this is the year cornerstone steps it up !!

Status
Not open for further replies.
The knowledeable collectors won't be influenced by anyone's list of "elite" cuemakers. They know who they like and why.

However it will probably influence the thinking of many who are looking at high end cues for the first time. Seeing cues categorized by an "authority" will probably lead them to repeat that list to other less knowledgable people.

It's Cornerstone's opinon and right to classify cues in any way they see fit to do so. I guess that there might be some cuemakers who don't make "the list" who might not feel so good about it.

If another website makes a list of who they feel are the best cuemakers then it will be the same thing. All it will do is reinforce that this is all subjective and based on ever fluctuating criteria.

Marcus said that real cuemakers only do everything by "hand". There are some Chinese cuemakers who qualify as masters if one uses just that description. :-)

Throughout history craftsmen have used jigs and templates to make their products. A computer is no different.

Recently I completed two cases where almost every part on it was designed using the computer. Still I spent more than forty hours in total on this project just designing the parts. Along the way I used the laser to cut the parts from pattern cardboard to test them. I also made models using printed paper that I cut out with scissors and taped up with scotch tape. Now, I could never have completed these cases without a tool that allowed me to tweak the design along the way. If I had to redraw the initial design by hand with each change then I wouldn't have done these cases.

Using a computer to aid in design allows a degree of artistic freedom in design that was next to impossible in the time without it. But the fact is that this is just one step in the process. Using a computer to control a router bit is no different than using a jig or a template. When someone uses a pantograpgh then the template was cut by CNC. The advantage however to using a computer to control the output is that the operator has the advantage of flexibility. Longer, wider, shorter is all a matter of adjustment.

But, as anyone who uses CNC can attest to it is NOT as simple as making a shape and throwing wood in the machine and out comes a cue on the other end.

So a master cuemaker is not defined solely by the tools he uses. He is defined by the product that he produces and the demand that such product elicits. And in my opinion there are many more than 15 cuemakers who are rightly in the master class. Of those which are the "elite" is certainly not a debate that will be settled by one dealer's list. However one way to get attention is to make such a list and for that it is a smart move on Cornerstone's part to do so.
 
cornerstone

hi ,why not rate your cues by playabillty instead of maker or your elite list ,a lot of great makers are dead now.let forum help with cues list.iam collector myself but also a p[layer any thoughts ,used to live in e burg too
 
JB Cases said:
So a master cuemaker is not defined solely by the tools he uses. He is defined by the product that he produces and the demand that such product elicits. And in my opinion there are many more than 15 cuemakers who are rightly in the master class. Of those which are the "elite" is certainly not a debate that will be settled by one dealer's list. However one way to get attention is to make such a list and for that it is a smart move on Cornerstone's part to do so.

Very well put!!! While I have zero experience making cues (or virtually anything else) I have spent many hours in Ernie's shop watching him make his Ginacues. He uses CNC for many of his steps, but your statement that it's not "insert wood here, extract cue here" couldn't be truer.

I believe Ernie feels that his cues are the best quality they have ever been in his 40 something years of making them, and certainly if he is making a new or unique design, it would be MUCH faster for him to do it "by hand" but he feels he produces a better product with the modern techniques.

As for Pharaoh's attack on the credentials of Cornerstone, Pharaoh, I think you are a bit misguided. For certain we all have opinions, but how would you define expertise? When we want to know if a Balabushka is real we send it to Pete Tascarella to authenticate. If he says it "is" or "is not", does that make it so? No, it's just his opinion...an opinion that has become valued by many due to his experience, but an opinion none the less.

Cornerstone has had many, many high-end cues pass through their hands, more than most. Are they a dealer, yes. Might they have some financial interest in certain cuemakers being perceived in a certain light, maybe. But the fact remains that their opinions are generally very well educated and respected by many in the community, and that as far as I know is the only thing that makes anyones opinion more "expert" than anothers...the perception.

Do you need to share the opinion that they are "expert", certainly not. I have testified in court on several occasions as an "expert" witness in my field. Was it based on some widely held belief that the opinions I had were unassailable?, no. It was based on the fact that they could stand before a group of "laymen" and point out my credentials, my standing in that community and convince them that my opinion was "well informed". It's not to say the other side couldn't find an "expert" witness with a different opinion, as they often do.

So, I think it's fine for you to hold an opinion not in concert with Cornerstone, but to think you can somehow erase their "perceived" standing in the community through your boorish attack is, in my OPINION, futile.

It sounds as though you're concerned about their "list" of elite cuemakers. I think they are welcome to their opinion of that list, as are we all. While their list may not match mine, I don't think it's a statement just about quality or craftsmanship, but rather THEIR opinion of the makers who they perceive as "elite" in terms of reputation.

