Why? Hard question for me. Complicated.
I am not really a collector I think, I am a gatherer of knowledge and history. I love true custom cues but I only have a couple or three. Then I have a number of old production cues, 1970's and older. Everything from Adam, to Rich, to Sampaio, Brunswick, and Katz...all the way up to an ivory joint 100 year old Brunswick. Then there are the dirty little secrets...the Ugly Betty cues...the Cobras and Mizeraks. LOL! Yeah. And finally I have a number that are "rescue" cues. They need work. They wait. They need a refinish or a joint pin or a shaft or a wrap or in some cases probably a funeral fire.
I really want old cues from big name makers and truly rare or valuable cues. I dream of it. I have had the money and failed to ever pull the trigger. I don't know why I am afraid to. Instead I bought a lot of "junk".
I also want to have a cue made. I have a double butterfly I want converted. Even talked to a HOF cue maker. Have not pulled the trigger. I also want to have a four point made "from scratch" in an old school style. But again, have not pulled the trigger. There is a fear in me of pulling the trigger and I don't know why.
I don't know why I gather. Just fun? No, it's more than that.
I am a history buff, information junkie, obsessive student of everything, and I have a very strange mind. I have synesthesia so I think of and remember things differently than most folks. The best way to describe it is that I see things in colorful abstract pictures and timelines but in a strange 3D way where I can zoom in and out on everything and everything is categorized. For some reason old cues fit into this well and are really fun to play with in my mind. I can remember things in the smallest detail and connect things together in spooky ways that others will not see, so I can group cues together in my mind by very minor features and details, which makes me pretty decent at identifying obscure cues, even cheap Taiwan ones because they are etched in my mind just as much as any others. I don't do it on purpose, it's the way my mind works.
I guess I only really want or need one or two that are great players. The rest are conversation pieces, historical pieces, novelty pieces, matters of intellectual stimulation. My players are my block letter JOSS and my 1981 Huebler. Damn hard to beat either one of those with more money or technology actually. I even traded a beautiful Predator for an old 70's McDermott (perfect condition) and It's George case. Why? The Predator was not interesting and there was no magic in it, functionally it couldn't do anything better than my JOSS just different. I am sure the other party in that trade thinks he got the better deal, but I know otherwise. There is magic in the McDermott and it has an original brown McDermott bumper.
So, why gather cues? For me personally, I think it's a sign of a personality defect. But I do love cues.
I estimate I have about 85 cues.

And then there are the cases.....:grin:
.