I was at the Derby maybe the 1st or 2nd year it was held in Elizabeth IN. There was an ice storm, everything was coated with ice, roads, trees, sidewalks. They don’t have any salt there and it took a few days to get cleaned up. Very dangerous conditions.
My thoughts on this are that it matters not one iota. Shot success depends solely on speed of the cue tip at impact, direction of the cue tip at impact, and precise placement of the cue tip on the cue ball.
Now, what DOES matter is the stroke. A smooth stroke, with good timing, good acceleration, good tip placement, and sending the cue tip exactly down the intended shot line, is much more conducive to successfully incorporating all these things into every shot consistently.
I agree with everything else you said except that the question doesn't matter, for me it's an interesting question mostly due to the fact that many people (in my experience, mostly mid-level players but also some 600-700 fargo ones) tend to believe the opposite of what I am claiming.
My thoughts on this are that it matters not one iota. Shot success depends solely on speed of the cue tip at impact, direction of the cue tip at impact, and precise placement of the cue tip on the cue ball.
Now, what DOES matter is the stroke. A smooth stroke, with good timing, good acceleration, good tip placement, and sending the cue tip exactly down the intended shot line, is much more conducive to successfully incorporating all these things into every shot consistently.