I will base my decisions about *my* list on personal experience, the opinions of others I respect and the makers standing in the marketplace.

No individual or website will make these decisions for me but some opinions, including Cornerstone's will be included in my thought process.

My $.02 and prob'ly overpriced at that.

Joe
 
junksecret said:
Cornerstone has had many, many high-end cues pass through their hands, more than most. Are they a dealer, yes. Might they have some financial interest in certain cuemakers being perceived in a certain light, maybe. But the fact remains that their opinions are generally very well educated and respected by many in the community, and that as far as I know is the only thing that makes anyones opinion more "expert" than anothers...the perception.

Under normal circumstances you would be right to assume that BG, being a dealer who handle cues day in and day out, possess some modicrum of expertise. However, he has time and time again proved that his opinions re custom cues are quite worthless.

In any case, he didn't merely make an announcement: He asked for our opinions. And I give it to him, as did Pharoah, as did yourself.

-roger
 
buddha162 said:
Under normal circumstances you would be right to assume that BG, being a dealer who handle cues day in and day out, possess some modicrum of expertise. However, he has time and time again proved that his opinions re custom cues are quite worthless.

In any case, he didn't merely make an announcement: He asked for our opinions. And I give it to him, as did Pharoah, as did yourself.

-roger

I agree that he asked for opinions, but I think he was after opinions about his site, not attacks on his character. I must confess I have done zero business with Cornerstone but I have visited his site and found many of his cues to be from *my* elite list so his opinion holds some weight with *me*.

I respect everyone's right to an opinion, I however felt the attack was a little "off-topic" since I never heard them claim to be "experts", perhaps I should re-read the thread. In any event your opinion has now been recorded in my brain and will carry whatever weight my small brain assigns to it, and for that I thank you.

Joe
 
hi ,why not rate your cues by playabillty instead of maker or your elite list ,a lot of great makers are dead now.let forum help with cues list.iam collector myself but also a p[layer any thoughts ,used to live in e burg too

good idea.i know this is a complicated and touchy subject,but the 15 elite cuemakers in the world may not be the 15 who make the best playing cues too.

i know it is a subjective issue,but certain cues are known by many to play better than others.
 
LM0152~Hot-Buttered-Popcorn-Posters.jpg



Hey Guys...we should stop it here. It is not leading anywhere.
I expected that to happen...because it was really a very subjective matter of choosing the Top 15 elite Cuemakers.

Just as i said in my 1st post. You ask 5 people for the 3 best Basketball Players in history and you get 5 different answers.
This thread was doomed from the beginning to get hot.

So before it gets ugly the Thread should be closed.
It could do harm to the business of Cornerstone.
He asked for opinions and i think he knows now what we think about that.
 
Bill is my friend. He is in the business of selling cues. He genuinly loves them too. He has found a way to earn a living doing something he loves-we should all be so lucky.

the above statments are facts from my knowlege of Bill, cues, and my opinion. Just as the fact remains I cant spell its clear to many people here who I consider friends(I appericate everyone tollerating that too)


I'm a marketer, I have done pretty good over the years, until 3 weeks ago, i'm unemployed now, but I have a new gig lined up, so I'm ok. Back to Bill.

Bill has to make $$$ nobody can work for free, when he announces the names of the new sites then the shit is really gonna hit the fan, you aint seen nothing yet.:D sorry Bill it had to be said.


Because Bill is my friend when I saw this thread I felt a lump in my belly, as a marketer I feel Bill has made a mistake here, I could have said my opinion privtely or publically, I opted to go public with my opinion. because Bill has thick enough skin to handle constructive criticism. He has 2 goals, #1 are his kids and religeous beliefs, #2 make $$ enjoying what he does. He has no intent to mislead anyone or harm anyone, I have handed him 6 figure's of "Poles" on a hand shake and am not worried about him moving to Haiti or Zimbabwe and stiffing me.

He just wants to differenciate himself from other cue dealers, Since I spen about $1,000,000 on cues last year you can be sure that damn near every cue dealer has found me, if they havent they really need help. I was reluctant to say how much I spent because it might upset someone that i'm showing off, I said it because I want people to understand that what you own dosent make you an expert. Back to marketing cues-I have seen alot of guys with different angles trying to sell me cues, I got 3 calls on one cue in houstan with in 15 minutes from 3 guys-they 2 said they owned the cue, the other guy didnt. That was Bill. I like that.

What Bill is doing is trying to seperate himself from the other cue dealers in his own way. However this idea is not good, I have known of the general plan for months, he asked me to keep it private so I did, its funny when peopl know you have $$$ and dont talk they tell you everything, thus I know more than I should about things in pool and cues, i just dont betray anyone who trusts me, but back to bill, yes I know I'm talking about myself to much right now but i'm in a shit mood sorry. Bills intentions are good, but labeling cue makers and putting a number on them is a poor choice to get to where Bill wants to go-something he didnt disclose yet.


