Nice post!
As you note, action pool has no relevance to this discussion. Greatness is measured in titles, and not in minor ones but major ones. Noone ever got into the BCA Hall of Fame based on their record in action pool, and action pool is rarely, if ever, mentioned in hall of fame proceedings. It's why the great Parica wasn't inducted until he was 65 --- his tournament record was good but not on the level of so many who get inducted.
Back to tournaments. Earl's record is phenomenal. In a recent thread about best ever nine ball players, I had Filler, Sigel and Earl as my top three, so we are pretty much on the same page here. Comparing them to each other is not so simple, and I respect your choice to place Earl above the other two He was an incredibly special player, and like Josh, he had a way of scoring a lot of blowout wins in event finals. I've often posted that Filler's countless moments of dominance bring to mind prime Earl Strickland. Nobody could beat him when Earl found his highest gear in the 1990s, and nobody can beat Filler when he finds his highest gear this decade.
That said, pro pool is much more than the World 9ball and the US Open 9ball, and Filler's resume, in which he has countless major titles all over the globe against the killer fields of this generation, merits great respect. Most of Earl's major titles (Sigel's, too) came when the fields were 90% American and when nearly all the majors were all played in America, and that must also be factored in.
Thanks for sharing your opinion here. It's always fun to compare notes with someone who has sweated decades of pool like me.
PS I think the debate about whether all games should be considered in the greatness equation is a debate for the ages. It's a quesiton that the members of AZB have often struggled with.