Challenge the table

Not many bar tables in my area if any left, and if there are, they are most likely 6ft English pool tables in bad conditions and aren't in the kind of placed I would go to these days....

Although I prefer to shoot on a decent 9ft table with a solid player and just pay by the hour, the fun bar games were a lot of fun, especially if you're on a winning streak and stay on the table for an hour or two... I miss those night back in the 90s when I lived in NYC. And although I'm not a gambler, I would take a game playing for a drink, I got to drink a lot for free playing pool and darts...

Qatar World Cup 10-Ball 2026

Fully admiting that I am a Filler fan and knowing that it sounds rude:
There was a time when the best American Pool Player was the best pool player of the world. But these times seem to be over. Just because SVB dominated the American pool players in the past doesn't show his superiourity right now any more. Quite a few European pool players are on his level and rising, where Shane is most likely at his peak or even past it. And we have a high number of Asian players lurking in the dark that might be even stronger.

Efren is Efren and Earl was brilliant. But when I watch the old videos, those guys made mistakes in nearly every other rack. Nowadays - that will sort you out in round 2 or 3 of a tournament like the Quatar World Cup.

My point is that the greatness of a player is highly linked to the ammount of dominace over the competition. And competition was high in Quatar. And competition will be high in future events like this. And I am not sure if our idols of the past would be able to repeat their success story against the present stiff competition.

Efren is/was the "Magician", but you don't need so much magic, if you play every position with surgical precision. ..... like Filler, when he is in stroke.

Just my humble opinion.

Gerhard
A solid, well-reasoned, post, but I'd like to offer that there are other considerations when it comes to Efren and Earl.

Efren's efforts are legendary, in part, because he advanced the science of the game. No idea how old you are, but when Efren came to America, he was employing some shots and strategies never seen before. He introduced us to many of the shots that would gradually enter the arsenals of most of the top players. Kick shots, 2-way sots, safeties --- Efren seemed to know shots that nobody else knew. At 9ball, but even more so at 1-pocket, he got everybody thinking differently about how the game can and should be played. Efren's greatness is partly tied to his performance and partly tied to his groundbreaking style of play, which integrated billiard knowledge into pool in a new way. His imagination set the stage for greater development of the theory underlying the game. Another amazing thing about Efren is the speed at which he learned and mastered new games. He had never played straight pool but tried his hand at the 1993 World 14.1 championships and medaled. He had never focused on 8ball, but when the IPT came along in 2006, he won the biggest prize ever paid in 8ball, which was $500,000. He had never tried one pocket until he learned much of it from, among others, Billy Incardona and Fred Bentivegna, and it wasn't long before, in Billy's words, he clearly understood things that even they didn't. He went on to be the greatest ever one-pocket player.

Earl's legend is another matter. Though it was played before, 9ball only became a major competitive discipline in 1976. For most of us, Earl came onto our radar in 1980 as a 19-year-old. He offered a brand of 9ball never seen before, a game based more on power than anything else. He was, unquestionably, the first to ever master the nine-ball break, and because of it, he sat opponents down for racks at a time more than anyone that came before him. It gave him a top gear that nobody could match. He was known for often dismissing the greatest of champions by very lopsided scores in competition. In short, Earl can be credited with ushering in the era of power 9ball that is still going strong.

Hence, it is true that if you watch old footage of Earl at 9ball, you will probably not think he played like the current edition of Filler, and I won't disagree. Similarly, if you watched footage of Efren at 1-pocket, you'd wonder whether he'd have beaten modern day Shane, Gorst or Filler at one pocket. I'd suggest, however, that a wider lens is needed to made these kinds of assessments. Earl and Efren were foundational players that introdcued a new type of pool to us, and part of their greatness is tied to having done so.

Just some food for thought.

Challenge the table

I can't find an old fashioned bar game near me anymore. Growing up in the 80s I could go into a bar, drop .50 on the table and get a good game. Now days I have to drive to a small town to get those type of games. I walk in to a lounge any day of the week.....tables taken either by league nights, or tournaments. If I stick around long enough, a table will open up around 2 hours after getting there. Pool halls near me rent tables by the hour, although one has quarters. The quarter tables are usually stacked full. I play in a city with 123k population. I was just wondering if anyone else misses the old days where people would play strangers any day of the week.
*I can drive back to my home town and hour a way and get a game sometimes.*
Nothing like a good bar challenge table. $1 or a draft per game.