He ran this idea up the flag poll and it dosent look good, since the sites arnt up, he asked for opinions so i'm making mine public:


Bill use price points as the criteria for the different linked sites, not your, mine or public opinion of the top 15-20-34 etc best elite cue makers, no matter what you do your gonna piss off someone, no matter what. "How not to piss off people is on page 23" in the "How to be a Great Marketer" book-its on Amazon.com ;) . Using price points is the way to do it(seperatiting your product line)., retailers do it all the time, Old Navy(shit cloths) is owned by "Gap" (better cloths) and "Banana Republic" is their top label. this way no one gets pissed, differintating your cue makers is fie but let the pricing do the job its simpler and no one gets pissed, how would cue maker #16 feel getting bumped off the "Big" site??? Bad plan never piss anyone off. take the worst of it before pissing anyone off.


If you want to rank cue makers which is a great idea put a on going poll with one time voting allowed and lets all see it in a year who is 1-15, Gus is my vote. you'll have people come back from time to time to see the results yielding more traffic to your site. after 1000's votes, it will make your site interactive, and the popular public opinion wont piss off anyone. its 2:45 AM and that's the best idea I can come up with, but having you determine who's best will look like the fix is in-meaning you'll tout which cue maker will make you the most $$$, I know you wouldnt do that but it looks bad as not many people know you like I do.


This poll idea keeps people comming back-and thats a good thing, and it will lead to other ideas for things to vote on and in a few years we will all see the publics opinions on cues and the trends of certain makers, now that has credibility and buyers insight if they are buying spectutivly with the intent odf profiting another type of customer, and gives you a nuetral position and more traffic(does it get any better your the good guy with lots of site traffic), it takes 15 minutes to sell a Sugartree and forever other cues in some cases(think Camalot), but a series of polls over time would benefit everyone,

There is room for all cue dealers in the market. Eduicating customes will keep them loyal, ranking cuemakers just pisses off the wrong people. Its all in how you package it-your style of marketing(since I bought a few cues this year I have seen some good marketing and some that was weak) he who sells the most cues wins, but ranking 15 makers aint the way foward, let the public decide, then you'll have some juice and more respect-its impossible to have too much of that, i'm not suggesting your not well respected, quite the obvious your well respected but labeling cue makers you will lose respect and thats worse than loseing $$.

I would never get into being a broker but I would be good at it<---shut up fatboy!!! you talk about yourself to much. :D :D :D Bt I know I would, man would that piss some people off, :cool: :D

i'm going to bed, best of luck to everyone. I came up with this idea as I was typing, if I give it more thought I could tweak it and make it better. business was my natural born talent-it sure as hell wasnt pool.

Bill call me to discuss -please. I only want the best for you and all cue brokers, makers, the whole industry, were comming into some tough times, you aint seen shit on how bad its gonna get, beating each other up is just going to harm everyone in the long run.

BTW anyone hireing I need a job.
 
Last edited:
junksecret said:
I agree that he asked for opinions, but I think he was after opinions about his site, not attacks on his character. I must confess I have done zero business with Cornerstone but I have visited his site and found many of his cues to be from *my* elite list so his opinion holds some weight with *me*.

I respect everyone's right to an opinion, I however felt the attack was a little "off-topic" since I never heard them claim to be "experts", perhaps I should re-read the thread. In any event your opinion has now been recorded in my brain and will carry whatever weight my small brain assigns to it, and for that I thank you.

Joe
first page of the thread Joe. I gave an opinion about this idea. Read a little closer. Bill and I have gone a few rounds before on AZ and based on his ego and some of his past remarks my "attack" may not be so unwarranted.

But its true. Bill has a lot of nice cues on his site and showcases a lot at the shows. Are they all his or are the a mix of consignment cues and other people's collections?

-B <-------- knows the answer to that already.
 
Hey Bill,

Keep up the good work...good or bad marketing is still marketing. Everyone here seem to be right that they are expressing their own opinion and they are just that good or bad. I would suggest that you take what will work for you and build upon the vision you already have for your site. Seeking confirmation sometime doesn't alway work, especially if you already have a plan. Keep with it and see how it will turn out...if it does not work than change it.

Does it really matter if bill own the cues or not? He has them up and if he able to sell good for everyone involved.

Just my own opinion, the subject of elite cuebuilders will be determine by collectors and basically demand for the cues in the market place. Having sold so many high end cues and a very good understanding of the cue market does make BILL an authority on cues in his own right. If you buy and sell cue, you have to know the cue market...you don't need to know how the cue is built but maybe the different construction methodologies and details. Having knowledge on cue building doesn't make anyone an expert in the cue market.

