Challenge the table

I play in Lafayette most of the time. I'm just a bar player, not a gambler. I could never get into as I never had money.

I used to get off the sled to eat at Mulatte's or Las's and then hit the two lanes. Breaux Bridge south and west was prime territory back then. Dropping below Lafayette was good too. South and maybe fifty miles or so west was all sweet. I didn't go north as much but I would think Opelousas and Ville Platte would still hold a place or two. Last I knew Tee Neg's was still on the bayou but under a more PC name I have long forgotten.

Tee Neg's reminds me. I bet you could drift through all the little towns on the way to Grand Isle and make a killing on a holiday weekend.

Ah well, been too long. Most of my old haunts are gone and I have gotten old! I would like to spend some time in the area just for old times sake but white hair and having to quit drinking beer makes it hard to move. The challenge tables are for entertainment and you need to look like you are mostly in a bar to drink. You know that of course but it negatively impacts me. Even back when I would buy a beer when I came in a place and throw it away largely untouched.

Hu

Qatar World Cup 10-Ball 2026

Counting the CSI US Opens as majors is hilarious. None of them are and, frankly, it has probably been a few years since anyone on this forum tried to suggest otherwise. Some of the CSI US Opens have had fields of less than 20 and very few of them have deep, international fields. I'd say one Euro-tour title is worth three CSI US Open titles. That gives Ralf Souquet the equivalent of 69 US Opens. Of course, that's nonsense, too. Shane has five US Opens, and all of them were against fields weaker and less internationally balanced than what we've seen in this decade of pro pool.

Yes, it's a matter of opinion, but Shane has never dominated across the world. Yes, he dominated on American soil against fields that were chiefly American, but his track record is much poorer when competing against large, internationally diverse fields worldwide. Filler's resume at age 29 already eclipses that of Shane at 43. Title count? Who cares. When discussing greatness, it is major title count that matters, because performance against elite fields is the only real measure. Filler's rate of winning major championships all over the globe is so much greater than that of Shane that the comparison borders on silly.

Is Shane's 5 US Opens 9ball, 1 World 9ball, 1 World 8ball any stronger than Filler's 1 US Open 9ball, 1 World 9ball, 3 China Open 9ball, 1 World Games 9ball gold medal, and 1 World 8ball? That's pretty close, but if you look at all the other majors, Filler has won everything in sight and Shane hasn't won anything close to that. Finally, as Shane has noted, Filler has worn him out in head-to-head play for the length of Josh' career.

Of course, you are allowed to size it up as you please. Thanks for sharing your views.
So if size of the field and level of competition matter, how can mosconi and Greenleaf be in your top 5?
Counting the CSI US Opens as majors is hilarious. None of them are and, frankly, it has probably been a few years since anyone on this forum tried to suggest otherwise. Some of the CSI US Opens have had fields of less than 20 and very few of them have deep, international fields. I'd say one Euro-tour title is worth three CSI US Open titles. That gives Ralf Souquet the equivalent of 69 US Opens. Of course, that's nonsense, too. Shane has five US Opens, and all of them were against fields weaker and less internationally balanced than what we've seen in this decade of pro pool.

Yes, it's a matter of opinion, but Shane has never dominated across the world. Yes, he dominated on American soil against fields that were chiefly American, but his track record is much poorer when competing against large, internationally diverse fields worldwide. Filler's resume at age 29 already eclipses that of Shane at 43. Title count? Who cares. When discussing greatness, it is major title count that matters, because performance against elite fields is the only real measure. Filler's rate of winning major championships all over the globe is so much greater than that of Shane that the comparison borders on silly.

Is Shane's 5 US Opens 9ball, 1 World 9ball, 1 World 8ball any stronger than Filler's 1 US Open 9ball, 1 World 9ball, 3 China Open 9ball, 1 World Games 9ball gold medal, and 1 World 8ball? That's pretty close, but if you look at all the other majors, Filler has won everything in sight and Shane hasn't won anything close to that. Finally, as Shane has noted, Filler has worn him out in head-to-head play for the length of Josh' career.

Of course, you are allowed to size it up as you please. Thanks for sharing your views.
You dismiss Shane’s CSI US open wins, but hold Willie mosconi”s championship in high regard even though the field at times only had 8 players? Ralph Greenleaf won most of his titles by winning head to head challenge matches! I think I’d take Shane’s us open with fields with at least 100 players holds more merit than Ralph’s titles

Filter

Back
Top