thing. All it will do is reinforce that this is all subjective and based on ever fluctuating criteria.
Marcus said that real cuemakers only do everything by "hand". There are some Chinese cuemakers who qualify as masters if one uses just that description.
Throughout history craftsmen have used jigs and templates to make their products. A computer is no different.
Recently I completed two cases where almost every part on it was designed using the computer. Still I spent more than forty hours in total on this project just designing the parts. Along the way I used the laser to cut the parts from pattern cardboard to test them. I also made models using printed paper that I cut out with scissors and taped up with scotch tape. Now, I could never have completed these cases without a tool that allowed me to tweak the design along the way. If I had to redraw the initial design by hand with each change then I wouldn't have done these cases.
Using a computer to aid in design allows a degree of artistic freedom in design that was next to impossible in the time without it. But the fact is that this is just one step in the process. Using a computer to control a router bit is no different than using a jig or a template. When someone uses a pantograpgh then the template was cut by CNC. The advantage however to using a computer to control the output is that the operator has the advantage of flexibility. Longer, wider, shorter is all a matter of adjustment.
But, as anyone who uses CNC can attest to it is NOT as simple as making a shape and throwing wood in the machine and out comes a cue on the other end.
So a master cuemaker is not defined solely by the tools he uses. He is defined by the product that he produces and the demand that such product elicits. And in my opinion there are many more than 15 cuemakers who are rightly in the master class. Of those which are the "elite" is certainly not a debate that will be settled by one dealer's list. However one way to get attention is to make such a list and for that it is a smart move on Cornerstone's part to do so.