I'll admit that I don't like handicapping either. I understand that you attract more ppl with handicapping, so I guess you could say that I do support it.
I'm not sure when handicapping became the norm, but it seems relatively new. When I first started playing in the 90's all the tournaments were either open, or they were A or B & C tournaments. All regional tournaments were open. It was the local tourneys that were A or BC and personally I'd rather it go back to that.
I will save him the trouble. He thinks pro pool is what makes pool as a whole popular, because the strongest players are what draw everyone to play pool to begin with. He also thinks leagues keep people from becoming super strong players, and therefore leagues are the cause for the lack of super strong and pro players, which in turn is what is keeping pool down because it is only the super strong players that draw the people in and make pool popular.
He also thinks that any two things that happen at the same time have to be related, even if the things are completely unrelated, because coincidence doesn't exist. He thinks leagues have been gaining in popularity over the years, while the rest of pool has been declining over the years, and therefore leagues have to be the cause of pool's decline since they are both happening at the same time, and all things happening at the same time are always related.
Yes I know there are some leaps of logic in there, but those were his basic arguments.
Leagues are the worst thing that ever happened to pool. I agree they are a business and should do their best to make as much as possible though. I think they ended pool in America though. Either that, or the timing of all the good players disappearing in relation to when leagues popped up is certainly a huge coincidence.
I'm a 1 and I'm going to win the tournament!They best I remember was an apa 2 crying to me that the 2s never win the 2-7sl bar tourney using apa races so it was not fair.On what planet should a 2 win a tourney ever?
I cant tell you how many times I take 2s and 3s aside and tell them "if we work on this or that we can get you to a 4 or 5 by next year easy " and they reply how they like where they are and dont want to get moved up and HAVE to play better.The league mentallity sucks.
Dont know why people are so against handicapped leagues. Handicapping has been around forever. Very few people play even up when gambling. Heck even pros spot each other in a match.
all i ever read on here is how much of a spot an a player should give a b or c player in a match. . A spot in a gambling match is nothing but a handicap. why should a bunch of amateur players be looked down upon for playing under a handicapped format in a league ? It's the same situation in my book.
I think "completely ridiculous" is a little over-the-top. You are entitled to your opinion, which I respect, but people have always, and will always bet on any form of competition. That is the nature of the beast. And some players cannot get their heads in the game unless something is on the line. It could be money, dinner, drinks or whatever. Some people like to walk away with a prize, it's that simple.And I have always felt that betting on pool is completely ridiculous. I don't need to put money on the table to prove anything or play my best. I enjoy playing the game. I know I am in the minority and that's fine.
Gambling and leagues are completely different.
Does the APA do anything to help a player want to get better? If I'm a 5, and every year my team does well, and we win money. Why wouldn't I just continue to play just well enough to remain a 5?
What incentive is there for me to get better and raise my SL?
I cant tell you how many times I take 2s and 3s aside and tell them "if we work on this or that we can get you to a 4 or 5 by next year easy " and they reply how they like where they are and dont want to get moved up and HAVE to play better.The league mentallity sucks.
If I play bad, I feel like crap no matter if I lost $100 doing it or if I made a mistake on my home table alone. You can learn the same thing watching some pool videos as you would giving your money to a pro to rack for them while they run out, unless you actually got lessons for your money.
Great post :thumbup:Another thread where one side (gamblers) are adamant is the only way to make you better, or to make it enjoyable. Like the non LD folks versus the LD folks. The LD folks don't mind or complain about the non LD folks, ever.
I've played baseball for 40 years and NEVER had to bet a nickel to run into a fence, or take a fastball in the back to get a free base. You played to win no matter what.
I think folks like Lou just don't enjoy the game enough to play for "free". I love the game, I love practicing in my basement against the ghost. Some folks just have that, and that's OK. But, they don't understand the rest of us.
Yeah, I can play for fun or a few bucks.... but I only play for a few bucks because the other guy can't play for fun and $10 per game is the same as "funsie" to me. I spend more than that for lunch ever day.
If I lose $50 or $100, I would not even notice it gone from the wallet, but the other guy would. But, I guarantee I'm trying just as hard or harder, cause you only play to win. Most folks don't know any other way.
Maybe these "pool gamblers" don't have the same commitment to win no matter what unless they are getting paid and don't understand others can play "balls to the wall' every time no matter what.
I hope I never play pool only for money because the game became so boring and the only thrill is to win a few bucks. If that's the case, there has got to be better way to make a few bucks for your time, no? I'd just quit pool at that point and donate more time at the local animal shelter.
I think you can learn from watching videos AND from getting beat to death by a great player. You are just learning different things. When I watch pool, I like to see how these better players play patterns, that's what I learn from videos. When I play a better player, I learn how to deal with pressure that I cannot get from the video. Pressure makes people do funny things.
Yes, the mental part you can't learn without experience, but in some cases you can't learn it at all no matter how much you try, your brain just does not want to listen to you. Learning things like how to meditate, calm your body, breathing, even something like Yoga or martial arts can help you mentally. I am betting Buddhist monks would make some killer pool players if they picked up playing.
Another thread where one side (gamblers) are adamant is the only way to make you better, or to make it enjoyable. Like the non LD folks versus the LD folks. The LD folks don't mind or complain about the non LD folks, ever.
I've played baseball for 40 years and NEVER had to bet a nickel to run into a fence, or take a fastball in the back to get a free base. You played to win no matter what.
I think folks like Lou just don't enjoy the game enough to play for "free". I love the game, I love practicing in my basement against the ghost. Some folks just don't have that, and that's OK. But, they don't understand the rest of us.
Yeah, I can play for fun or a few bucks.... but I only play for a few bucks because the other guy can't play for fun and $10 per game is the same as "funsie" to me. I spend more than that for lunch ever day.
If I lose $50 or $100, I would not even notice it gone from the wallet, but the other guy would. But, I guarantee I'm trying just as hard or harder, cause you only play to win. Most folks don't know any other way.
Maybe these "pool gamblers" don't have the same commitment to win no matter what unless they are getting paid and don't understand others can play "balls to the wall' every time no matter what.
I hope I never play pool only for money because the game became so boring and the only thrill is to win a few bucks. If that's the case, there has got to be better way to make a few bucks for your time, no? I'd just quit pool at that point and donate more time at the local animal shelter.
Who says they don't.Yes, the mental part you can't learn without experience, but in some cases you can't learn it at all no matter how much you try, your brain just does not want to listen to you. Learning things like how to meditate, calm your body, breathing, even something like Yoga or martial arts can help you mentally.
I am betting Buddhist monks would make some killer pool players if they picked up playing.
I think folks like Lou just don't enjoy the game enough to play for "free".