Myth or real - Stroke smoothness as a requisite for certain shots

I'm having an ongoing argument with a friend about tip/ball contact.

He refuses to acknowledge that different stroke types - as in a smooth stroke that accelerates through the ball, versus a jab that pulls away as soon as possible post result in different outcomes.

He claims the only influence on what happens is the motion at impact.
I like to visualize it from the cue ball's perspective: The CB can only "feel" the Angle, Spot and Speed of the tip's impact - all the hard earned stroke mastery that we put into delivering that millisecond of contact is sadly lost on it (fortunately, ASS is all it needs).

He claims the only influence on what happens is the motion at impact.
I agree with him that only the impact itself has direct influence on the CB, and also recognize the knowledge and technique needed to deliver it.

pj
chgo

Filter

Back
Top