Sadly, you won't find many of those down here...

Question about "Carbon Magic" polish for carbon fiber shafts

Hi all,

Just curious if any of you folks have tried this product: https://www.halcyoncues.com/products/carbon-magic-polish

It seems to be some sort of paste that you can use to clean carbon fiber shafts, and according to the company's website, it also removes white spots and makes the color of the shafts darker. That sounds like marketing hype and not sure how a cleaner could darken a shaft (and if it can, could it potentially damage the finish?). It seems to be sold on Amazon, as well as the company's website.

If anyone has tried the product, I'd be very interested in what you thought of it. Thanks in advance for any information you can provide!!
1793388269348.png

F/S MEZZ EC9

here’s a really impressive Mezz EC9 wrapless cue with an Expro + extension for anyone seeking a genuine player, particularly at a price that won’t empty your wallet—$1150 gets you this new Mezz cue

19oz 12.5mm 😉👍

Attachments

  • IMG_8722.jpeg
    IMG_8722.jpeg
    428.1 KB · Views: 108
  • IMG_8716.jpeg
    IMG_8716.jpeg
    344.3 KB · Views: 100
  • IMG_8718.jpeg
    IMG_8718.jpeg
    465.2 KB · Views: 95
  • IMG_8720.jpeg
    IMG_8720.jpeg
    261.9 KB · Views: 93
  • IMG_8721.jpeg
    IMG_8721.jpeg
    400.7 KB · Views: 94
  • IMG_8719.jpeg
    IMG_8719.jpeg
    321.3 KB · Views: 101

Challenge the table

I can't find an old fashioned bar game near me anymore. Growing up in the 80s I could go into a bar, drop .50 on the table and get a good game. Now days I have to drive to a small town to get those type of games. I walk in to a lounge any day of the week.....tables taken either by league nights, or tournaments. If I stick around long enough, a table will open up around 2 hours after getting there. Pool halls near me rent tables by the hour, although one has quarters. The quarter tables are usually stacked full. I play in a city with 123k population. I was just wondering if anyone else misses the old days where people would play strangers any day of the week.
*I can drive back to my home town an hour a way and get a game sometimes.*

Qatar World Cup 10-Ball 2026

I respect your opinion and knowledge but I disagree. Shane is a 20 time us open champion, a two time world champion, has over 100 professional tournament wins in every discipline that pool has to offer. No disrespect to Willie or Raph, but when they won their championships the fields were with around 8-16 players. For what its worth Francisco Bustamante when asked who the GOAT was he named Shane. At the end of the day it’s all a Matter of opinion.
Counting the CSI US Opens as majors is hilarious. None of them are and, frankly, it has probably been a few years since anyone on this forum tried to suggest otherwise. Some of the CSI US Opens have had fields of less than 20 and very few of them have deep, international fields. I'd say one Euro-tour title is worth three CSI US Open titles. That gives Ralf Souquet the equivalent of 69 US Opens. Of course, that's nonsense, too. Shane has five US Opens, and all of them were against fields weaker and less internationally balanced than what we've seen in this decade of pro pool.

Yes, it's a matter of opinion, but Shane has never dominated across the world. Yes, he dominated on American soil against fields that were chiefly American, but his track record is much poorer when competing against large, internationally diverse fields worldwide. Filler's resume at age 29 already eclipses that of Shane at 43. Title count? Who cares. When discussing greatness, it is major title count that matters, because performance against elite fields is the only real measure. Filler's rate of winning major championships all over the globe is so much greater than that of Shane that the comparison borders on silly.

Is Shane's 5 US Opens 9ball, 1 World 9ball, 1 World 8ball any stronger than Filler's 1 US Open 9ball, 1 World 9ball, 3 China Open 9ball, 1 World Games 9ball gold medal, and 1 World 8ball? That's pretty close, but if you look at all the other majors, Filler has won everything in sight and Shane hasn't won anything close to that. Finally, as Shane has noted, Filler has worn him out in head-to-head play for the length of Josh' career.

Of course, you are allowed to size it up as you please. Thanks for sharing your views.

Filter

Back
Top