I think Bill move enough high end cues that he would qualify as an expert in the cue industry. His choice for 15 top elite builders again may be subjective but I'm sure it will be based on alot of sound criteria. But it's not like this categories are fixed...they will be changing with the market. I would consider Eric Crisp cue up there just based on the demand of his cue.....imagine a super high end cue from Eric like some of the exotic Arthur cue???

All in all, I'm looking forward to Bill site. I would agree that he should have a centralize site with all the builders on there even if they are going to be hosted on different site. Cornerstone cue is a really good domain and I think there are many that check on this site on a regular basis including myself. Bill you should consider having all the builders name on your site...that way you can have the public vote or decide which categories they should belong too base on # of cues produces, prices, experiences, etc... It's very easy to build a voting system.....would make you site a fun interactive site for buyers and potential buyer. I would also tied a CRM system in behind the scene so that you'll be able keep track of all your client and have a better understanding of their buyer behavour. If you see someone coming back to you site to look for a certain type of cues, you'll be in a good position to source for them. Just my opinion..take only what will work for you.

Good luck. Can't wait to see new cues from you.

Regards,
Duc.
 
Last edited:
On balance, what Bill does is good for people who have an interest in custom cues - from the makers to the buyers and everybody in between. This is something that should be taken into consideration before commenting on Bill and what he does / is trying to do.
 
Fatboy said:
Because Bill is my friend when I saw this thread I felt a lump in my belly, as a marketer I feel Bill has made a mistake here, I could have said my opinion privtely or publically, I opted to go public with my opinion.
because Bill has thick enough skin to handle constructive criticism.

but having you determine who's best will look like the fix is in-meaning you'll tout which cue maker will make you the most $$$, I know you wouldnt do that but it looks bad as not many people know you like I do.

Eduicating customes will keep them loyal, ranking cuemakers just pisses off the wrong people.
Bill call me to discuss -please. I only want the best for you

Well, my opinion is this is great advice. Im not sure what is your goal in creating an elite 15 cuemakers. I feel it is no accident why there are some people that have voiced the same concern over what you are plannig on doing. If they are willing to give feeback, could it mean that they actually care? ;) imho i agree with buddha162, FAST_N_LOOSE and pharaoh68 in saying that it would be misleading. i would also like you to consider the possibility of your idea doing more harm to you and the general public than good.

What i would suggest is that first post by these guys were opinions not knocking your character, rather voicing their concerns about the idea of setting up the elite class.

Its good to be right, almost everyone likes to enjoy only taking in feedback that reinforces your belief that your idea is the best. im merely suggesting the you look at the possibility that you might actually create a misleading experience for quite a few people. by shutting off feedback you do not like to hear, you will always be right but is that the most important thing to you, getting acknowledgement that your idea is the best? ;)

just my 2 cents worth.
 
Bill it's always a mistake to ask for "OPINIONS" on AZ. Keep the cues coming, it's only going to get better.
 
I just want to know

How you are going to classify the cuemaker that sells cues for $5,000 and up, but they hit like a $200 cue, and

The cuemaker that makes a $600 cue that plays like a $2,000 cue.

You see, I am a bargain shopper (I come by it honestly from my Mom), and I would much rather have the $600 cue rather than the $5,000 cue. Everyone likes to feel that they got their money's worth or better.
 
Bill:

As you were looking for feedback here's mine. There is language that is divisive and as we can see from this thread, the computer age can compound that divisiveness when our words are dissected and analyzed in black and white without the privilege of hearing the voices of those we are in contact with. As a professing Christian just look no further than the Bible to see how we use words to divide ourselves with all of the differing churches viewpoints. Anyway my point is this.... find the language that doesn't offend or especially harm others. I am sure you can find the words to differentiate the sites w/o causing harm to any of the great cue makers you deal with.

Obviously you will use the methods you need to in order to keep your business viable. I think the anger expressed here in some of the responses are just the tip of the iceburg, as many collectors, cue makers, and connoisseurs of cues may feel harmed by the classifications if they don't follow their own. It's a paradigm thing, just think if you had $ invested in x maker and someone didn't promote x maker as being the best but y maker instead, you may feel wronged. Those perceptions can cause anger, and why anger any of the potential clients, suppliers, etc.

Some of the best responses that I have to agree with are based on categorizing by price...maybe called "High Ticket cues" or something to that effect. Then the cue makers can offer cues in each category based on their business plan and it doesn't tick anyone off.

The word "elite" doesn't have to mean elitist, but it does to many. In the angry world that we seem to be coming to why go there. It's not the way of a faith based business. JMHO

I hope I can get to your store the next time I travel in Mich. if it is open to the public. I love nice cues! :D And if I hit the lottery, maybe I'll buy a FEW. Feel free to contact me offline if you wish.

td
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top